Terence Jeffrey asks: Will promoting democracy in Islamic lands really make us safer from terrorism? Clearly, the answer is no, as he demonstrates from the career of Chechnya's Shamil Basayev. Only a thoroughgoing worldwide repudiation of the Islamic principles that lead to terrorist violence will suffice. From Town Hall, with thanks to EPG:
By turns, Shamil Basayev has been a terrorist in the murderous mold of Osama bin Laden, a top candidate for the presidency of Chechnya and the Chechen prime minister. Now he is back in his Osama-bin-Laden mode.As Americans debate our future foreign policy -- in an era when terrorism is the greatest threat -- we would do well to study the Russian experience with Basayev. It raises the question: Will promoting democracy in remote lands be effective in defending America against terrorists?
Basayev took credit last week for the hostage-taking raid on the school in Beslan, Russia. He also claimed responsibility for other recent terror attacks: the suicide bombing of two Russian jetliners, a suicide bombing outside a Moscow subway station and another bombing at a Moscow bus stop.
For Russians, it was no surprise Basayev was behind the Beslan raid. He had done this before.
In "Chechnya -- Calamity in the Caucasus," co-authors Carlotta Gall and Thomas de Waal, who worked as reporters for the Moscow Times during the first Russo-Chechen war, describe the June 14, 1995, raid Basayev personally led against the Russian town of Budennovsk. Basayev and his raiders shot up the police station, rounded up civilians -- "many of them old men and women and housewives sitting at home" -- and blockaded themselves in a hospital with more than 1,000 hostages.
He was contemptuous of innocent life. "I thought, what difference is there, whatever means I use, if they are Russian, they are jackals. My people are more important to me than these Russian children or women," Gall and de Waal quote him as saying.
After the Russians failed to free the hostages through force, Russian Prime Minister Viktor Chernomyrdin agreed to allow Basayev and his terrorists safe passage back to Chechnya in a convoy of buses. They took hostages with them as human shields.
A year later, Russia agreed to withdraw its forces from Chechen territory and allow a Chechen presidential and parliamentary election. But the Russians did not recognize Chechen independence, saying Chechnya's status should be decided in five years.
Now, Basayev, the bloody terrorist, became Basayev, the presidential candidate.
His main opponent was Aslan Maskhadov, the one-time Soviet colonel who had commanded Chechen forces in the war. Both candidates stood for Chechen independence, but Maskhadov was deemed the "moderate."
Basayev ran on his war record. "Candidate Basayev," reported the Philadelphia Inquirer, "has compiled what amounts to a greatest-hits video of his audacious war exploits and turned it into a campaign advertisement. At any hour of the day or night, people in this ruined land can tune to a pro-Basayev television station and watch graphic reruns of the most savage moments in Chechnya's 21-month-long war with Moscow, all starring the controversial rebel. There's Basayev, the daring commander, laying siege to the Russian town of Budennovsk, where civilian hostages were doused with gasoline."
One Basayev supporter told Moscow Times correspondent Gall: "I voted for Basayev because I want to show Russia that they may see him as a terrorist, but we do not."
"Only a thoroughgoing worldwide repudiation of the Islamic principles that lead to terrorist violence will suffice."
If one must take a public stand, than this is as far as one can reasonably go in stating their position among what was once termed "polite society."
However, it should be pointed out that this laudable position will never come to be.
Moreover, recent events suggest that just the opposite in fact, is actually occurring.
The harsh realization that all the underpinnings of "islamic principles that lead to terrorist violence" can not be repudiated unitl islam itself is repudiated -- will force one to consider difficult choices.
Since this last position can not be publically stated by anyone wishing to maintain credibility, islam with all its horrors seems likely to thrive.
Indeed, it is ironic - and tragically so, that the islamic beasts are allowed to murder the reasonable - because the reasonable, being what they are, wish to maintain the extravegance of credibility in the company of those who have neither respect nor appreciation for the meaning of such things.
In the beggining I was against the war in Iraq,not because I give a rats ass about "arabs hating us"(like they didn't anyway Mr.Libs), or "global terror rising" (it would have continued at the same pace anyway,BTW heard of 9/11 Mr.Libs...oh yeah that was because we're giving support to Israel, who damn well deserve it)or even because Iraq was "nothing to do with 9/11( islamic terrorism, and islamic tyrants have the same agenda and the same arch enemy... can anyone on the left say "Team Up").
No, the reason I was against the Iraq war is because I didn't want more british soldiers lives being wasted to save the asses of foreigners (muslim foreigners to make matters worse) who didn't have the balls to fight oppression from Saddam themselves.And I also thought didn't want billions of £ of taxpayers money being wasted on rebuilding their shithole of a country, and I also believed that there was no hope of a democracy ever working over there.
