Surprise US Fax Shakes German Terror Trial

Sami Al-Arian is not the only one who may walk -- he may soon be joined by the first man convicted of crimes related to 9/11. From Deutsche Welle, with thanks to Cathy J. Palmer:

The retrial of Mounir el Motassadeq takes an unexpected turn as the US releases testimony from an al Qaeda captive who says the suspect knew nothing of the attack plans. But prosecutors have their doubts.

The Hamburg higher adminstrative court hearing the retrial of the first man convicted in Germany of ties to the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks received a bombshell fax from the US Justice Department on Wednesday.

The fax contained summaries of three detainees' interrogations, including the testimony of Ramzi Binalshibh, the alleged mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks. Many observers have long believed that testimony from Binalshibh could provide the key to a final verdict in the case.

Only this time, it could help suspect Motassadeq rather than the prosecution.

According to the summary read out in the court room by presiding judge Ernst-Rainer Schudt, Motassadeq -- who is on trial for aiding the Hamburg-based Sept. 11 suicide pilots Mohammed Atta, Marwan al-Shehhi and Ziad Jarrah -- had no idea of the terrorist plot.

A blow for prosecutors?

"We have to think about the consequences of this," Schudt said.

After the surprising development on Wednesday, Motassadeq's defense attorneys -- who only one day earlier claimed any testimony from Binalshibh or Mohammed would be unreliable because they had likely been tortured or forced into giving testimony by US intelligence agents --seemed pleased with the apparently exculpatory evidence.

"I think it's going to result in an acquittal," said attorney Josef Grässle-Münscher.

| 38 Comments
Print | Email this entry | Digg this | del.icio.us |

38 Comments

Why dont we just stop the messing around and just give these people the key's to the nukes?

The last place on Earth that you would want Osama Bin laden to be tried would be in a Western Country...cause he would walk out on some technicality.

PC and apologists are infuriating enough......what a mockery our systems must seem in the eyes of these Vampires....no wonder they treat us with contempt.

Thats nice the Muslim-puke is going to be acquitted.

The Israelis know how to deal with these "sand maggots", they hunt them down and assasinate them.

The US needs some Special Opps that will eliminate these Islamo-bastards, after the pc liberal idiots turn them lose.

There's no accounting for stupidity. The Germans don't want to be seen as supporting the American line and, now, Germany and the rest of Europe, is infested. They are afraid of antagonizing the Muslims in the midst.

Stupidity is now rampant in the world.

Let's take another look at this initial report...

The Hamburg higher adminstrative court hearing the retrial of the first man convicted in Germany of ties to the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks received a bombshell fax from the US Justice Department on Wednesday.

The fax contained summaries of three detainees' interrogations, including the testimony of Ramzi Binalshibh, the alleged mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks. Many observers have long believed that testimony from Binalshibh could provide the key to a final verdict in the case.


...Bomshell fax? From the US Justice Department on Wednesday? Containing "summaries of three detainees interrogations?"

Of course these detainees would NEVER lie...So I have to wonder if certain work at certain government agencies have also been "outsourced" to certain companies that, staff certain al-qu...
no, I sure that could NEVER happen.

Its all a big, fat, happy coincidence thats all.

I find the response of the lawyer telling. He said just a day earlier that: " any testimony from Binalshibh or Mohammed would be unreliable because they had likely been tortured or forced into giving testimony by US intelligence agents". But now he is pleased with the result. So if it is incriminating to his client than it must be a result of torture and it must be discarded, but as long as they say what he and his client would like to hear, that is good evidence. How can you call this constructive deffence? How can anyone ever argue with people like that?

Germany, France, Spain and England have all been over run by the hordes of "third world" Islamo-fascists that have invaded these countries.

The politically correct left wing socialist and marxist scum have helped to facilitate this transmutation.

The European culture now appropriately called "Eurabia", will eventually be a memory of the past, as Islam takes it place.

Oh please no.... no.

Al-Aryan is going to walk? That makes me want to puke.

I was attending USF when he was "unfairly" punished. It was disgusting. Muslim kids and hippies would take every opportunity to whine and criticise, and make up the most outrageous bullsh*t. (The hippies are called "Moonbats" over at LGF.)

They said poor, old Dr. Death-to-Israel was a victim of a Zionist plot, that he was being deprived of his right to free speech, that he was being deprived of his academic freedom, that he was guilty of "thought crime", that he was a victim of "guilt by association", that the govt. of Israel was behind all of this, on an on and on.... ad absurdum.

They figured out that the University president was Jewish, and boy did they love that! More proof of the Zionist Conspiracy.

