Mosque And State: Just How Close?

From the I-told-you-so Department: Business Week's article (thanks to Jerry Gordon) is subtitled "Iraq's new government may be more influenced by Islam than the U.S. hoped."

The article quotes Juan Cole, the University of Michigan prof and a leader of MESA Nostra, or the Saidist intellectual straitjacket that strangles free inquiry about Middle East issues in American universities:

Even if the clerics stay out of politics, Iraq may be on the way to a system where religion and religious laws play a bigger role than U.S. policymakers anticipate, possibly thwarting cherished American goals such as broadening women's rights and creating a freewheeling capitalist economy. "The main goal in political Islam hasn't been clerical rule. It has been the replacement of civil law with Shariah, or Islamic canon law. And that is where Iraq is headed," says Juan Cole, professor of modern Middle Eastern history at the University of Michigan. "The only question is how wide-ranging the substitution will be."

This is a distinction without a difference. If Sharia rules Iraq, it doesn't matter if Sistani or any other cleric actually has the title of head of state or not. The effect will be the same. Witness the article's conclusion:

The southern city of Basra, once relatively secular, has come to look a lot like Iran: Women are afraid to go outdoors without headscarves for fear of reprisals from the SCIRI-affiliated Badr brigades, as well as other toughs associated with the firebrand cleric Moqtada al Sadr. For ordinary Iraqis, who rules the streets may for years be more important than what ends up in the constitution.
| 15 Comments
del.icio.us | Digg this | Email | FaceBook | Twitter | Print | Tweet

15 Comments

Iraqi soil, despite all optimism to the contrary, probably requires plenty of sustained American sunlight and moisture before it can sustain the heavy demand of resources that the plant of Democracy makes before it grows into a tree. Of course, once it becomes a tree, it becomes self-sufficient, bears fruit aand provides shade and succor to all around.

Sadly, given the current world situation, a MacArthur style constitution writing and enforcement by US forces is out of question.

Will all that the US has done in the mideast go in vain? Time will tell. But at least history won't say the US didn't try its best.

If the sunni majority had voted instead of boycotting would this be any different or to they support sharia law as well?

Freedom for such jihadists as Zawahari means freedom from homosexuals (we know how they get free of them), from visible women possibly giving them "impure" thoughts (ditto), and of course freedom for all captured jihadists at Guantanamo Bay or wherever they are incarcerated.

Apparently, they do not understand our concept of freedom as freedom of choice for a religion or no religion, of thought, of dress, for any act and accepting responsibility for it, etc., under a system of laws formulated by the representatives of the population (not ideal, but then what is?). These laws can be changed or abrogated by these same representatives.

Shariah is a petrified code imposed from a distant and murky past and from above. Can it be changed, moderated, partially applied? No matter what is done under it, freedom of religion is not included (except for Muslims). As for freedom of speech--we know what happens if you say something unfavorable about the "founder." And so on, take any of our freedoms and you'll find it won't stand up under shariah.

Islam does allow freedoms that are not what G. W. Bush had in mind, such as the freedom to kill non-Muslims, freedom to incite hate for non-Muslims, freedom to treat women like domestic animals (surgically fixed, beaten, owned), we know the rest.

How there can be freedom with an established, oppressive, intolerant state ideology--take your pick, communism, nazism, Islam--is incomprehensible to our minds.

Today’s OT news and commentary, Always Jihad Related, never to be silenced.

CNN’s Treason (the War on Terror in Iraq):

http://www.townhall.com/columnists/larrykudlow/lk20050211.shtml

(not much is posted on the weekends)

And...

Can we get freedom of mosque and state in the US? Michigan for example?

It all started a long time ago with a caravan raider named Muhammad. He was the L Ron Hubbard of his time, Hubbard's most famous quote being, "If you want to get rich start a religion". L. Ron Hubbard dabbled in Satanism and the occult, while Muhammad was able to foist his hallucinations onto the unwitting Arabian masses as being divine revelations. These revelations got codified into the Koran with it's prime directive being to emulate the life of the prophet, for he has lived the most perfect life ever lived, for he is the most worthy model for all mankind.

Keep in mind folks, that Juan Cole is notoriously anti-Zionist, anti-necon, and just plain anti-American. He will say anything to discredit the Bush administration, even if it means bring attention to dark forces in the Arab world that undermine true democracy.

Nobody in their right mind believed that a democratic Iraq was going to be Switzerland, but I doubt the Shia politicians are going to do too much to alienate the other ethnic groups that have a different vision for Iraq.

