Federal Judge Dismisses Terrorism Charges Against Two Men in Detroit, Citing Prosecutors' "zeal"

More Keystone Kops terror prosecutions. How many can we afford? Unfortunately, however, it's impossible to tell here whether the real villain of the piece is the zealous prosecution team, or the federal judge. From AP, with thanks to Anthony:

DETROIT (AP) - A federal judge dismissed terrorism charges against two men convicted last year, saying the prosecution's zeal to obtain a conviction in the wake of Sept. 11 overcame its professional judgment.

But U.S. District Judge Gerald Rosen said the two, as well as a third man, must stand trial again on charges of document fraud.

The judge's decision came after the Justice Department admitted widespread prosecutorial misconduct in the case and asked the judge to dismiss the terrorism charges against two men accused of being part of a Detroit terror cell.

Rosen said the prosecution's "understandable sense of mission and zeal to obtain a conviction" in the wake of the Sept. 11 "overcame not only its professional judgment, but its broader obligations to the justice system and the rule of law."

The case had been hailed by the Bush Administration as a victory in the war on terror.

The government's change of heart came after a monthslong court-ordered review of documents connected to the case. The Justice Department uncovered much more potentially exculpatory evidence that should have been given to the defense before trial.

Karim Koubriti, 26, and Abdel-Ilah Elmardoudi, 38, were convicted in June 2003 of conspiracy to provide material support for terrorism and to engage in fraud and misuse of visas and other documents. Ahmed Hannan, 36, was convicted of only the fraud charge, and Farouk Ali-Haimoud, 24, was acquitted.

| 13 Comments
del.icio.us | Digg this | Email | FaceBook | Twitter | Print | Tweet

13 Comments

So the lives of two more innocent Muslims (and their families) are ruined because of American religious and racial bigotry. Once again the American secret police, inquisitors, and "prosecutors" conspire to persecute innocent people for the crime of being Muslim.

How much longer do you expect that peaceful Muslims will tolerate this oppression and abuse? How much longer do you thing they will allow the Americans to war against Almighty Allah (swt) in direct contravention of the Quranic injunctions?

You will reap what you sow.

Your grandchildren will be Muslim.

Allahu akbar

Reza,

You may be a good muslim but you are bad at math. The terrorism, genocide and oppression in Russia, Isreal, Sudan, Rawanda, Iraq, Spain, Phillipines, Bali, and the US have been committed by followers of a false moon god - al-lah. That adds up to the fact that islam is a belief system based on hate and fear and it uses terror as a tool to promote its agenda.

I pray that the "peaceful" muslims will someday see the words of the koran and mohammed as lies and worship the the true God. The God of Abraham, Issac and Jacob.

BTW Trying to expose and eliminate islam is not racial bigotry. islam is a belief system and a belief system is not a race.

Hate to agree with Reza on anything, but according to the European view of the world the Semites are a race, the Nordics are a race, etc. So any assertion that we are better than they are is by definition 'racism'. But that doesn't make it wrong! :-)

Ellis~ arabs are semites. But this still isn't racism, as semites are white. Ethnic white. Islam is a religion, albeit a very bad one.

I doesn't matter what kind of "mites" they are. A belief systems is a belief system. If that is what's being questioned then, while it might be religiuos bigotry, it is not racism.

How much longer do you expect that peaceful Muslims
Posted by: Reza at September 3, 2004 07:45 AM


Yea sure tell that to the people in Russia who your friends ISLAMIC TERRORIST KILL SMALL CHILDREN BY SHOOTING THEM IN THE BACK!!


YEA WE GOT YOUR PEACEFUL!!


You and your people are nothing but a bunch of COWARDS KILLERS WHO NEED TO BE KILLED!!


Part of the American Tribe
Spider Killer
Squirrel Hunter
God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and All who Fight with her open their eyes to the ISLAMIC TERRORIST and give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Victory Amen

What has race have to do with this?

As I have commented many times before, When it comes to terrorism; I would rather see the prosecuting team go after the slimest of evidence whether they get a conviction in court or not.

Would you rather have them just ignore the evidence and throw their hands up saying; we can`t win this one! I for one think that would be extemely foolish given the climate we are living in today.

I applaud the Zeal and effort of these prosecutors; win or lose.

"I`d rather be a keystone cop then a no stone turned over cop".

Reza,

So the lives of two more innocent Muslims.......Blah, Blah, Blah.
Are any of you Sand Maggots doing anything to capture the guilty ones engaged in criminal activities? Not a one. Why? Is it because they are all “Innocent Peaceful Muslims?’

How much longer do you expect that peaceful Muslims will tolerate this oppression.........Blah, Blah, Blah.
You Sand Maggots go to other countries bringing your Mid-Evil cult with you and then impose it on the citizens of that country. You may succeed in some countries, but not in others. In that case the other countries will tolerate “Innocent Peaceful Muslims” is when the Muslims go back to their own country and try and be good “Innocent Peaceful Muslims” and join in on the tribal warfare.

You will reap what you sow............Keep it up and you will get exactly that.

Your grandchildren will be Muslim...........Blah, Blah, Blah
Your grandchildren will always be the likes of you - Sand Maggots

Simple answer for you - if you don’t like the country you are in - be “Innocent Peaceful Muslims” and leave in peace!!!!

Like your typical trailer park style flea market, just chock full of used, useless shit all crammed into one event, Muslims think that Islam is a race, religion, and nationality all wrapped up in one name.

Unfortunately for them, they're too illiterate (stupid) to realize that Islam is not a race, not a nationality, and definitely not a legitimate religion.

They are, however, a prickly thorn in the ass of planet earth, that need to be plucked as soon as possible, as the pus biproduct they create is oozing. If I offend any Muslims trolling this site, then I've accomplished what I set out to do.

Rough justice is in the wind for those jihadists that target the children of the West. We are sick of them and their nasty death cult.

Judge is over zealous in defense of 'poor oppressed Muslims' Methinks. Or is he just another
dim Dhmmi??

It would be curious to know what kind of exculpitory evidence that was not made available to the defence during the trial, over rides the evidence that got these guys prosecuted and convicted in the first place.

I like it when Muslim complain, Makes me pray for more bad treatment for all of them!

Site Meter