Now I'm all for it, and my reasons for this are:
1.>Saddam needed stopping before he made Iraq the most dangerous country in the world.
2.> Just like when you pour poison on an ants nest, the verminous-bugs come out of their nest to die, thousands of the worlds terrorist/insurgent/militant/jihadists are coming to iraq to fight jihad against " U.S occupation".This is only a good thing, the more that come , the more get captured or killed, and the less terrorism in the future, there shall be (BTW- Brainless lefties moan how things are worse now than ever.... HELLO it's a war not a carnival, and the reason more terrorist are there is because we've flushed them out, made a battle arena to defeat them on, and the lunatics, being to primitive and religiously mental to see it, just keep comming and comming!!!There'll be none left for Iran-LOL)
3.> With a pro-western government installed, we will have a new ally in the heart of terrorland (arabia y'all), to collaborate with exchange intelligence with , and a new haven/HQ for CIA, MI5 and European anti-terror groups.
Summarized, the war in Iraq was an extremely smart tactical move that killed two birds with one stone (toppled Saddam, and will put us at an advantage when Iran and Syria get whats comming to them).
Whether the left like it or not (and they don't because ,quite simply, they see it as an illegal war and it appears to their mindset that we are the villains - a new Nazi movement or something simular -- which is ridiculous because if that was the case we'd have taken out two thirds of the Arabian Peninsula by now) we've started this war on terror,we're making good progress and (if Kerry doesn't get elected, which I hope to God he doesn't)
we'll damn well see it finished too.
fear of saddam? nothings really changed , the good people of Iraq, men and woman ,children, just have a different fear,,,,, freedom, if someone walked the streets saying thank you USA they would be in fear of their lives again. all it would take is the wrong person to hear it!
Naseem,
You're either schitzophrenic or full of shit.
Either way your "it is a proud day to be a muslim"..and..."islam is the miracle..." crazy-ass spin on things from your comments yesterday totally contradicts your "I dislike Sharia law..." and simular BS quotes posted today.
So which one is it???
Mr. Rikki,
Wot are U on about? I see no contradictions here. My greatest pride is being a muslim. I was born a muslim, it is who and what I am...I told you when I 1st came here...I cannot and will not compromise on that. So yes it is a good time to be muslim and the miracle is there for all to see...I see nothing wrong with that stance.
As for Sharia law...well that must have been OK for the 7th centuary, but it's outdated and not fit for the modern world, ....things move on...before you had lamps and candles, today you have electricity.
Before you had carts & oxen, tyoday you have tractors & cars...you move on.
It appears that Russia has learned its lessons the hard way after giving into Baseyev in 1995 and giving him safe passage back to Chechnya.
So here he is again, taking responsibility for the 2 downed Russian aircraft, the car bomb near a moscow subway, and the horrible massacre of children in the town of Beslan.
Russia may still have to learn the hard way when it comes to working with Iran. I think assisting or supporting Iran with its infrastructure is going to be a serious miscalulation for Russia in the future. When you support a radical islamic regime such as Iran, you run the risk of them turning on you when they think they have enough power.
As Russia ,France, and Germany need to realize that the radical states who subscribe to the militant tenets of the Quran and the hadiths will still see them as infidels in the end and will use them until they can turn on them.
Naseem says: As for Sharia law...well that must have been OK for the 7th centuary, but it's outdated and not fit for the modern world, ....things move on...before you had lamps and candles, today you have electricity. Before you had carts & oxen, tyoday you have tractors & cars...you move on.
So let's not bash him for being a Muslim, he is trying, against all odds, to be a moderate. I applaud him for his bravery.
Well done, Naseem. Now, the next step is secularism. Report to www.secularislam.org for your next lesson.
Naseem, my friend, Sharia law WAS okay, not for the 7th century, but in 7th-century southern Saudi Arabia... in a harsh environment there has to be cooperation, or the entire tribe will fail (die out.) When cooperation isn't voluntary (as with the "primitive" Bushmen of Angola-Namibia-South Africa, the Aboriginies of Australia, etc.) it has to be enforced. So of course, in order to avoid men fighting to the death over a women, it was important to keep women "modest" and covered up and hidden away from the lustful eye of all other men. And when your life depends on maintaining your small supply of food, thievery should be punished severely, etc. etc.
Naseem, as the necessity for Sharia has passed, so has the necessity for religion at all. I'm not saying that we should not be religious, but we shouldn't follow religions that practice, condone, and even encourage violence, forced conversion, etc.
