Australia vilification case: Playing with fire

Andrew Bolt on the shameful conviction of the two Christian pastors in Australia. From The Herald Sun, with thanks to JE:

HOW odd that a Christian pastor has been found guilty of vilifying Islam after quoting the Koran.

Is this really what Premier Steve Bracks intended with his absurd racial and religious vilification law?

Pastor Daniel Scot and Pastor Danny Nalliah were last week found to have committed religious vilification after the first trial under this new law.

Judge Michael Higgins found Scot offended by quoting the Koran in a way that got "a response from the audience at various times in the form of laughter".

Yes, Scot made his audience of 250 Christians laugh at Islam. He didn't inspire them to burn a mosque, shout insults at Muslims, plant bombs or paint nasty slogans on fences.

He just made the audience laugh. And that in Victoria is now a crime.

But that's not the only absurdity in a case that has so far cost these two pastors more than $200,000 in costs.

The absurdities start with the excuse the Premier gave in 2001 for imposing this law, threatening us with six months' jail and $6000 fines.

"Victorians take considerable pride in the fact that people from . . . diverse backgrounds live together harmoniously in our community," he told Parliament.

Yet even though we got on well, we now had to limit our free speech -- despite Bracks conceding "freedom of expression is crucial to our democratic society".

Publicly saying hurtful things about a race or religion would now be illegal.

Fear not, Bracks soothed. This law was "confined to prohibit only the most noxious forms of conduct", and would "promote racial and religious tolerance".

But it wasn't and hasn't.

With a new law to play with, it was inevitable activists would try to use it.

Read it all.

| 16 Comments
Print | Email this entry | Digg this | del.icio.us |

16 Comments

The judge cited 13 statements that Mr. Scot made in his seminars that the judge considered vilifying of Islam. The news reporter quotes just a few of them. Does anyone know where to find all 13?

This is serious.

Bracks needs a kick where it hurts and this idiotic 'law' must be revoked.

Judge Michael Higgins, whose brainchild is he?

Been following this case for a while now:

Money buys influence. In this case it seems that the judgement has been bought.

Who would like to investigate Judge Higgins?

This kind of garbage cannot be tolerated anymore. We have to give our politicians a kick in the rear end. We have to be as organized, intense, merciless and self-sacrificing as our Muslim opposition. Otherwise, our countries will be taken away from us. We will find ourselves, like the Dutch, in less than a lifetime, waking up to find that their country is no longer Dutch but Muslim and that their only hope is immigration. Why are we allowing this to happen? Are we all so feckless and uncaring? Can we all be so stupid? WAKE UP YOU IDIOTS!

A friend told me that Australians aren't upside-down. I didn't believe him then, and now I'm certain he's wrong.

PeeCee gone gaga:

This morning in the news: Madman in England stabs 5 people, so far one dead, others severly wounded.

Italian news described the attacker as of 'turkish or middle eatern appearance'- with 'psychological' problems. This would be vague enough,-

but here comes the Aussies:

'A man' stabbed and killed-, 'a man', just 'a man'

Amen

Similar in the French hospital where 'a man' decaptiated the nurses and placed them on the TV, also just ' a man?'

The MSM is F..k...d beyon comprehension...

Sonofwalker:

Everything is upside down here mate, even the water goes down the tube the 'wrong' way.

Can't you tell?

At least we didn't send any sucker to Arafats funeral though...

Terminator:

I too find the recurring theme of a "moderate" muslim suddenly going "mad", not a co-incidence anymore. On top of the incidents you refer to, there was the Egyptian in LA, a peaceful and religious man according to neighbours, who suddenly went "mad" and gunned down the staff at the ElAl counter. Then there was the egyptian soldier, who suddenly went "mad" and killed a number of Israeli tourists. There was also the Jordanian soldier who suddenly went "mad" and killed a number of school girls at the Israeli-Jordan border. In each case the authorities were adament in sticking to the "mad" man theory. The Western press and politicians accepted this theory as fact, as the alternative was too politically dangerous.

I hear that in Australia, a "man" has taken a number of hostages and has explosives with him. No further news on the identity or cultural association of the "man" so far.

Here in the UK, the police are adament that the man who killed and stabbed several people, has a history of mental illness. Yes he has - it is known as the madness of islam.

A NOTE TO ALL AUSTRALIANS: BEWARE THE WOLVES IN SHEEP'S CLOTHING SETTING UP NEW LAWS ON YOUR SOIL...


Regarding this new law in Australia: it seems it could easily be used to outlaw Islam if implemented honestly and intelligently. Islam has (bogusly) set itself up as the ONLY religion and targets all other religions and all their followers for destruction (and agnostics and atheists too!). Who or what will save them from this horror? (Clearly not the Australian government...)

