Accused Fort Dix jihadists denied bail, but not opportunity for prison dawa

"Prosecutors' argued that at least one defendant had been promoting jihad, or Muslim holy war, against the West, among other inmates at a Philadelphia detention center where they are being held."

An update on this story. "Men accused of U.S. army base attack plot denied bail," from Reuters:

CAMDEN, New Jersey (Reuters) - A U.S. federal judge on Thursday denied bail to five Muslim men accused of plotting an armed attack on New Jersey's Fort Dix army base.
Judge Robert Kugler rejected claims by lawyers for the men that they had been denied proper access to information that may be used against them at trial. The lawyers argued the men needed to be released on bail in order to get proper access.
The five men pleaded not guilty in June to charges of plotting to kill U.S. soldiers at the Fort Dix military base, located about 40 miles east of Philadelphia, and to possessing illegal weapons.
They are Yugoslav-born ethnic Albanian brothers Eljvir, Dritan and Shain Duka, all illegal immigrants who ran a roofing busineses in Cherry Hill, New Jersey; Mohamad Shnewer, a Jordanian-born taxi driver from Philadelphia; and Serdar Tatar, a Turkish-born convenience store clerk.
Prosecutors' argued that at least one defendant had been promoting jihad, or Muslim holy war, against the West, among other inmates at a Philadelphia detention center where they are being held, but Kugler said he was not convinced.
The judge, who previously denied bail to the men shortly after their May 2007 arrest, rejected a request by prosecutors to make public a video that they say was used by Shnewer in the detention center to attract recruits to jihad.
Kugler said the "inflammatory" video includes "exhortations" by a figure that looks like Osama bin Laden, and images of dead and maimed people who "could be Muslims."
Public access to the disc would risk prejudicing a jury whose likely members have already been exposed to extensive media coverage of the charges against the men, he said.
The trial, already postponed twice, is currently scheduled to begin on March 24.
| 13 Comments
Print this entry | Email this entry | Digg this | del.icio.us |

13 Comments

"The judge, who previously denied bail to the men shortly after their May 2007 arrest, rejected a request by prosecutors to make public a video that they say was used by Shnewer in the detention center to attract recruits to jihad."

....since when are prisoners allowed to show home movies?.....

Muslim inmates conducting Da'wa (that is, a great many of those inmates) should be segregated in Muslim-only wards. On what grounds? On the grounds of national security.

But how is this argument to be made? Not by those who simply know little or nothing of Islam. The ground has to be properly prepared -- the mental ground of the prosecutors, and of the judges who will be decidiing such cases. If the argument is properly presented (and this requires prosecutors well-versed in the texts and tenets of Islam, and the Western scholarship that will support them)nds, any challenge brought under the equal protection clause should be met with the claim, not hard to prove, that national security -- keeping people from conducting work to multiply the number of "Jihadists" permanently hostile to this country's political and legal institutions, and prepared to act on that hostility -- is a state interest sufficiently compelling to withstand any such Fifth-and-Fourteenth-Amendment challenge.

It can and should be done. The in-prison Da'wa proceeds apace,and it is not enough to suggest that missionaries of other faiths should go and do likewise. The systematic and well-financed (with or without money from foreign, especially Saudi, sources) campaigns of Da'wa, targetting prisoners (especially black prisoners) have to be not merely monitored, but curtailed. If there are Muslim-only cell-blocks or, better, prisons, especially for those arrested for these kind of offenses, that will make the conduct of Da'wa impossible.

It will be a case of preaching to the reverted.

"Muslim inmates conducting Da'wa (that is, a great many of those inmates) should be segregated in Muslim-only wards. On what grounds? On the grounds of national security."

...I second the motion...

No religion in prisons.

Four walls, three meals, two to a cell, one reason for being there and that's punishment.

Serbians have to live with this mindset each day in their almost-lost province of Kosovo.

Same thing in Canada, probably all over. Canadian authorities even recognized whats' happening, but then said they're not going to do anything about it. I think the article was posted here in the past month.