I like most Americans was born into a Christian familiy, but have gradually accepted that it's mostly a bunch of crap. Likewise, if you objectively studied the origins and history of Islam, I think that you will come to the same conclusion.
It is easy enough to renounce the bad parts of a certain mindset and retain the good parts...but you need to make sure that you really get rid of all the bad parts. So for instance, I believe in the Christian urging toward tolerance, forbearance, kindness, "do unto others..." etc. In a similar manner there's nothing wrong with maintaining the Muslim tendency toward charitable giving, determination, etc.
Muslims in general have many favorable traits, like here in America, they all want to work hard, make a lot of money, send their kids to college for science, medicine, engineering, etc. It is widely believed that Muslims really love kids (well, especially Muslim kids).
But there are other Muslim traits that are very unfavorable, like the anti-Semitism, the mistreatment of women and girls, etc.
There is some good and some bad in every group of like-minded people: conservatives, liberals, communists, capitalists, anarchists, Moaists, Loyalists, Federalists, socialists, atheists, christians, muslims, jews, Quakers, republicans, democrats, Dixiecrats, Confederates, Unionists, Irish-Catholics, Anglo-Protestants, etc. The important thing do is shift through all of them and not "throw the baby out with the bathwater."
Naseem, not to be insulting, but an appropriate analogy here would be that of a turd. Once it's out, the smell disipates, until eventually there's no smell at all (if you have ever had a pet dog, which I realize is unlikely, you can believe this.) You can cover the turd in baby powder or perfume, paint it, etc. but no matter how much you change it, it's still a turd.
Good Muslims, like good Christians, are not good because of their religion, but rather in spite of it.
So again I beg you to report to www.secularislam.org for the next step in you progress.
KJ
Oh, I almost forgot, the reason I wanted to comment on this article entitled "When the Candidate Was a Terrorist".
That kind of reminds me of Muqtada Al Sadr claiming that he will run for political office, all perfectly legal in the Nu-perfect "democracy" of Iraq Nam, of course. Wait, I thought he was wanted in the connection of the murder of another Mullah (not to mention a few US Marines.) Oh well, that's not important anymore.
KJ,
My respect for you has gone up 10fold with your post to Naseem.
Nasseem,
KJ is absolutely right you are showing all signs that you actually starting to question your faith ,as I did mine-christianity, and for many years was an atheist, because religion just made no sense in the world, and contradicted itself so much, and just sempt so far fetched with it's stories (if someone told us today of a man walking on water, we'd laugh at them and think they were nuts, but we're to believe such unbelievably far-fetched stories from religious books that were written thousands of years ago!!!).
Think about it Naseem, it's ludicrous. Most people in the more advanced countries of the civilized world are beginning to reject religion, and for this very reason.
In fact I'd say that muslims are the only culture of people, where the majority of them still follow their religious teachings to the letter ;it borders on obssession and the modern world has no place for it, which is why so many people are now looking at muslims as primitive savages.
If anyting islam is a dangerous, brainwashing religion and you'd be better off without, try secularism.org and see what you think.
And understand that the only reason for my harshness to you is because of the faith you follow that I see as a threat to my family, children, girlfriend, friends , and country, which I would happily die to defend, surely you can understand that , and understand why I see it as a threat, you've been coming here now long enough and have seen the attrocities your muslim brothers and sisters are capable of.
KJ~ Right On! Excellent writing.
errr... btw, Jeanne seems to be in a bad mood. I hope your home is not in the current path.
Rikki is it not a good thing that America didn’t feel that way about her pocket book during WW2?
BTW- Brainless lefties moan how things are worse now than ever.... HELLO it's a war not a carnival,
Right O! Remind them of the WW2 and the Bombing of England and what the Germans did to England them Remind them of what modern weapons can do like Cem,Bio?
What is it WAR IS HELL AND WE ARE AT WAR!! Remind of what they mussi’s think?
THIEVERY & SLAVERY:
Qur’an 8:1 “They ask you about the benefits of capturing the spoils of war. Tell them: ‘The benefits belong to Allah and to His Messenger.’”
Ishaq:510 “We ask Thee for the booty of this town and its people. Forward in the name of Allah.’ He used to say this of every town he raided.”
Ishaq:327 “Allah said, ‘A prophet must slaughter before collecting captives. A slaughtered enemy is driven from the land. Muhammad, you craved the desires of this world, its goods and the ransom captives would bring. But Allah desires killing them to manifest the religion.’”
