Perhaps if Congress does not have the stomach or ability to stop the squandering of American resources in Iraq for a fool's errand of a policy, it can at least put a stop to the payment of Jizyah to the "Palestinians." That means blocking the $86 million the Administration wants to give the Slow Jihadists -- who are, if Abbas' language is to be taken into account, not all that "Slow" in any case -- so that they, who are already so well-armed, can become even stronger.
They have been pleading, just like assorted "Iraqis," for more, more, more weapons from the Americans, claiming that "of course" these will strengthen the forces of "moderation." Doesn't the AP, doesn't Reuters, always affix the Homeric epithet "moderate" before the name "Mahmoud Abbas"? And strengthening the forces of “moderation” is, of course, a Good Thing, since those force will then be able to wrest control from the “extremists.” That means they will be able to wrest the contents of the "Palestinian" bank accounts and all that foreign aid or Jizyah that will start to flow, because the Slow Jihadists love high living and are far more corrupt than the Fast Jihadists. That is the essential difference between Fatah's True but Corrupt Believers and Hamas's Even Truer and Less Corrupt Believers.
Stop the goddam Jizyah. If you can't stop the half-trillion that has gone to prevent sectarian and ethnic strife in Iraq that we should welcome and even encourage, then for god's sake at least take a stand on the Jizyah -- the Jizyah to Pakistan, creator and supporter and now meretricious protector of the Taliban and of many other Islamic groups dangerous to India and to the Infidels everywhere. Stop the Jizyah to Egypt, Egypt the sinister kleptocracy, the world center of antisemitism and anti-Americanism. Stop the Jizyah to Jordan, whose "plucky little kinglet" (son of the "plucky little king") is, thanks to Noor and Rana and plummy-voiced Prince Hassan, such a perennial crowd-pleaser. But what a crock, what a thin veneer, what a facade of rationality on a country quivering with anti-American and anti-Infidel hate. And stop, above all stop the Jizyah to that favorite cause of Western leaders wishing to avoid the matter of Islam, wishing to postpone the day of reckoning, wishing not to think about the arms of NATO or the lands of NATO falling into the wrong hands and becoming controlled by the Camp of Islam. And so, in their failure and ignorance and wish to avoid confronting reality, they always rush to give toys and good things to eat to the "Palestinians" and to reinforce, in their own minds, the dreamy belief that "if only" Israel and the "Palestinians" can come to an agreement, everything will simmer down. Oh, sure they can come to an agreement -- an agreement that will be broken, and must be broken, on the model of Muhammad's Treaty with the Meccans at Hudaibiyyah, just as soon as the Arab Muslims feel strong enough to go in for the kill.) They can come to an agreement, and then this little blip during which "extremists" seemed to have found an audience will end, and things will continue as before.
And as for the islamization of Western Europe through Da'wa and demographic conquest -- fugeddaboutit.
This is the level of thought that prevails in the chanceries of the West. The Americans are hardly the worst. But if the Bush Administration persists in this and other follies, it must be stopped by the sane and well-informed members of Congress, Republican and Democratic.
One waits for Tom Tancredo and others to declare their opposition, and to put that opposition in the terms used here: Stop the Jizyah. And explain why American aid to Muslim peoples and polities has become a kind of Jizyah, and why it must end. It must end so that the Americans and other Westerners break the habit of submission, of feeling that somehow they owe this to the "Palestinians," or to Egypt, or to Pakistan, or to Jordan. And it must end in order to break or disabuse the recipients from their confidence that they have this Jizyah coming to them, and the Western Infidels would not dare to permanently cut them off.
And finally, the Jizyah paid by Western governments should end so that the poorer Arabs and Muslims are forced to demand money from the rich Arabs, who are drowning in unearned wealth, so that they, those Saudis, those denizens of Kuwait and the U.A.E. and Qatar, with their tiny populations and hundreds of billions of dollars, will have to show or explain why they are not showing that famous solidarity and loyalty to fellow members of the world-wide Umma al-islamiyya. And since they will never provide what the "Palestinians" consider their due, or if it is provided the "Palestinians" will come back for more, all kinds of unhappiness and resentments will develop. For “Palestinians” do not have the habit of work, but only of warfare, and besides, Gaza and the West Bank are essentially unviable economically. The people there, though no one will say it aloud, can only continue to exist on a permanent dole. When they come back for more this will begin to grate on those Saudis, those Qataris, those Kuwaitis, and all the others.