They protested hearings, they protested outside his jail cell, they carried banners and marched back and forth. They made bumper stickers, they held rallies.

Al-Aryan himself went on a "hunger strike" and proclaimed that he was a "prophet" who was being "martyred."

When he was arrested, his sextoy said that their family was "massacred" by the arrresting authorities.

National organizations of academics and pundits swooped down upon USF after they fired him, promising harsh censoring and angry rebukes if he wasn't reinstated at once, with full recompense for lost wages.

"Oh, the humanity" the hippies and a few teachers cried. Dozens of websites and school clubs (with always the same 50 or so Muslim kids and their pet hippies) sprung up, offering phony collegiate activities to support the jihad. Stuff like "Muslim Awareness Month" and "Palestinian Awareness Week."

I laughed through it all, because I knew that the FBI had a 50-count indictment against Al-Aryan, and that the indictments were based on taped phone conversations, and the they have been "fingerprinting" voices for decades. I used to laugh at my misguided fellow liberals and academics, and say "If just ONE charge sticks, he's going away for life."

I did feel bad for his poor, brainwashed children. But I happened to meet the youngest one (on campus at a dawah booth) and she told me that all of the Al Aryan kids are college educated, so they should be alright (at least financially.)

Then one day a bunch of prosecutorial evidence was accidentally shredded.... WTF? They only keep one single copy? Nothing is archived onto discs?

I worked for a mechanical engineer that archived everything he did, in case someone tried to come back with lawsuit ten years later... we're talking about air conditioning and ventilation here. But the prosecutors of terrorists don't digitally archive?

Furthermore, can't the FBI use tape and piece the shreds back together? It is possible. Tedious, yes. But definitely do-able.

And now this. The bastard is going to skip right out of jail, go back to his cushy, $85,000 a year (for about 9 month's work) job, with a state of Florida employee's benifit package, he's going to sue the ASS off the prosecutors, and go right back to inciting hatred and bias against Israel and the so-called "Zionists." He's going to keep sending money to the Jihadis of the world, he'll just have to be a little more careful. And maybe open soup kitchen in "palestine."

And like the rest of the "palestinians", when Israel is forced to accept a sovereign "palestine" he will start chipping away on reparations.

I am just so disgusted by it all.

And there, the icing on the cake, Son of Infidel uses this as an excuse to whine about pc left-wingers. Keep it up, Son. You're only pouring gas on the fire. Why don't you try to convince some liberals to wake up to the jihadi threat instead of whining about how we help the Jihad?

And who is more pc about Islam that your messiah, the cowardly draftdodging Bush?

KiethJoy, why don't You try to wake your bastard buddies up to their own stupidity in letting these scum get away with so much, since You know how to talk to them in their own language?

We Are working to change things- by not electing Kerry, for starters. Another change will be more conservative judges being appointed by our President. That's why we need 4 more years.

The only reason your side refuses to see this as a War by islam against US, is that it will delay their political and social goals. To acknowledge that there IS a war against us would require them to DO something about it- and they can't permit that to delay their return to power, which it certainly will.

by the way, KeithJoy, some of us answered your question.


http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/002764.php

sorry, but we had to use Reason. We don't speak your language, therefore we weren't able to use lies, distortions and half-truths.

I hope this guy trips coming out of the courthouse, falls into & knocks down the defense lawyers & they all break their necks tumbling down the stairs.........seems like that's the only way any justice will be served.


August 11, 2004
China? Earthquake in mulsum area?
Iraqi people are pointing out the Terrorist they want to help the USA take back their country from these evil terrorist who are working for Iran! and china?
The Iraqi people will be Free with the Help of the USA and Friends!!!

August 12, 2004
Sader is a coward is hiding behind pregnant women?
Thought he was going to die to the last drop of blood is running to coward in a mosque and is shooting from the mosque I hear that they are sh-ting on the beautiful floors thought they had respect for the mosque?
The Iraqi army is fighting bravely to take out these mulsum terrorist that have been sent from Iran to hurt the Iraqi people!! The Iraqi Army is fighting with the USA to take out the Iranian terrorist and save their mosque if possible but will rebuild it if sader destroys it like they did in Mt. Casino!!!
Sader is a YELLOW MAN!!!

Part of the American Tribe
God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and All who Fight with her give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Victory [FREEDOM] Amen

Its all a big, fat, happy coincidence thats all.

Posted by: witness at August 12, 2004 08:18 AM

You will never be pleased hope you are not married because you would be hell to live with?

Life is a rose garden and roses have thorns! Yes they smell good but to produce the flowers you need bees and the bees sting but make honey that is sweet and you are the kind of person who will miss all that sweetness because you don't see past the bees and thorns how sad!!!

