So says Pamela Geller in an interview with Jamie Glazov of FrontPage magazine today on the Rifqa Bary case -- the girl who converted from Islam to Christianity and then fled her home in fear for her life.
Everyone is watching to see what happens to Rifqa. She has become a test case for everyone. The Muslims, the Islamic supremacists, want to prove that a young girl cannot break free, cannot break out of their web, even in America. More importantly, it is a case being watched by every subjugated Muslim dying to break free of the shackles of Islam. If Rifqa can do it and is protected, so can they. This is why it is so critical that she be broken by the Islamic machine.It's a test case for free people, and for America also. Will American courts knuckle under to Islamic intimidation and implement Sharia provisions for the isolation of female apostates? Will we stand up and defend religious freedom? Do Muslim girls in the same situation as Rifqa have any hope? Rifqa's case will show the answer.
Pamela's efforts in behalf of Rifqa are really good karma as are Spencer's and the rest of the Rifqa supporters...
Personally I am more than appalled at the kufrs demonizing, and working against Rifqa, in the media and in person...I am royally pzzed off, and it will get much worse if they sink her ship. The audacity of these people who seem to think it is their sacred duty to gamble with her life...I can see this coming from CAIR and other Mahoundians, but kufrs? Do we need another title KINO...Kufrs In Name Only? So now we have RINO, DINO, MINO, KINO and AINO...Is anyone for real? I'm getting confused...
Another honor killing?
Say no to Sharia and freedom for Muslims to check out.
PINORs - Politicians In Need Of Re-election.
It's a test case for free people, and for America also.
....................
Pamela Geller could not be more correct. What happens to little Rifqa Bary will, I believe, set much of the tone of how not only we Americans handle the threat of Islam, but the West in general.
Let us act bravely and wisely. Kudos to Robert and Pamela for leading the fight for this young girl's life!
One can only wonder how much influence Ohio's governor has on this case, since it is reported he has basically been bought out by jihadists and their supporters.
All religions have criminals in them.
This christian preacher sexually abused his daughter and murdered his wife
http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/07/31/preacher.freezer/index.html
All religions have criminals in them.
This christian preacher sexually abused his daughter and murdered his wife
http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/07/31/preacher.freezer/index.html
If this is true then it is very sad and it needs to come out so the christians can deal with it fairly.
But, he does not represent all Christian and this is a good way to side track from the real issue, Rifqa is being denied her civil rights and right to religious freedom. Ohio seems to be follwing sharia law vs rule of law.
Are you a liberal or an apologist for the Islamacist?
Are you a charter member of CAIR?
45cp is an Islamic apologist. As all Islamic apologists, he ignores the beam in his eye, but notices the mote in others.
All religions have criminals in them.
This christian preacher sexually abused his daughter and murdered his wife
http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/07/31/preacher.freezer/index.html
If this is true then it is very sad and it needs to come out so the christians can deal with it fairly.
But, he does not represent all Christian and this is a good way to side track from the real issue, Rifqa is being denied her civil rights and right to religious freedom. Ohio seems to be follwing sharia law vs rule of law.
Are you a liberal or an apologist for the Islamacist?
Are you a charter member of CAIR?
Geller has been perfectly heroic on this subject.
Eagle,
The case of the preacher sexually abusing his daughter and murdering his wife is one of many cases where preachers have become murderers.
What does it teach us ? Religions are able to influence behavior but religion does not determine behavior since every human being has free will.
Likewise, Islam is able to influence behavior but every muslim has the free will to either act on the teachings of islam or not, just as Timothy McVeigh was influenced by US foreign policy but US foreign policy never overrides any person's free will.
I am a christian defending the rights of muslims to believe as they want to but all criminal behavior has to be prosecuted.
Nobody should be forced to believe in anything and everybody should be allowed to preach his religion freely or leave his religion freely and everybody should be free to insult any religion no matter how bad the insult.
There are many reformers in Islam who believe as I do in everybody's free right to practice any religion or no religion at all or insult any religion
"There are many reformers in Islam who believe as I do in everybody's free right to practice any religion or no religion at all or insult any religion"
Are those reformers dead or alive? Because I'm going with dead.
Great! So 45ch, what are you doing to support Rifqa's right, as a human being and as a girl living in America, to practice her religion the way she sees fit and to protect her from the father who said he would kill her if she "has this Jesus" in her heart?
I think we can agree and if this preacher is guilty then he deserves to be prosecuted. I don't know the whole case and CNN is a source I rarely trust but it could have some merit, let me look at this link again. I am not religious but I do believe in freedom of religion or no religion. I am more universal and spiritual.
It is true evil can be found everywhere when it comes to human institutions; religious or political.
