U.S. May Veto Islamic Law in Iraq

Paul Bremer has apparently weighed in against Sharia in Iraq. From AP:

The top U.S. administrator in Iraq suggested Monday he would block any interim constitution that would make Islam the chief source of law, as some members of the Iraqi Governing Council have sought.

L. Paul Bremer said the current draft of the constitution would make Islam the state religion of Iraq and "a source of inspiration for the law" — as opposed to the main source.

Many Iraqi women have expressed fears that the rights they hold under Iraq's longtime secular system would be rolled back in the interim constitution being written by U.S.-picked Iraqi leaders and their advisers, many of them Americans. U.S. lawmakers have urged the White House to prevent Islamic restrictions on Iraqi women.

Asked what would happen if Iraqi leaders wrote into the constitution that Islamic sharia law is the principal basis of the law, Bremer suggested he would wield his veto. "Our position is clear. It can't be law until I sign it," he said.

Bremer must sign into law all measures passed by the 25-member council, including the interim constitution. Iraq's powerful Shiite clergy, however, has demanded the document be approved by an elected legislature. Under U.S. plans, a permanent constitution would not be drawn up and voted on until 2005.

Bremer used the inauguration ceremony at a women's center in the southern city of Karbala to argue for more than "token" women's representation in the transitional government due to take power June 30.

"I think it is very important that women be represented in all the political bodies," Bremer said.

"Women are the majority in this country, in this area probably a substantial majority," he said, referring to the Saddam Hussein's 1991 purges of Shiite Muslim men. Those killings left the holy city of Karbala and other Shiite cities dotted with mass graves and brimming with thousands of widows.

Bremer and an entourage of reporters flew from Baghdad into this Shiite holy city in a pair of U.S. Army Black Hawk helicopters. He toured a women's center renovated by U.S. and seized Iraqi funds, pausing to chat with women and girls who were sewing curtains and surfing the Internet.

In a speech to about 100 women — most dressed in flowing black abayas and some with tattooed chins — Bremer cited a 2003 United Nations report that found that productivity in Arab countries was being strangled because women had been kept out of the work force. Bremer suggested that women's participation did not run counter to Muslim values.

"Women who can read and write and understand mathematics are not prevented from being good mothers. Quite the opposite," Bremer told the gathering. "No son is better off because his mother and sisters cannot read."

Nawal Jabar, 44, whose husband was killed in the Iran-Iraq war in the 1980s, said she joined the women's center to learn a trade.

"Either my mother or my brother has supported me from time to time since my husband died," Jabar said. "It's a very bad situation. But I am hoping I can get a job here so that I can support my kids."

Enshrining women's rights in a constitution could be difficult. U.S. observers have predicted liberal reforms introduced in the transitional law could well be rolled back in a future constitution. Bremer acknowledged that U.S. influence on an Iraqi constitution would fade after the June 30 handover.

"There will be a sovereign government here in June. The Iraqis then will then have responsibility for their own country," Bremer said. "There's a real hunger for democracy in this country. It may not look like American democracy, but there's a real hunger for it and we're encouraging that."

There are three women on the Governing Council.

Mohsen Abdel-Hamid, the current council president and a member of a committee drafting the interim constitution, has proposed making Islamic sharia law the "principal basis" of legislation.

The phrasing could have broad effects on secular Iraq. In particular, it would likely make moot much of Iraq's 1959 Law of Personal Status, which grants uniform rights to husband and wife to divorce and inheritance, and governs related issues like child support.

Under most interpretations of Islamic law, women's rights to seek divorce are strictly limited and they only receive half the inheritance of men. Islamic law also allows for polygamy and often permits marriage of girls at a younger age than secular law.

In December, the council passed a decision abolishing the 1959 law and allowing each of the main religious groups to apply its own tradition — including Islamic law. Many Iraqi women expressed alarm at the decision, and Bremer has not signed it into law.

Earlier this month, 45 members of the U.S. House of Representatives signed a letter to President Bush urging him to preserve women's rights.

"It would be a tragedy beyond words if Iraqi women lost the rights they had under Saddam Hussein, especially when the purpose of our mission in Iraq was to make life better for the Iraqi people," the letter read.

| 8 Comments
Print | Email this entry | Digg this | del.icio.us |

8 Comments

If Sharia comes into effect, all minorities and the women of Iraq are lost. I hope that Bremer can pull this off.

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story_12-2-2004_pg7_8 No one has seen this ?
Dhaka protests killing of workers in Saudi Arabia

By Saleem Samad

DHAKA: Bangladesh has conveyed its protest to Riyadh about the reported killing of five Bangladeshi workers on Saudi soil and requested a thorough investigation into the incident.

Reportedly, an angry member of the Saudi royal family sprayed bullets on a number of foreign workers at a place 300 kilometres from Riyadh on February 4 when they were resting at a combination of picnic spots and agricultural farms. The firing left six people, five Bangladeshis and a Sudanese, dead. Later the killer burnt their bodies. The Saudi police rushed to the spot and arrested a man identified as a son of Abdullah bin Fahd, a member of the royal family. A week later, the bodies of the ill-fated workers still remain untraced, admitted officials at ministries of Foreign Affairs and Expatriate Welfare and Overseas Employment, reports an English daily the New Age.

Following newspaper reports quoting the victims’ co-workers in Saudi Arabia, the Saudi government has decided to give compensation of Taka 100,000 each to the families of the murdered Bangladeshis. “We’ve requested the Saudi government to find out why the killing occurred and inform us about the details,” said Mohammed Quamrul Islam, state minister for Expatriates Welfare and Overseas Employment.
So a Saudi Prince can kill the "low class" Bangladeshis with impunity and get away with it. The Saudi are the current "Master Race", these f... racists ! The surprising thing is you can't get this news using Google search. I wonder why ?

I found these stories, which may be about the same incident, using Google search:

Dhaka confirms death of 3 Bangladeshis in Riyadh
http://www.thedailystar.net/2004/02/11/d40211011212.htm

Pall of gloom at B'baria village
http://www.thedailystar.net/2004/02/12/d40212070386.htm

Either Bremer pulls it off or the US can hardly hope to bring any measure of freedom into Iraq. This is the least he must do to make all the sacrifices worthwhile.

Put it this way, If Bremmar doesn't pull this off, the USA might as well pack up and go home, rather than have any more American blood spilled for nothing. let them have a civil war, arm the kurds to the teeth and let them have at it. Then, when Iran steps in more the troops back in from Kwait and sock it to Iran.

What if we put it to the Iraqi people, including women, and 51% vote for Sharia? This is democracy. You may not like the outcome, but democracy within a Religion of Peace...is this not what we are fighting for?

If the followers of this ROP are allowed to leave like any real religion that four fifth of the world has come to expect of any religion then and only then the argument is valid.

im agrry about the islamic lor in iraq