Furthermore, the koran specifically refers to Christians and Jews as descendants of apes and pigs. Read it for yourself.
Worse, Islam permits what we perceive as violent and hateful acts against and killings of non-muslims. THIS constitutes hate against religions under current hate crime statutes in the west. But all this is mysteriously being overlooked by this new Australian law.


SO it is incumbent upon us to ask WHY are Australians NOT BEING Protected from Islam by this law? Unless this law was intended as a trojan horse set up to destroy democratic freedoms of speech in Australia (by Islam). Which obviously would make this law unconstitutional under Australian law. Was this law designed to straitjacket Australians as Islam destroys Australian insitiutions and replaces them with Islam...

How many Muslims are currently holding offices in Australia?? This is an extremely troubling development as Islam is likely setting up Australians for genocide in some clandestine and sinister scheme we have yet to uncover. Aussies, watch your backs--- someone is targeting them with a dagger...

pythagoras - this law is not Australia-wide, it is in Victoria, which is a state. Hopefully, Victorians will vote this government out in the next election.

To my knowledge, there are no Muslims currently holding office in Australia (do any Aussie posters know of any?).

Most Australians are against continuing Muslim immigration. Thanks to PM John Howard's tough policies, the illegal immigration of Muslims has been stopped.

I have faith in the Australians, as I have faith in America. I wish them success. Perseverance is key. Always play your strong suit, truth.

Diana,

None that i know of, we do however, have the self procaimed Mufti of Australia.

http://www.hvk.org/hvk/articles/0204/117.html

who comes out with crap like this.

We must have some in council or dhimmi councellers suckign for votes in dense muslim suburbs, xmas is serverly cancelled, in public areas and schools in certain suburbs, this morning there was debate about it on telly thank god.

Terminator, I tried to have a hand-out ready to print so we could take it to the public. I haven't succeeded so far. It's all gone pear-shaped today. I'm expecting better results soon.

If you have time over the holidays, and if you have the interest, you can google "sonofwalkedr pamphlet" to find out more than you'll ever want to know of what I'm on about. I hope you think, as I do, that Aussies are in a golden position to hit back at last. It's true that most geezers down under won't see this as a problem as serious as a losing football team, and they might not rush into the streets to protest like they would the rise in the price of beer, but the attack on Aussie freedom has to strike a number of you folks as more than you should take. I see this case as a great chance to mobilize a united resistence in your own homeland. I think the hand-outs will make their way around the pubs till they become a topic of conversation, if they're well-done. I can write Ox-bridge till the world rights itself but Oz is more than I can do well. You folks are in a prime positon with this issue to make an issue of it.

We have a couple of contributors here who are already leafleting their neighborhoods, and we can see that there are new names here daily. As the word gets out more will come here, unfortunately, some of them trolls and groupies, but that's reality. I fwe score 99 out of 100, that's success. And I think with the court case you have going, you're in a better position to recruit than most others.

If you and others have questions that I can answer, contact susan_b to have her act as conduit. She keeps us anonymous for the better part, so there's no need of you being terrified that as my groupie screams I'm a Moslem agent in the pay of Sudan. In fact, Susan will keep little shit-heads like that from bothering you.

I'm currently resident in a foreign country, and I might stay here till the Spring. Here there are some interesting developments that I hope to involve myself in. You who are in Australia, Netherlands, Scandanavia, and England have great opportunities to do fine work. If you like, look at the way I out-line the leaflet campaign. That part I know pretty well; it's the computer work that stumps me. You can reach me through susan_b. I will be away for some parts of the holiday week but do contact me if you need anything from me. I'll return to you asap.

Before I go, if you'd like to produce a pamphlet for your community, allow me to recommend graphics from google images: "Scenes of amputation by criminal taliban in kabul" available at www.rawa.org. Also "taliban publicly execute woman." For another on women, "ipc articles, islam, a dangerous political ideology, woman hanged." And finally, google "bomber baby." Any of those images will immediately capture the interest of those who have any sense at all.

If you google my name and pamphlets or leaflets you should get a full load of details on my take, at least, on how to do this, right up to the point of providing it to others. I hope to return with some real success in the near future.

That's it for me for now. I leave the rest to my geoupie.

Regards.

Terminator: Bracks and Higgins come from an enlightenment philosophy that thinks it alone has a corner on "reason" and "logic". Go read Alasdair MacIntyre's _Whose Justice? Which Rationality?_ which followed his _After Virtue_.

I'm not for throwing rocks at liberals, but this Australian decision is one reason why I will not vote for them.

Kepha,

yes dont vote for the PC , but their adgenda is ours for the taking, after all the west is now a victem of terror and oppressed by force.......

Thanks Meredith - I forgot about our resident Jew-hater, el-Hilaly.

Paul Keating should hang his head in shame for his part in allowing this person to remain in Australia.

Kepha, I was making a pun some time back when I refereed to rock throwing. That pun would be based on Biblical Hebrew, and it had nothing to do with making insults, which I'm sure you understood but that I'll reinforce here just to be sure.