I am aware of some groups who want reform such as muslimsagainstsharialaw and at least one or two others you can find as a link on this forum.
Reformation has already taken place in numerous muslim countries that do not have sharia :
Burkina Faso
Chad
Gambia
Guinea
Mali
Senegal
Somalia
Kazakhstan
Kyrgystan
Tajikstan
Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan
Albania
Azerbaijan
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Kosovo
Turkey
here are at least four muslim organizations that are working at reformation in the muslim world :
The Center Party of Egypt (Hizb ul-Wasat ), Turkey's ruling AKP Party, Tehreek i Insaf Party of Pakistan and Iran's Defenders of Human Rights Center are four of numerous muslim organizations and muslim reformers who don't hate muslims but want reformation in the muslim world.
here is a partial list of reformers in the muslim world :
Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im
Leila Ahmed
Reza Aslan
Mehdi Bazargan
Samira Bellil
Assia Djebar
Hamid Dalwai
Shirin Ebadi
Mawlana Faizani
Ahmad Ghabel
Asma Jahangir
Ghada Jamshir
Afrasiab Ahmad
Afrasiab Khattak
Kadizadeli
Mohammad Khatami
Mohsen Kadivar
Syed Ahmed Khan
Fatema Mernissi
Irshad Manji
Şihabetdin Märcani
Mostafa Malekian
Asra Nomani
Abdolkarim Soroush
Ali Shariati
Mohammad Mojtahed Shabestari
Yousef Sanei
Hassan al-Turabi
Mahmoud Mohamed Taha
Mahmoud Taleghani
Amina Wadud
Fareed Zakaria
Nasr Abu Zayd
Warith Deen Mohammed
Here are a list of prominent muslims and organizations who condemned Al-Qaeda for the attacks on 9/11 plus other reformers, organizations or countries that have pushed for reform in some way :
(1) Ibn Taymiya
(2) According to 18th century records, the Ottoman empire - Islam's ruling power - had not flogged, imprisoned, or passed the death sentence on adulterers for nearly 400 years.
ref : http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2007/sep/28/theislamicreformation
(3) Muslim Canadian congress
(4) Tariq Ramadan
(5) Salman Al-Audah
(6) Shah Waliullah
(7) Aqa Bihbihani
(8) Reformed Shi'sim or Bahai
(9) Ahmadiyya movement
(10) Deoband movement
(11) All Salafi Scholars spoke against present so called jihad and they hold thier opinion as ""No individual has the right to take the law into his own hands on any account. Even the closest of Muhammad's companions never killed a single of his opponents even when invectives were hurled at him day and night in the first thirteen years of his Da'wah at Makkah. Nor did they kill anyone in retaliation when he was pelted with stones at Ta'if"".
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salafi#Current_disagreements_and_division
(12) Fiqh Council of North America
(13) Ali Gomaa, the grand mufti of Egypt and one of the highest-ranking clerics in the Sunni Muslim world
(14) Amina Wadud
(15) Laleh Bakhtiar
(16) Abdullahi Ahmed An-Naim, muslim legal scholar
(17) Mahmoud Mohamed Taha
(18) Javed Ghamidi of muslim satellite TV
(19) Shaykh Waheeduddin Khan, another mainstay of Muslim satellite TV
(20) Amr Khaled
(21) Farhat Hashmi
(22) Indonesian president Bambang
(23) Junoon, a sufi muslim
(24) Akbar Ganji in Iran
(25) REZA ASLAN
(26) IRSHAD MANJI
(27) RIFFAT HASSAN, Ph.D. Professor of Religious Studies and Humanities
(28) KASSIM AHMAD, former president of Malaysian Socialist Party
(29) GATUT ADISOMA, PhD, Indonesia
(30) Layth Saleh al-Shaiban
(31) AISHA Y. MUSA, PhD, Assistant Professor of Islamic Studies
(32) Abdel Moneim Mohammed of the Muslim Brotherhood who wants to reform the Muslim Brotherhood
ref : http://www.boston.com/news/world/africa/articles/2007/10/11/egypts_brotherhood_party_details_platform_akin_to_that_of_iran/
(33) Abdel Moneim Said, head of the leading Al Ahram Center for Strategic and Political Studies
(34) Shirin Ebadi, the Nobel Prize winner
(35) Rahim Jahanbegloo, called "the Iranian Gandhi" for his non-violent approach to protest.
(36) Ayatollah Kazemeini Boroujerdi.