And that is a Good Thing. Because along with the Sectarian and Ethnic Fissures on display in Iraq, the third great fissure within the Camp of Islam is Economic, between the fabulously rich oil states and peoples, and those without the manna of oil and gas. The economies of the latter states are as wretched as would be those of the Muslim oil states if those states did not possess that oil, that gas, those trillions in unearned and unmerited oil wealth.
The Jizyah masquerading as Foreign Aid to the Umma should of course be stopped. All our assitance to our enemies through foreign aid amounts to a pittance next to the flow of petrodollars to them.
$75 to $100 million a day to Saudi Arabia $60 million a day to Nigeria, $30 million a day to Kuwait, $2.5 million to Lybia. Here is the real Jizyah we are paying.
We must have a "New Manhattan Project" aimed at energy independence. Finance this with a $25 a barrel tax on Umma Oil. Once we have slipped the leash of Islamic oil we can sit back and watch from afar the newly impoverished Umma destroy itself.
Thats what we get for accepting welfare as kindness to the downtrodden!!!
Why feed people whose only achievemeny is self-pity and hate?
Millions for Defense, Not One Cent for Tribute.
Webb knows this phrase. He may be the one to run with it. It's more sellable than Jizyah.
During the time of Muhammad[3] and later in Middle Ages, Jewish writers commonly referred to Muhammad as ha-meshuggah ("the madman" or "possessed"), a title contemptuously used in the Hebrew Bible for impostors who think of themselves as prophets.[4]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Muhammad
dennisw:
My Yiddish stinks, but "al-meshuga" as a nickname for Mohammed strikes me as a little bit of a stretch.
Given that Abbas has already been caught advocating turning the weapons recently promised to him against Israelis rather than to quell the sectarian violence in the PA, giving support in any form to Fatah seems to go beyond "jizyah".
"those Saudis, those denizens of Kuwait and the U.A.E. and Qatar, with their tiny populations and hundreds of billions of dollars, will have to show or explain why they are not showing that famous solidarity and loyalty to fellow members of the world-wide Umma al-islamiyya"
....When questioned about this, the rich ones tell them it is Americans fault, then promptly provided money and weapons to go fight the Americans...
I WANT MY JIZYAH!
Hugh said
With all their levels of conflicting loyalties (to Islam, to Islamic sect, to nation, to clan, to ethnicity), it becomes exponentially more difficult to predict their reactions, than say, the outcome of a chess move. But who cares what their reaction will be or who they will blame. Just stop the damned jizya, indeed. Let the viper's nest sort itself out. With no a$$i$$tance from the infidels. Not one more penny.
This viewpoint is not yet popular enough to merit criticism by domestic Islamic apologists, but one day this may be labeled "the new isolationism", and all sorts of comparisons made to pre-WWII U.S. And of course it is nothing of the sort. We should simultaneously increase our ties to non-Islamic nations around the world. Infidel nations unite!
For “Palestinians” do not have the habit of work, but only of warfare, and besides, Gaza and the West Bank are essentially unviable economically.
I agree they don't have the habit of work. But Gaza and the West Bank are economically unviable ONLY due to the very fact of the backward and lazy polulation inhabiting it.
Luxembourg and Liechtenstein are small entities who have no oil or other natural resources and still they are quite successful little statelets.
If islam wasn't in the West Bank and Gaza I could imagine banking and a thriving Casino industry a la Monaco which does rather well with that.
It's strictly due to the proliferation of islam that these territories are and must remain a wasteland.
I strongly encourage the guvments of the Free West to stop wasting our hard-earned money on these people and do as Hugh suggests: Let their wealthy oil-rich brethren take care of them for a change!! Put the moral onus on them for the World to see!! Same for the next Tsunami or earthquake.
I'd like to point out to freedom1776 that over the years, even much of the US's oil payments has been foreign aid --or jizyah if you like. This disguised foreign aid was based on the Foreign Tax Credit. See: http://ziontruth.blogspot.com/2005/09/kindly-making-arabia-rich.html
http://ziontruth.blogspot.com/2005/09/what-does-left-really-mean-in-2005.html
a fool and his money are soon parted....