We Are Winning and the world will go on we won WW2 and the mess was a hell of a lot worse !!!

You are a whinny Baby!!


IRAQ will Be FREE and will have peace will have beautiful lands that produce farm land to feed their people and change the reigon get over that you guy was bussy with his pants down!
And what the HELL was Sandy Berger STUFFING in his pants ? What Papers was he willing to go to jail for?


Part of the American Tribe

God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and All who Fight with her give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Victory[FREEDOM] Amen

I don't know why you are all so surprised. Caught red-handed in a sting to buy RPG'S to take down one of our planes they outright lie. ("What, We are peaceful Muslims?")

A quote by Yasser Arafat says it all:

"I am ready to kill for the sake of my cause; wouldn't I lie for it?"

Because of this attitude extreme torture is the only answer. And because of their lying and treachery it takes a man like Saddam to keep the rioting masses in line.

They should all have "accidents."

Keithjoy,

Come on...

Your first post in this thread was great - on target, to the point, and NON-PARTISAN. Couldn't you just have left it at that?

Son of Infidel's post is correct - that political correctness, the multicultural smokesceen that is so often used for promoting "tolerance", and activist judges have, in large part, created an environment that allows this sort of crap to occur. I didn't see him chewing on Kerry or Clinton. As far as I can see, your first post also pointed some fingers in the same direction SOI's post did - and he didn't even use the (I assume derogatory) term hippie.

BTW, I have seen KJ's posts on other web forums, and he DOES try to enlighten his misguided liberal friends about Islam and it's dangers. Rather forcefully too, so don't automatically assume he's negligent there, Gary. I disagree with KJ on quite a lot politically, but he has attempted dialogue to convice his friends that they've put blinders on where Islam is concerned.

Keith, I don't think anybody here considers Bush to be a messiah, and as soon as everybody else drops the political expediency of "Islam is a Religion of Peace", on both sides of the political spectrum, if Bush is still spouting that nonsense you will have a point. By and large, they're all doing it.

Catherine:

You're name calling has cut me to the quick, now get a grip, and come back to reality before its too late for all of us.

Walker~ I'd give him more slack if he didn't:

1. Put thought into our heads we do not have. As in, hate-mongering extreme right wing garbage.

2. Claim we have said things about him that Cannot be found in any thread. Which is putting words in people's mouths.

3. Lie about what we are bringing up about those on the Left whom he seems to favor. When in truth all we are doing are pointing to Links detailing things those people actually said and did, which are well-documented by the press. (and often the very press who Backs those people).

4. Ignores anything we do say about ourselves that proves his contentions about us wrong.

As you say, when he makes sense, he makes sense.

------

Catherine~ I still don't get why you take swipes at people who had made it Clear they are against the Jihadists. I need to know something- do you yourself belong to any particular political / idealogical organization? It is the only reason I can see for some of your responses to them.

Beyond that I think you are great. *g*

Gary,

Those items you mention as antagonism from KJ weren't the point of my post, nor did I ask for you to cut him slack - you in essence accused him of not doing anything educational towards resolving the mutual problem (in reply to his accusation of same against SOI), I was just providing info that you may not have been aware of.

The death tolls mounts for the muslims in their holy City Najaf and Al Sadr blames America for the lack of peace. Seems to me that this is good news.

The fundamentalist freaks mount their barbaric and hateful opposition from inside their mosques where they hide with their guns and bombs like the cancerous assassins they are.

Blinded by a religion of fools …...no a cult of the brainless..... they scream that the infidel must not defile their holiest places of worship by setting foot in such a miraculous place.

Yet they defile such places themselves with their hate, their lies, their deceit, their dishonor and their viciousness against all that is good, moral and ethical in the world after all anything is justified for that old bastard allah.

What makes such a place “holy”. In Islam, it probably means that Mohammed once had a crap on the site. (thus giving rise to the popular expression “holy shit”) .

Sorry I do not buy it. If these hypocrites are hiding behind the walls of their mosques, while waging war, then I have no problem knocking those “holy” walls down.

Let it inflame the whole God forsaken Islamic world – WE SHOULD NOT GIVE A DAMN.

Did Islam care when the walls of the World Trade Centre came down.

Yeah they cared – they danced in the street


I say it’s time for a street party.

Toro

Toro - I'm with you 100%! Game On!!!