I'm particularly interested to see how this will pan out for the kurds, who have been fighting faithfully alongside our boys for an opportunity for representative government...I saw one little interview with one of their representatives who was hoping we wouldn't pull out of Iraq before things are finalized and settled.

I am afraid all will be completely lost if sharia will be the ruling law of Iraq, and Bush said that is entirely possible. He said "that's democracy at work". But is it really? Already 800,000 christians have left Iraq because of bombings of their churches, forced conversions to Islam and other unspeakable crimes.

Rubelev I don't know what Juan Cole is or isn't, but I do know that the Muslims aren't exactly in love with him.

By the way, one can be Anti Zionist, Anti Neo con, and anti Jihadi, while still embracing good ole fashion American Values.

Maybe Juan Cole has a different vision of American than you do, other than say a milk cow for Israel and the Arabs.

Some Muslim Comments vis a vis Juan cole posted on a "free speech" forum (chock full of Muslims, and anti Zionist right wing Christians)


Lead article Juan Cole: Iraqi Press Reaction to Fallujah Killing

Poster comments:

rearguard writes: "Usually I find Juan Cole's opinions and commentary very informative and factual, but have a look at the parts of his comments that I exposed in red.

I find it hard to believe that Juan really thinks (or at least never questions) that Zarqawi may be something other than part of the Iraqi resistance movement. It is also noteworthy that Margaret Hassan was NOT taken hostage by "Zarqawi's" group as Juan Cole may of implied (unintentionally?).

Juan goes on to state "The Marines are, in contrast, a legitimate miliary force that is operating in Iraq with UN sanction.". Juan is being very slective in not telling the whole story and gives a false impression of US legitimacy. The invading US and puppet troops are about as illegitimate as they can possibly get! The war was NOT sanctioned by the UN, and the officially stated reasons (on record) for going to war has long since been proven to of been based on flat out lies. There simply is NO legitimacy to the invading forces.

Juan Cole seems to of forgotten that the people of Iraq have the legal and moral authority to resist foreign aggressors, while the US and its puppets can make no such claim.


ampikle
(free-thinker)
11/17/04 02:44 PM
Re: Juan Cole: Iraqi Press Reaction to Fallujah Mosque Killing [ To: rearguard | Post 293111561, reply to 293111212 ] (Score: 1)

Juan is an idiot. He might know a lot about others but from reading books. I read his column earlier as I read it often and found one thing he mentioned very profound. he said as an Amerikan and that made all the difference, to him murdering 4 people guarding their home and neighborhood in cold blood is okay.. As an amerikan... Cause as an Amerikan those doing the murdering was one of him and as an amerikan those murdered were not amerikan and that is a-okay..

The problem I have known for a few years now, They are the amerikan liberals like juan. The worst of the worst..



rearguard
(insurgent)
11/17/04 03:35 PM
Re: Juan Cole: Iraqi Press Reaction to Fallujah Mosque Killing [ To: ampikle |

Juan is discrediting himself with the comments he made. I'll be placing his website into the same bucket I've tossed the Al Jazeera website into: propaganda mixed in with a dose of real information. I'll still read his views, but with a lot more skepticism.

rearguard
(insurgent)
11/17/04 04:16 PM

I agree. Juan Cole blew his cover with that idiotic statement.

You see Rubelev, the moment that Juan Cole started to talk like an American, and not give whole hearted supported to the "insurgency" he is accused of being a Zionist agent, just as you accuse me of being the opposite.

All I can say is that there are either a bunch of simple minded folk in this world, or people with self righteous, self pitying agendas which demand "either you are with me or you are against me".

By the way there is only one outcome in a country where Muslims is the majority and that is an Islamic state (society) ruled by Shari'a.

Doesn't matter whether it is Sunni or Shi'a.

The big difference between Sunni and Shi'a is that Sunni rule is fragmented, tending to anarchial (save Saudi Arabia, which is a rather unique case in which Arab tribal leader Abdul Aziz struck a bargain with a Muslim fanatic (Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab) for "joint rule" (Attila the Hun and the Witchdoctor).

Shi'a Islam is heirarchial, where mujtahids ascend the socioeconomic ladder, and the numbers of Ayatollahs decrase in proportion to the common mullah, and tends towards centralization of authority, whereas in Sunni Islam authority (which is clerical) is dispersed.

From the aspect of doing business with international financial institutions, and companies a centralized authority is more stable, and has a better chance of honoring contracts,paying back loans, and making the reparations payments that Iraq owes Iran and which the Carlyle Group bought from Kuwait at pennies on the dollar.