Albania used to be part of Western Civilization, part of Europe, part of our way of life. But no more. Albania is now an Islamic country.

The Islamization of Albania is sad but predictable. When Islam arrives, kiss your culture and your way of life good-bye.

How many more pieces of Europe, of Western Civilization, will be eaten by Islam? Well, if history is any guide, the answer is: All of them.

This is because Western Civilization confers religion upon Islam.

Someday, we may realize that Islam is not a religion. Then we will be able to defend what's left of our lands and our people. After 1,400 years of predation by Muslims, one would think we would grow a sack. But we won't.

Well said, Mike. Well said.

It was the EIJ who set up shop in Albania right after assassinating Sadat.

The EIJ, if this is possible to believe, are the guys who made crazy guy Bin Laden, even crazier.

Al Qaeda's number two's brother, Mohammed, spent most of his exile years in the Balkans. He spent his last miserable moments on this miserable planet being tortured by the Egyptian security services after being caught in the Balkans. It doesn't bear thinking about. The whole operation must have cost the Egyptian Gov't a pile. New Pliars. Big electricity bill. Black and Decker servicing bills. It must have cost a pretty penny.

Anyhow, to you and me, guys like him are just psycho crazies, BUT, to NATO they became the key link for their heroic liberation of Kosovo.

Yes, now's the time to come clean. The very same guys who were naughty when they slaughtered a couple of 1,000 yuppies on 9 11 were the very same chaps who murdered, with NATO orders, a couple of 1,000 a couple of years earlier in Kosovo.

The big difference was, in Kosovo, their victims were worthless peasants and so not real people. So they became a punchline to a 1,000 NeoCon blogs and late night talk shows.

The victims, ethnic Albanian, ethnic Serb, Roma and Jewish, were just an idle, indolent belch in TV channel hopping land. Nothing more.

In order to liberate place A, NATO style, it takes

a) heroin dealers like the KLA
b) child sex slave dealers like the KLA
c) Nazi/Maoist thugs like the KLA
and most importantly
d) Mujahideen target spotters like, well, the Mujaideen.

Yup. Slobo's government was supported by ALL the minorities and also by a significant minority of ethnic Albanians, made up largely of the minority Catholic Kosovo Albanians who'd started up a couple or so pro Belgrade parties, but he was trumped by NATO's merry band of psycho nuts.

YUP. It's an equation that Sir Isaac Newton left out.

Nutters + Self Hating Western Gov't > Poor innocent fcukers

Really, this has all been proven time and time again. Look out of the window for corroboration

The psychos will indeed rule the world. The meek are just too, well, meek.

Ah, EWHA1, I doubt that westerners will ever understand what really happened in Yugoslavia...

"minority Catholic Kosovo Albanians"

Was Mother Theresa born in Albania? What happened to the Albanian Church?

Make it Muslim-only prisons, regardless of the offense. Wards can't be cordoned off reliably.

The big problem: can Muslims be denied employment as guards at this or any other prison on the same national security grounds? Otherwise they pose a security risk, in that they can serve as interlocutors, carrying messages out of and into the prison. The same goes for the imam.

National security and civil rights bump up against one another. Civil rights will win because otherwise we are judging people for who they are and not for what they have done.

Freedom can be inconvenient at times.

"Make it Muslim-only prisons, regardless of the offense. Wards can't be cordoned off reliably."


....there are empty prisons in the US, such as Alcatraz that could be readily refurbished and filled with Muslims only....

My brother-in-law is sitting in Fort Dix right now. He'll be going to Iraq eventually as an MP and will most likely be guarding a prison full of 'detainees' in central Iraq for a year or more.

I had a visit with him while he was home on leave and gave him the P.I.G. and asked him to read it so that he'll understand some background and so he'll get a perspective to balance out the official explanation of Why, How, Who and What. He said he would - he'd have plenty of time on the way over to Kuwait. I hope he passes it on. I think he will.

Prislam - all the rage.