Tabari VII:64/Ishaq:307 “The Messenger of Allah gave orders concerning the contents of the camp which the people had collected, and it was all brought together. Among the Muslims, however, there was a difference of opinion concerning it. Those who had collected it said, ‘It is ours. Muhammad promised every man that he could keep the booty he took.’ Those who were fighting said, ‘If it had not been for us, you would not have taken it. We distracted the enemy from you so that you could take what you took.’ Those who were guarding the Prophet for fear the enemy would attack him said, ‘By Allah, you have no better right to it than we have. We wanted to kill the enemy when Allah gave us the opportunity and made them turn their backs, and we wanted to take property when there was no one to protect it; but we were afraid that the Meccans might attack the Prophet. We protected him so you have no better right to it than we have.’ When we quarreled about the booty we became very bad tempered. So Allah removed it from us and handed it over to His Messenger.”
Bukhari:V5B59N360 “The total number of Muslim fighters from Mecca who fought at Badr and were given a share of the booty, were 81. When their shares were distributed, their number was 101. But Allah knows it better.”
Ishaq:307 “The ‘Spoils of War’ Surah came down from Allah to His Prophet concerning the distribution of the booty when the Muslims showed their evil nature. Allah took it out of their hands and gave it to the Apostle.”
Tabari VII:65 “Allah’s Messenger came back to Medina, bringing with him the booty which had been taken from the polytheists.... There were forty-four captives in the Messenger of Allah’s possession. There was a similar number of dead.”
Bukhari:V5B59N512 “The captives of Khaybar were divided among the Muslims. Then the Messenger began taking the homes and property that were closest to him.”
Tabari VIII:116/Ishaq:511 “So Muhammad began seizing their herds and their property bit by bit. He conquered home by home. The Messenger took some of its people captive, including Safiyah and her two cousins. The Prophet chose Safiyah for himself.”
Ishaq:511 “When Dihyah protested, wanting to keep Safiyah for himself, the Apostle traded for Safiyah by giving Dihyah her two cousins. The women of Khaybar were distributed among the Muslims.”
Tabari VIII:130 “The Prophet conquered Khaybar by force after fighting. Khaybar was something that Allah gave as booty to His Messenger. He took one-fifth of it and divided the remainder among the Muslims.”
Bukhari V4B52N46 “I heard Allah’s Apostle saying, ‘Allah guarantees that He will admit the Muslim fighter into Paradise if he is killed, otherwise He will return him to his home safely with rewards and booty.’”
Tabari VIII:117 “The Banu Sahm of Aslam [newly recruited Muslim militants] came to the Messenger and complained, ‘Muhammad, we have been hurt by drought and possess nothing.’ Although they had fought for the Prophet they found he had nothing [he was willing] to give them. The Apostle said, ‘O Allah, You know their condition—I have no strength and nothing [I want] to give them [from the booty I have stolen]. So conquer for them the wealthiest of the Khaybar homes, the ones with the most food and fat meat.’”
Ishaq:515 “Allah’s Apostle besieged the final [Jewish] community of Khaybar until they could hold out no longer. Finally, when they were certain that they would perish, they asked Muhammad to banish them and spare their lives, which he did. The Prophet took possession of all their property.”
Tabari VIII:128 “Khaybar was divided among the people who had been at Hudaybiyah.”
Ishaq:521 “Khaybar was apportioned among the men of Hudaybiyah without regard to whether they were present at Khaybar or not. The spoil was divided into 1,800 shares.”
Ishaq:521 “When the spoil of Khaybar was apportioned, the settlements of Shaqq and Nata were given to the Muslims while Katiba was divided into five sections: Allah’s fifth [which Muhammad was custodian]; the Prophet’s fifth; the share to the kindred [Muhammad’s kin]; maintenance of the Prophet’s wives [now there’s an honest report]; and payment to the men who acted as intermediaries in the peace negotiation with Fadak [which enabled the prophet to steal the entire spoil].”
Ishaq:522 “Then the Apostle distributed the booty between his relatives, his wives, and to other men and women. He gave his daughter Fatima 200 shares, Ali 100, Usama 250, Aisha 200, Bakr 100…. In the name of Allah—this is a memorandum of what Muhammad the Apostle gave his wives from the dates and wheat: 180 loads.”
Bukhari:V5B59N537 “Allah’s Apostle divided the war booty with the ratio of two shares for the horse and one-share for the foot soldier.”
Bukhari:V5B59N541 “When we conquered, we gained neither gold nor silver as booty, but we gained cows, camels, goods and gardens.”
Tabari VIII:12 “When cities were conquered Muslims used to say, ‘Conquer for yourselves whatever seems good to you because all treasures were given to Muhammad.’”
Qur’an 48:19 “He rewarded them with abundant spoils that they will capture. Allah has promised you much booty that you shall take, and He has made this easy for you.”
Qur’an 9:103 “Take alms out of their property in order to cleanse and purify them, and invoke Allah for them; surely this is a relief for them.”