The Mullahcracy of Iran, setting aside its Shari'a and rule by clerics is more stable than say a Sunni country, ruled by "elected" strongmen, whose rule is resented,hated and resisted by the mujtahids.

A Sunni governed Iraq can only be ruled by a brutal strongman, be it secular or sectarian.

From the point of view of a secular westerner,there is no difference at all between Sunni and Shi'a. From the Point of view of a global or transnational business, there is a major difference, and that difference is stability and popular support.

In Islamic countries, whether the individual likes it or not, the mullah barks roll over (issues a fatwa) and the population submits.. after all Islam means submission.

Not to worry. Even under Shariah there are guaranteed freedoms: the freedom of religion (you can choose any religion you like, as long as it is Islam), freedom to go on jihad, freedom to kill apostates, targets of a fatwa, Jews, other infidels, homosexuals, those who insult the founder, and to do anything else you wish as long as it is following the example of that most perfect of men and allowed by the jewel of perfect morality and legality, the Q'uran.

OT but
New start for 'extremist' mosque
By Daniel Sandford
BBC home affairs correspondent
In foot-high letters and in black and red, the words "a new beginning for the mosque" were printed on a banner draped from the second-floor window.
Abu Hamza al-Masri was banned from preaching inside the mosque
The incoming trustees of Finsbury Park mosque could not have made their intentions more clear.
There was a heavy police presence as over 200 Muslim men, many of them dressed in suits, attended Friday prayers - the first under the new regime at the mosque.
The khutbah, or sermon, took as its theme how Muslims need to connect better with the rest of humanity.
The new trustees, co-ordinated by the Muslim Association of Britain, had seized the mosque last Saturday, reclaiming it for the mainstream Muslim community in north London.
The Board of Trustees has always been the legal owner of the Central North London Mosque, informally known as Finsbury Park Mosque.
But their power was eroded by the controversial cleric Abu Hamza al-Masri. One senior member of the Muslim Association of Britain said it had been "hijacked by Hamza's mob".
Mr Abu Hamza turned the mosque into the public face of the extremist jihadi movement in Britain.
We will not tolerate anyone who will seek to abuse the mosque
Dr Azzam Tamimi
Muslim Association of Britain
The former Guantanamo detainee Feroz Abassi has written about his time there. He describes how he was encouraged to go to Afghanistan to attend a training camp.
Richard Reid, the failed shoebomber, also passed through the mosque, as did Djamel Beghal, who is currently on trial in France for plotting to bomb the US embassy in Paris.
Now the extremists have been cleared out of the offices and the rooms where they slept.
Dr Azzam Tamimi, of the Muslim Association of Britain, says the plan is to outnumber the extremists to persuade them to stay away.
"For the first few Fridays we will be organising for our members from across London to come and pray here so that we have a strong majority. We will not tolerate anyone who will seek to abuse the mosque," he said.
Worshippers continued to pray outside the mosque during 2004
The mosque cost £8m to build and will be able to take more than 2,000 people for prayer once the women's section has been re-opened.
The trustees now want to turn it into one of the most important centres for the Muslim community in London.
But there was an edgy feel to Friday prayers. No-one knew what to expect. The police officers in the area easily outnumbered the number of Muslim men attending the mosque, as a police helicopter flew overhead.
But apart from a couple of young hotheads, one of them hiding his face with a scarf, there was no trouble.
Finsbury Park Mosque has made a fresh start

Giaour- thanks for the info on that sunni-shiite thing.

"Maybe Juan Cole has a different vision of American than you do, other than say a milk cow for Israel and the Arabs"

As usual Giaour, you are full of it. Folks, check out the quotes by Juan Cole and tell me if you really believe that this nutcase has any legitimate "vision."

http://www.campus-watch.org/quotes.php

Two choice quotes by the "all-American" Juan Cole:


"Even medieval Islamic law recognized the right of Christians, Jews and other monotheists to practice their religion and enjoy rights to their lives and property. This relative tolerance has often been enhanced in the twentieth century by the rise of nationalism, wherein Arab Christians sometimes are privileged as symbols of national authenticity, because Christianity predated Islam in the nation's history."

"About half of Americans are terminally stupid."


I trust this guy about as far as Charles Krauthammer can throw him (and remember folks, Charles is a quadiplegic!)

Two choice quotes by the "all-American" Juan Cole:

"About half of Americans are terminally stupid."

Posted by: Rublev at February 13, 2005 02:17 PM


...and which half do you think that is... ...the half who think the Islamist threat is serious or the Michael Moore-on half who see conspiracies everywhere other than where they actually exist.