We all knew Western style Justice was flawed : heavily in favour of crooks and murderers who have been thumbing their noses and laughing at soft sentencing judges for years! One thing we could learn from our Muslim friends is how NOT to
fall into the trap of feeling sorry for criminals.
How often have we heard the old ,oft trotted out excuses 'He had a deprived childhood....He has only offended once...He has only killed once..He is now truly reformed and has embraced Christianity/Islam...' Taken on these excuses, Saddam Hussein will walk free as well because he had a deprived childhood. We are NOT trying people on grounds of their deprived childhoods : we should be trying them for their CRIMES.

Catherine:

You're name calling has cut me to the quick, now get a grip, and come back to reality before its too late for all of us.

Posted by: witness at August 12, 2004 02:57 PM


I don't understand you who are you saying are the bad guys the Germans or the Americans?


Heard that Iran wants the Iraqi people to take to the streets ? Does that prove that it is Iran who are the killers running around in Iraq?


Well Iran you had better worry about your own backyard! We saw 30,000 people killed and how many more will die from your actions?


You follow YELLOW MEN and send yellow men to kill the Iraqi people?

Iraq VS Portugal Iraq wins the match 4-2


Part of the American Tribe
God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and All who Fight with her give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Victory Amen

Catherine:

The bad guys are is islamists. Not everyone "working on our side" -- is "on our side!"

This is as far as I am going to go with this comment. The article is important for not only what it says explicitly, but also for what it says implicitly.

May I suggest a careful re-read and consideration.

do you yourself belong to any particular political / idealogical organization? It is the only reason I can see for some of your responses to them.

Beyond that I think you are great. *g*

Posted by: Gary at August 12, 2004 03:46 PM


Yea It is called the USA and I am tired of people who say they are fighting with us and stabing those who fight at every turn?

Witness like kj are with the fight but not realy with every win them slam because the want their guy to win weather they will take up the fight or not but when they are feeling the danger that is real they lash out not for the real answers but to strike well I like to strike back !

I'm willing to Fight with those who want to Fight but I will not worry about my 6!!!


And the name whinny baby can be sexy depends on how you look at it? and who is cut to the soul by a name like that not any strong Fighter sounds like a French man to me?


Part of the American Tribe
God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and All who Fight with her give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Victory [FREEDOM] Amen

Kj,

"And there, the icing on the cake, Son of Infidel uses this as an excuse to whine about pc left-wingers".

I do not whine about anything, I make clear, concise, factual statements.

Futhermore I never need an "excuse" to state the "truth" about you and your ilk.

"The politically correct left wing socialist and marxist scum have helped to facilitate this transmutation".

It is the pc liberals such as yourself, the ACLU and all the rest that do the whining.

"Keep it up, Son. You're only pouring gas on the fire. Why don't you try to convince some liberals to wake up to the jihadi threat instead of whining about how we help the Jihad"?

As far as trying to "convince" libs to see the clear and present danger of Islam, unfortunately they are to blinded by their liberal socialist view of the world.

I have on many occasions engaged in discourse with the left wing crowd and they refuse to recognize the "facts" about Islamo-fascism.

"And who is more pc about Islam that your messiah, the cowardly draftdodging Bush"?

The above statement of yours is ignorant at best.

George Bush certianly is no coward he has brought the fight to the Islamo-fascists and to accuse him of being a draft dodger is a typical left wing baseless statement.

On the other hand the "facts" about John Kerry's "alleged" military record are indisputable!

"Kerry "gamed" the system to win decorations and later betrayed comrades by charging war crimes. Typical is the quote by Bob Hildreth, commanding an accompanying boat: "I would never want Kerry behind me. I wouldn't want him in front of me, either. And I sure wouldn't want him commanding our kids in Iraq and Afghanistan." Some 200 "Swiftees" on May 4 signed a letter to Kerry demanding full release of his service records".

One of the more disturbing facts about Mr. Kerry's war record are his combat decorations are unjustified.

"His first Purple Heart, was accidentally self-inflicted. His commander, Grant Hibbard, is quoted as saying: "I didn't recommend him for a Purple Heart. Kerry probably wrote up the paperwork and recommended himself"

Finally to say that I or any other conservatives believe that President Bush is some type of messiah is foolish.

The Bush Administration certianly needs to become more aggresive in taking military action aganist the Islamic countries that finance, train and support the Jihadists.

Walker colt,

Thanks for the support.

Hello to all. I see we've been at it again. I have much respect for all of you. I just wanted to again point out that we're in this thing together. Whether or not we agree with each other on the rest of politics, we all agree that Islamism has to be removed.

Left, right, conservative, liberal, Republican, Democrat, Independent........It doesn't matter anymore. We've made mistakes on both sides of the aisle for a long time. The biggest mistake was letting all of them in here in the first place.