Tabari IX:3 “Since the Hawazin and Thaqif had marched with their women, children, and flocks, Allah granted them as booty to His Messenger, who divided the spoils among those Quraysh who had recently embraced Islam.”
Tabari IX:13 “Abu Talhah alone took the spoils of twenty men whom he had killed.”
Ishaq:571 “I went up to a man and struck off his hand. He fell and I killed him while he was down. But I was too occupied with fighting to pay any more attention to him. So one of the Meccan Muslims passed by and stripped him. Then when the fighting was over and we had finished with the enemy, the Apostle said that anyone who had killed a foe could have his spoil. I told the Apostle that I had killed a man who was worth stripping but had been too busy killing others at the time to notice who had spoiled him. Abu Bakr said, “To Allah’s lions who fight for His religion go the spoils that come from their prey. Return the booty to the man who killed him.’ The Apostle confirmed Abu Bakr’s words. So I was given the property of the man whom I had killed. I sold it and bought a small palm grove with the money. It was the first property I ever owned.”
Ishaq:592 “The Apostle held a large number of captives. There were 6,000 women and children prisoners. He had captured so many sheep and camels they could not be counted.”
Tabari IX:31/Ishaq:594 “‘Muhammad, divide the spoil and booty of camels and cattle among us.’ They forced the Prophet up against a tree, and his robe was torn from him. Muhammad cried, ‘Give me back my robe. If there had been more sheep I would have given you some. You have not found me to be niggardly, cowardly or false.”
Tabari IX:31/Ishaq:594 “‘You have not found me miserly, cowardly, or a liar.’ Then he walked over to his camel and took a hair from its hump. Holding it aloft in his fingers he said, ‘Men, I do not have anything of your booty, not even as much as this hair. Just filth. And that filth is what is being given to you. So, bring back my cloak.’”
Ishaq:594 “The Apostle gave gifts to those whose hearts were to be won over, notably the chiefs of the army, to win them and through them the people.”
Bukhari:V4B53N373 “Allah’s Apostle got property and war prisoners and gave them to some people to the exclusion of others. The latter seemed to be displeased by that. The Prophet said, ‘I give to some people, lest they should deviate from Islam or lose patience.’”
Bukhari:V4B53N374 “The Prophet said, ‘I give to the Quraysh so that they will desire Islam, for they are nearer to their life of Ignorance and it is not strong in their hearts.’”
Tabari IX:36/Ishaq:596 “‘Prophet, this group of Ansar have a grudge against you for what you did with the booty and how you divided it among you own people.’ ‘Ansar, what is this talk I hear from you? What is the grudge you harbor against me? Do you think ill of me? Did I not come to you when you were erring and needy, and then made rich by Allah?”
Tabari IX:37/Ishaq:596 “Do you hold a grudge against me and are you mentally disturbed because of the worldly things by which I conciliate a people and win them over so that they will embrace Islam and become Muslims?”
Tabari IX:38 “In this year, the Messenger sent Amr to collect the zakat tax from Jayfar and Amr, the clans of Julanda and Azd.... He collected the jizyah from the Zoroastrians.”
Tabari IX:74 “Indeed, Allah has guided you with His guidance. If you wish to do well [capture booty], obey Allah and His Messenger. You must perform the prayers, pay the zakat tax, and give a fifth share of Allah’s booty to His Messenger. The required zakat is: from the land one tenth of that watered by springs and rain, and one twentieth of that watered by the leathern bucket. From camels, a milch camel for every forty camels, and a young male camel for every thirty camels. From sheep, one for every five camels; and from cows, one from every fourth… If anyone pays more, it is to his credit. He who professes this, bears witness to his Islam and helps the faithful [fight] against the polytheists, he has the protection of Allah and His Messenger.”
Tabari IX:75 “He who holds fast to his religion, Judaism or Christianity, is not to be tempted from it. It is incumbent on them to pay the jizyah protection tax. For every adult, male or female, free or slave, one full denarius, or its value in al-ma’afir [fine cloth]. He who pays that to the Messenger has the protection of Allah and His Messenger, and he who holds back from it is the enemy of Allah and His Messenger.”
Tabari IX:76 “The Messenger has sent Zur’ah and his Companions to you. ‘I commend them to your care. Collect the zakat and jizyah from your districts and hand the money over to my messengers.’ The Prophet is the master of your rich and your poor.”
Ishaq:564 “The Muslims stole our goods and divided them. Their spears pierced us not once but twice. Their squadrons came at us like a swarm of locusts. Were it not for the religion of Muhammad’s people, their cavalry would never have attacked us.”