Not Peace But A Sword by Robert SpencerDid Muhammad Exist? The Muslim Brotherhood in America, by Robert SpencerIslamophobia: Thoughtcrime of the Totalitarian FutureMuslim Persecution of Christians, by Robert Spencer Obama and IslamThe Ground Zero Mosque: Second Wave of the 9/11 Attacks
The Complete Infidel’s Guide to the Koran


Stealth Jihad


The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam


The Truth About Muhammad


What they’re saying about Robert Spencer
“My comrade-in-arms, my pal, my buddy.”
Oriana Fallaci

“Robert Spencer incarnates intellectual courage when, all over the world, governments, intellectuals, churches, universities and media crawl under a hegemonic Universal Caliphate’s New Order. His achievement in the battle for the survival of free speech and dignity of man will remain as a fundamental monument to the love of, and the self-sacrifice for, liberty.”
Bat Ye’or

“Robert Spencer is indefatigable. He is keeping up the good fight long after many have already given up. I do not know what we would do without him. I appreciate all the intelligence and courage it takes to keep going despite the appeasement of the West.”
Ibn Warraq

“America's most informed, fearless, and compelling voice on modern jihadism.”
Andrew C. McCarthy, Senior Fellow at National Review Institute

“Robert Spencer is the leading voice of scholarship and reason in a world gone mad. If the West is to be saved, we will owe Robert Spencer an incalculable debt.”
Pamela Geller, Atlas Shrugs

"The consummate Islam critic and expert." — Bruce Bawer

“Over the years, we have become friends, and I have received his assistance on several pieces of legislation I proposed.”
Former Congressman Tom Tancredo

“Few people are capable of applying scholarship, analytical reasoning, and objectivity to their topic -- while simultaneously being readable and witty -- as can Robert Spencer.”
Raymond Ibrahim

“A national treasure...The acclaimed scholar of Islam.”
Frank Gaffney, Center for Security Policy

“I am indeed honored to call him my friend.”
Brad Thor, novelist

“A top American analyst of Islam....A serious scholar...I learn from him.”
Daniel Pipes

“A brilliant scholar and writer.”
Douglas Murray

"One of my best teachers."
Ashraf Ramelah, Voice of the Copts

“Thank God there’s at least one man with balls left in the West.”
Kathy Shaidle, Five Feet of Fury

“I read people like [Mark Steyn] and Bob Spencer and the rest of them, and I say, ‘Boortz, you’re pretending you’re an author. These people really are. They really write some entertaining, some standup stuff.’”
Neal Boortz

“Robert Spencer is the Stephen King of Jihad.”
Chris Gaubatz, Muslim Mafia

“Armed with facts and fearlessness, Spencer stands up for Western civilization.”
Michelle Malkin

“Widely read in conservative foreign policy circles.”
New York Times

“Widely read in many quarters in Washington.”
Washington Post

“A canny operative who likely has the inside track on the State Department’s Middle East affairs desk should the tea party win the White House.”
New York Magazine

“A hero of the American right.”
Karen Armstrong

"The leading anti-Islamic intellectual in the United States....The go-to Islam expert for the right wing."
Salon Magazine

“Robert Spencer is an Edward Said turned upside down.”
Stephen Suleyman Schwartz

“One of the nation's most notorious Islamophobes.”
Hamas-linked CAIR

"Geller and Spencer are probably the most important propagandizing Islamophobes in the world. These people's voices speak very loudly — not just here in the United States but overseas."
Heidi Beirach, Southern Poverty Law Center

“Satanic ignoramus.”
Khaleel Mohammed

“The Likud anti-Christ.”
Dar al-Hayat newspaper (Saudi Arabia)

“Zionist Crusader, missionary of hate, counter-Islam consultant.”
Al-Qaeda’s Adam Gadahn, “Azzam the American”



Follow me on Twitter
facebook islam
RSS feed

Monthly Archives



Donate
Jihad Watch is a 501 (c) 3 organization. Donations are tax-deductible.


Robert Spencer debates on The Quran Teaches WarVideo: Robert Spencer on CPAC Breitbart News
Crucified Again by Raymond Ibrahim
SIOAFreedom Defense InitiativeJihad Watch VideosAmerican Freedom Law Center
Note: Listing here does not imply endorsement of every view expressed at every linked site.