Sorry to interrupt, but we all have a huge plague to get rid of......

Thanks,

D.C.

DC Watson,

I appreciate your comments.

Concerning the left wing liberals it is their pc socialist ideology that has helped to facilitate the Islamo-fascists agenda.

This type of mentality needs to be purged from this country or our battle aganist Islam will be that much more difficult.

I would be glad to give the libs a gun to shoot the bastards, although I don't think they would know which end the bullets come out of.

Catherine wrote

I'm willing to Fight with those who want to Fight but I will not worry about my 6!!!

BillFish?

Off topic, but good news anyway.

AP Photo/Ben Margot Calif. Court Voids S.F. Gay Marriages
SAN FRANCISCO - "The California Supreme Court on Thursday voided the nearly 4,000 same-sex marriages sanctioned in San Francisco this year and ruled unanimously that the mayor overstepped his authority by issuing licenses to gay and lesbian couples".

Well, like just about anything the democrats are doing this year, it was an attempt to put (any) Republican response to it in a bad light- but especially Bush, this being an election year.

On topic: Germany is certainly sending mixed signals, is it not? Now that they are creating a database to track islamic movement in their country, even while giving murderers the right to walk away.

The Islamization and Arabization of "Eurabia" continues to grow, 8,000 mosques in Germany.

What else would one expect from those pc socialist Germans.

"Germany has 8,000 mosques, according to German intelligence officials, to minister to a Turkish minority of 2.4 million and some 500,000 North African Muslims. France has some 10,000 mosques for 6 million North Africans; the U.S. about 2,000".

"European intelligence services know an alarming number of mosques are privileged sanctuaries used by extremists. Self-proclaimed imams can choose any place, from a basement to a garage, and declare it a mosque, an Islamic place of worship".

>Off topic, but good news anyway.

>AP Photo/Ben Margot Calif. Court Voids S.F. Gay Marriages


I guess you and Bin Laden have the same opinion on the issue. That's funny, isn't it.


What did you think of Pim Fortuyn, the gay Netherlands politicians who was assassinated for opposing Islamofascism in Holland?

More clumsy Bush moves that will let the terrorists go free. Germany has been complaining for over a year of lack of cooperation from Bush in this trial. If this bastard goes free, after aiding the death of 3000, it will be an outrage against justice.

But Bush and Cheney are too busy with politics for justice.

Note: There are no "pc liberals" in the Arab world. Tolerance and pluralism ("e pluribus unum") are mostly Western ideas. So are the people who hate "pc liberals" agreeing with the Islamofascists???????

Maybe you folks can hang these "pc liberals" in a soccer stadium or cut off their hands, or whatever.

mega2004,

The politically correct liberal Democrats are apologists for, sympathizers with, and enablers of the Islamo-fascists.

The Democrats Embrace Al-Jazeera
By Thomas Ryan
FrontPageMagazine.com | July 30, 2004

"Despite Democratic Presidential Nominee John Kerry’s assertion that as President, he would “use every available resource to destroy terrorists and deny them sanctuary…and new recruits,” one of the invited guests at the now-concluded Democratic National Convention was an organization that has served as a terrorist recruitment tool, a communications conduit for al-Qaeda in general and Osama bin Laden in particular. This network has repeatedly described Palestinian suicide-bombers as “martyrs.” High above the platform and the sea of “Kerry-Edwards” placards, covering the convention from a skybox towering over the Fleet Center floor was Arabic network al-Jazeera, the Arab satellite news agency whose allegedly “factual and accurate” news coverage has been blatantly anti-American. The Democrats were at least savvy enough to remove the network’s banner, which had been strategically placed near the speakers’ podium. But how could any candidate or political party “serious” about terrorism make no fuss about allowing such a news group inside its convention?"

PS: As long as the Homosexuals stay in the closet, they are not a threat to world peace.

Catherine~ I still don't get why you take swipes at people who had made it Clear they are against the Jihadists. I need to know something- do you yourself belong to any particular political / idealogical organization? It is the only reason I can see for some of your responses to them.

Beyond that I think you are great. *g*

I may be a little to late on this thread for you to read this Gary but I think I see where Catherine is comming from. She is as totally far-right as you can possibly get, she has had swipes in me at the past because guns are banned in Britain (and as I've told her many times, the illegal gun-gathering process is much easier and cheaper).
She doesn't mean anything by it, she's just concerned, as she should be, that if muslims start up some kind of mass uprising on our own turf, the west will not be prepared , and she just wants everyone just as geared up for battle as she is.

Catherine,
Am I right, (not trying to get Freudian on you)?