Bukhari:V9B84N59 “When the Prophet died, Arabs reverted to disbelief. Umar said, ‘Should we fight these people?’ Bakr said, ‘By Allah! I will fight whoever differentiates between prayers and Zakat, as Zakat is to be taken from property according to Allah’s Orders. If they refuse to pay me even so little as a kid they used to pay, I will fight with them for withholding it.’”
Qur’an 59:6 “What Allah gave as booty to His Messenger He has taken away from them [the Jews]. For this you made no raid. Allah gives His Messenger Lordship over whomsoever He wills. Whatever booty Allah has given to His Messenger and taken away from the [Jewish] people of the townships, belongs to Allah and to His Messenger.... So take what the Messenger assigns to you, and deny yourselves that which he withholds from you.”
Tabari VII:26 “In this year Muhammad ordered people to pay the zakat tax. It is said that the Prophet commanded them to do this.”
Ishaq:309 “‘Bind Abu Aziz tight for his mother is rich and she may ransom him for a great deal of money.’”
Tabari VII:71 “Among the captives was Abu Wada. Muhammad said, ‘He has a son who is a shrewd merchant with much money.” [The son] “slipped away at night, went to Medina, ransomed his father for 4,000 dirhams.”
Ishaq:312 “The Prophet said, ‘Abbas, you must ransom yourself, your two nephews, Aqil and Nawfal, and your confederate, Utbah, for you are a wealthy man.’ ‘Muhammad,’ Abbas said, ‘I was a Muslim, but the people compelled me to fight against my will.’ Allah knows best concerning your Islam,’ Muhammad said. ‘As for your outward appearance, you have been against us, so pay to ransom yourself.’ The Messenger had previously taken twenty ounces of gold from him following the battle. So Abbas said, ‘Credit me with this amount towards my ransom.’ ‘No,’ Muhammad replied. ‘That money Allah has already taken from you and given to us.’”
Ishaq:313 “The Muslims told Abu Sufyan to pay them a ransom to free his son, Amr. He replied, ‘Am I to suffer the double loss of my blood and my money? After you have killed my son Hanzala, you want me to pay you a ransom to save Amr?’”
Bukhari:V5B59N357 “The Badr warriors were given five thousand dirhams each, yearly. Umar [the future Caliph] said, ‘I will always give them more than what I will give to others.’”
Tabari VII:80 “When the events of Badr were over, Allah revealed the 8th surah, ‘The Spoils of War,’ in its entirety. The two armies met [there were no armies—just merchants and militants] and Allah defeated the Meccans [with Muslim swords]. Seventy of them were killed, and seventy were taken captive. Abu Bakr said, ‘O Prophet of Allah, these are your people, your family; they are your cousins, fellow clansmen, and nephews. I think that you should accept ransoms for them so that what we take from them will strengthen us.’” Tabari VII:81 “‘What do you think Khattab?’ Muhammad asked. ‘I say you should hand them over to me so that I can cut off their heads. Thus Allah will know that there is no leniency in our hearts toward the unbelievers.’ The Messenger liked what Bakr said and did not like what I said, and accepted ransoms for the captives.”
Ishaq:316 “On the Badr expedition, the Messenger took the sword of Dhu al-Faqar as booty. It had belonged to Munabbih. On that day he also took Abu Jahl’s camel as booty. It was a Mahri dromedary on which he used to go on raids. It is said that he wrote ‘Ma’aqil’ [Blood-Money] on his sword.”
Qur’an 8:1 “They question you about (windfalls taken as) spoils of war. Say: ‘Booty is at the disposal of Allah and the Messenger; they belong to Us and are for Our benefit. So fear Allah, and adjust your way of thinking in this matter. Obey Allah and His Messenger.’”
Ishaq:321 “The Spoils of War surah was handed down because we quarreled about the booty. So Allah took it away from us and gave it to His Apostle. When He did, we learned to fear Allah and obey his Messenger.... For in truth, our army had gone out with the Prophet seeking the caravan because we wanted its booty.”
Ishaq:324 “Allah taught them how to divide the spoil. He made it lawful and said, ‘A fifth of the booty belongs to the Apostle.’
Qur’an 8:40 “If people are obstinate, and refuse to surrender, know that Allah is your Supporter. And know that one fifth of all the booty you take belongs to Allah, and to the Messenger, and for the near relatives (of the Messenger).”
Qur’an 8:68 “Had it not been for a previous agreement from Allah, a severe penalty would have reached you for the (ransom) that you took as booty.”
Qur’an 8:69 “So enjoy what you took as booty; the spoils are lawful and good.”
Ishaq:327 “Allah made booty lawful and good. He used it to incite the Muslims to unity of purpose. So enjoy what you have captured.”