» ACT for America
» Always on Watch
» American Center for Democracy
» American Coptic Association
» American Council for Kosovo
» American Freedom Alliance
» American Freedom Law Center
» American Islamic Forum for Democracy
» American Sheepdogs
» American Thinker
» Americans Against Hate
» Americans for Legal Immigration
» Amerisrael
» Amillennialist Contra Mundum
» Annaqed
» A New Dark Age Is Dawning
» Answering Islam
» Answering Muslims
» Anti-CAIR
» Apostates of Islam
» Aramaic Broadcasting Network (ABN)
» Armies of Liberation
» Assyrian International News Agency
» Atlas Shrugs
» Atour — The State of Assyria
» Australian Islamist Monitor
» Biafra Nation
» Blazing Cat Fur
» Bosch Fawstin
» Brad Thor
» Brussels Journal
» CAIR Watch
» Campus Watch
» Caroline Glick
» Christians Under Attack
» Citizen Warrior
» Coalition for the Defense of Human Rights
» Conservative Nation News
» Copts.com
» Creeping Sharia
» Daniel Pipes
» David Horowitz Freedom Center
» The David Project
» David Thompson
» David Yerushalmi Law
» D. C. Watson
» Dearborn Underground
» DEBKAfile
» Dhimmitude.org
» Dry Bones
» Ellis Washington Report
» Europe News
» Eye On Islam
» Ezra Levant
» Faith Freedom International
» Father Zakaria
» Federale
» Five Feet of Fury
» Foundation for Democracy in Iran
» Free Congress Foundation
» The Free Copts
» Freedom Defense Initiative
» FrontPage Magazine.com
» Geert Wilders
» Genocide1915.info
» Global Research in International Affairs (GLORIA) Center
» History of Jihad
» Hizb ut-Tahrir Watch
» Honest Reporting
» Honor Killings
» Human Rights Congress for Bangladesh Minorities
» India Defence
» Infidel Blogger’s Alliance
» Infidels Are Cool
» The Intelligence Summit
» International Analyst Network
» International Free Press Society
» Internet Haganah
» The Investigative Project on Terrorism
» IOwnTheWorld.com
» IranPressNews
» Iran va Jahan
» Islam Review
» Islam Speaks
» Islam Versus Europe
» Islam Watch
» Islamic Terrorism in India
» Islamist Watch — Middle East Forum
» Israel Matzav
» JihadOnBuddhists.org
» Kejda Gjermani
» KRSI: Radio Sedaye Iran
» Liberated
» Logan's Warning
» Looking At the Left
» Mahdi Watch
» Mapping Sharia
» Mark Steyn
» Martin Kramer
» MEMRI TV
» Middle East Facts
» Middle East Quarterly
» Middle-East-Info.org
» Middle East Media Research Institute
» Middle East Review of International Affairs (MERIA)
» Militant Islam Monitor
» Morning Star
» Muhammad Tube
» The Muslim Issue
» Muslim World Today
» Myths and Facts
» National Vietnam & Gulf War Veterans Coalition
» NewsReal Blog
» No Mosques At Ground Zero
» Nonie Darwish
» Northeast Intelligence Network
» Occidental Jihadist
» One Jerusalem
» Open Speech
» Operation Give
» Operation Gratitude
» Organiser
» Orwellian Culture
» Palestinian Media Watch
» PamelaGeller.com
» Panun Kashmir
» Pedestrian Infidel
» The People's Cube
» The People of the Book
» Persecution Project
» Political Islam
» Politically Incorrect
» Politiskt Inkorrekt
» Q Society of Australia
» Radio Farda
» Radio Jihad
» RAWA: Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan
» Raymond Ibrahim
» Red Alerts
» Refugee Resettlement Watch
» Religion of Peace
» Republican Riot
» Reuters Middle East Watch
» The “Reverend” Jim Sutter
» SANE: Society of Americans for National Existence
» The Second Draft
» Shire Network News
» SITE Intelligence Group
» Small Wars Journal
» Smoke-Filled World
» The Snooper Report
» Snow Report Blog
» StandWithUs
» Steve Lackner
» The Stiletto Blog
» STOP! Honour Killings
» Sultan Knish
» Tell the Children the Truth
» Terrorism Awareness Project
» Theodore’s World
» Tom Gross Media
» Translating Jihad
» Una via per Oriana
» Undaunted
» United States Central Command
» Urban Infidel
» Walid Shoebat
» Winds of Jihad
» Women Against Shariah
» World Council for the Cedars Revolution
» Yid With Lid
» Z Street
» Zilla of the Resistance
» Zionist Conspiracy
David LittmanOriana Fallaci Thousands of Deadly Terror Attacks Since 9/11The incredible Reza Aslan automated insult generator! iGoogle Gadget
Site Meter