Bukhari:V4B52N276 “By Allah, we saw the Meccan women running, revealing their leg-bangles. So, we cried out, ‘The booty! O Muslims, the booty! Our Companions have become victorious. What are we waiting for? By Allah! We will go to the pagans and collect our share of the war booty.’”
Tabari VIII:38 “The Messenger divided the wealth, wives, and children of the Banu Qurayza Jews among the Muslims.” Ishaq:465 “When their wrists were bound with cords, the Apostle was a sea of generosity to us. Allah’s Messenger took his fifth of the booty. He made known on that day the extra shares for horses and their riders —giving the horse two shares and the rider one. A Muslim without a horse got one share of the spoil. It was the first booty in which lots were cast.”
Tabari VIII:39 “Then the Messenger of Allah sent Sa’d bin Zayd with some of the Qurayza captives to Najd, and in exchange for them he purchased horses and arms.”
Ishaq:503 “Allah saw what was in their hearts [what they coveted] so he rewarded them with victory and with as much spoil as they could take. Allah promised that they would soon capture a great deal of booty.”
Ishaq:508/Tabari VIII:91 “Abu Jandal, Suhayl’s son, escaped and joined Abu Basir. Nearly seventy Muslim men gathered around them and they harassed the Quraysh. Whenever they heard of a Meccan caravan setting out for Syria, they intercepted it, and killed everyone they could get a hold of. They tore every caravan to pieces and took the goods.”
Tabari VIII:93 “According to Waqidi, in this month, the Messenger sent out Ukkashah with forty men to raid Ghamr. He traveled quickly, but the enemy became aware and fled. He sent out scouts and they captured a spy who guided them to some of their cattle. They took two hundred head back to Medina.”
Tabari IX:28 “The Muslims were concerned. They did not want to give up their share. So Muhammad said, ‘He who holds a share of these captives shall get six camels for every slave from the next booty we take.’ So the Muslims returned the women and children captives.”
Qur’an 4:94 “Believers, when you go abroad to fight wars in Allah’s Cause, investigate carefully, and say not to anyone who greets you: ‘You are not a believer!’ Coveting the chance profits of this life (so that you may despoil him). With Allah are plenteous spoils and booty.” [top] [toc] [quotes main]
Then tell them to look up history of the 1700s and early 1800s all the Rape and Raids and the Dimmi Tax on all shipping in the Med? Remember the White Slaves that were taken from Ireland and England this history is not that old?
Remind that it was the Young USA who came to the Aid and that the USA was right then and is right NOW!!
As Russia ,France, and Germany need to realize that the radical states who subscribe to the militant tenets of the Quran and the hadiths will still see them as infidels in the end and will use them until they can turn on them.
Posted by: Mackie at September 23, 2004 09:51 AM
Makie Russia has seen the Turn the problem is it is to late Russia has given ALL that Iran needed and that rock is rolling down the Mountain? The big ? is will they Fight with the USA now we can not undo what is already done but we can stop the spread we have the cure are we and the rest strong enough to use it? They think we are not I say they are WRONG!!
Part of the American Tribe
Squirrel Hunter
Spider Killer
God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and ALL who Fight with her give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Defeat the Islamic Terrorist and ALL who Support them Open the Worlds Eyes to their Threat and Give them Courage to stand and Fight Amen
Talking of terrorist candidates, anyone remember that election in Algeria where the islamic front was on the verge of winning and the secular military staged a coup to prevent them from gaining power?
" Well, isn't that murder of democracy and typical western double standards?" the leftists would saivate but wait!
The islamic salvation front was campaigning on the platform of abolishing all elections and bringing in Sharia' with itself in power for perpetuity.... and those slimeballs won a majority of the votes!!!
Now we know why islam and democracy are oh-so-compatible....
You know, this is MUCH more important than it appears. If the freely chosen choice of a democratic electorate in Islamic societies is radical Islamic Shaira law and home and expanisionist Jihad abroad, then one the reasons President Bush gave for going into Iraq is wrong. If you will recall, one of his goals was regieme change the idea being that a democratic Iraq would not oppress its people. That being the case, they could practice Islam freely and run for office at home, if they chose. It is a well known belief in US government circles that "Democracies do not make war on one another" but does that apply to Islamic democracies?
IF Jihad is the people's choice and not something imposed on them by dictators, then we are facing a WWII style total war, not just a few bad governments here and there. So far the evidence in Algeria, Chechneya, and Iran where popular movements gave power to Islamists or were about to, is that this is indeed the case.
In other words, the problem in Iraq is a large percentage of the Iraqi people, not a few leftovers from Saddam's rule.
Any thought, people?
Gosh, Gary and Rikki... I don't know what to say... I thought you hated me for daring to say "Instead of asking whether the world is safer with Saddam in jail, wouldn't it be better with Osama Bin Laden in jail?"
Right now we aren't the projected path of Jeanne. If she changes course, we hit the road. Immediately.
Democracy and Islam.... (shudder.) That would really suck. Or to put it another way, imagine if the good folk of Pakistan could hold elections today. Is it crazy to assume that Bin Laden (or one of his idealogical clones) would be their next president?
Thank GOD that the military coup took over Algeria and Pakistan. At least a General is more likely to have a real education instead of a lifetime wasted reading one single book (Koran) and maybe its adenda (Hadiths.)
Or here at home, would you prefer Wes Clark, Tommy Franks, Stormin' Norman, Ike, or Admiral Stockdale... or Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, Fred Phelps, Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson?
Then of course there's General Cota and General Patton... whooo wee. The whole world would be part of America with eight years of them in office. (That would be great!) Those of you that have never heard of General Cota, especially you patriotic types, owe it to yourselves to read up on him. Use your search engine.... he was in on the D-Day invasion, and really didn't understand the concept of "fear". A real inspiration to his men.
'Or here at home, would you prefer Wes Clark, Tommy Franks, Stormin' Norman, Ike, or Admiral Stockdale... or Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, Fred Phelps, Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson?' ~KJ
None of the above. Patton, now, I think might have been interesting... Wait a moment. Didn't we have Ike for a president? :P You almost had me with that one.
I would Never turn over the government to any of those guys (other than Ike). Colin Powell would be interesting.
I will admit you do make me think a bit more (in some areas), Keith. As in, how would history have played out if Patton had been allowed to go after Russia?
It would also be interesting to read up and find out what Patton and Cota thought of the muslims at the time.
See Shamil Basayev and Zarqawi as the same : Brutal Thugs
who sadistically enjoy carving up their victims which are usually Infidels. Bleating Psychologists
would probably explain their behaviour as 'One Legged Men Syndrome'. Think CIA are now admitting
Zarqawi has TWO Legs otherwise he wouldn't be so spry doing all those beheadings for the camera...
Hey gang, hate to be a bore but one of those muslim chappies has completely lost it at the "Beheading DVDs Top Sellers In Baghdad" article. Abushcar33 , a British muslim has just impolded on Jihadwatch. He couldn't take our filthy infidel comments so "BA-BA-BOOM" he revealed the TRUE FACE OF ISLAM. Please check it out but make sure your rabies shots are up to date.
KJ wrote:///Then of course there's General Cota and General Patton... whooo wee. The whole world would be part of America with eight years of them in office. (That would be great!) ///
Hope you were sarcastic, KJ. As a right-wing Christian patriotic American, I always thought we learned a hard lesson or two about what Canadians really wanted back in 1812-15; and settled for having neighbors around. Yes, I can sure live with a lot of foreign countries, and even live and work in one where I have to go through the usual immigration rigamorale.
I can just see Besayev getting democratically elected: everyone's afraid of being shot or beheaded, so they vote for Slime-eel Besayev.
Also, KJ, don't get so excited about secularism. The 20th century murdered, displaced, jailed, and ruined more people in the name of its "Scientific" idols than suffered for the wrong kind of Christianity or none at all during the entire millenium and a half between the conversion of Constantine and 1811 (Ruggles v. New York, in which the State Supreme Court of NY upheld a conviction for blasphemy).
Also, I hold with Augustine. We have no need of religion per se, but God has made us for Himself, and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in Him (the people who will automatically change it to "her" are so so funny. HARHARHAR. Just fell off my tame dinosaur).
Kepha1~ You called it on KJ. He is right on some things, but as usual, left thinking ignores a lot of non-religous political disasterous thinking to bash the one group that has done the most to uplift the human race- Christianity. Note that, as with what Augustine said, the Founding Fathers based quite a lot of their thinking on Christian Principles, regardless of how they perceived the Deity they worshipped.
find their rest in Him (the people who will automatically change it to "her" are so so funny. HARHARHAR. Just fell off my tame dinosaur).
Posted by: Kepha1 at September 24, 2004 01:29 AM
The her reference is to the USA!!Like calling a car in the female a term of endearment not a mussi who hate women but see women in what gives the gift of birth through Gods will!
Part of the American Tribe
Squrriel Hunter
Spider Killer
God Bless the USA and her Fighting Forces and ALL who Fight with them give them Strength,Wisdom and Courage to stay the course to Defeat the Islamic Terrorist and ALL who Support them Open the Eyes of the World to their Threat Amen