(37) Muhammad Sa'id al-Ashmawi
(38) Muhammad Khalaf-Allah
(39) Nurcholish Madjid of Indonesia
(40) Fazlur Rahman,
(41) The Center Party of Egypt (Hizb ul-Wasat )
(42) Turkey's ruling AKP Party
(43) Tehreek i Insaf Party of Pakistan
(44) Shaykh Yusuf Qaradawi
(45) Ayatollah Muhammad Husain Fadlallah of Lebanon
(46) AbdulHakim Murad
(47) Shaykh Muhammad Afifi al-Akiti
(48) Shaykh Hamza Yusuf
(49) Shaykh Muhammad Sayyed Tantawi
(50) Ayatollah Ali Khamanei of Iran
(51) Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Iranian scholar
(52) Muzammil H. Siddiqui
(53) Shaykh Muhammad Sayyed Tantawi, Grand Imam of Al-Azhar University
(54) Shaykh Muhammad al-Munajjid
(55) Imam Zaid Shakir
(56) Tahir ul Qadri, Pakistani cleric
(57) AbdulHakim Murad, scholar
(58) Muzammil H. Siddiqui
(59) Moiz Amjad, Pakistani scholar
(60) Sheikh Abderrahman al-Sudayes
(61) Shaikh Abdulaziz Al-Ashaikh
(62) Shaykh Abdul-Aziz Aali-Shaykh
(63) Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia and President of the Committee of Senior Scholars
(64) Shaykh Saleh Al-Lehaydaan, Chief Justice Of The Saudi Arabian Judiciary
(65) Shaykh Dr. Saaleh Ibn Ghaanem As-Sadlaan, Pres. Higher Studies Dept. Al-Imaam Muhammd Ibn Saud Islamic University
(66) Khaled Abou El Fadl
(67) Jamil Abdul Razzak Hajoo, of Idriss Mosque, Seattle
(68) Shaykh Abdul Azeez bin Abdullah bin Baaz
(69) Shaykh Muhammad Bin Saalih al Uthaymeen
(70) Hamza Yusuf
(71) Shaykh Salah al-Lahidan, head of the Islamic Judiciary of Saudi Arabia
(72) Imam Siraj Wahhaj
(73) Ali abd al-Raziq
(74) Mustafa Kemal Ataturk
(75) Reza Shah of Iran
(76) Ahmad Kasravi of Iran
(77) Habib Bourguiba of Tunisia
(78) Ya'qub Sarruf of Egypt
(79) Faris Nimr of Egypt
(80) Nicola Haddad of Egypt
(81) Hizb 'Almani or the Wafd party of Egypt
(82) Arab nationalist Baath Party of Syria
(83) Azza Karam
(84) Rabat Al-Mar’a Al`arabiyya (the Alliance for Arab Women)
(85) Faraj Foda
(86) Dr. Muhammad Imara
(87) Shirin Ebadi of Iran
(88) Nazanin Afshin-Jam of Iran
Isabella,
Two independent investigations in Ohio and Florida found no credible evidence that Rifqa Bary's life was in danger
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fathima_Rifqa_Bary_controversy
Honor killing is wrong and evil, no matter what the girl has done, just as the murder of a girl by her jealous boyfriend or husband in this country is wrong and evil, but sadly and tragically, more crimes of passion ( the murder of intimate partners) go on in this world than honor killings by muslims.
About 2000 annual murders of intimate partners in the US alone, compared to 5000 annual honor killings world wide, so you can imagine the total number of intimate partners being killed world wide in the non-muslim world.
ref : http://www.soundvision.com/Info/domesticviolence/statistics.asp
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honor_killing
Let's try again, shall we?
Rifqa Bary is currently under house arrest in a foster home in Columbus, Ohio. She has no access to her friends via visits, telephone conversations or email. Rifqa's crime? She apostasized from Islam and became a Christian. Now we know, as you know, that Muslim who leave Islam are threatened with death. The Prophet Mohammad said, "Any one who leaves his religion, kill him." Muslim clerics around the world enforce the prophet's edict by issuing fatwas demanding the death of apostates and promising eternal rewards and forgiving legal ramifications to any Muslim who will here the call and act. Ibn Warraq, Nonie Darwish, Magdi Cristiano Allam, Mark Gabriel and Walid Shoebat are just a few of the more well known former Muslim who left Islam and became Christians, and every one of them has a fatwa hanging over his/her head. So you are either lying 45ch or ignorant.
I think you're lying. You know that Rifqa is in danger of being murdered if she's sent back to her parents and I think you're totally fine with it. (Can't have any dissent if you want to keep the Good Old Boys Worship-the-Penis-Club intact. ; ) I think you're lying when you say you are a Christian because you don't seem to understand the basic concept of "Love your neighbor as yourself" or "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you". You seek to vilify Christianity but don't bother to apologize for it's supposed actions, something you would do if you were really a Christian and you really feel bad about something that was done in the name of Christianity. You also give the standard pro-Islamic response of "Two independent investigations in Ohio and Florida found no credible evidence that Rifqa Bary's life was in danger".
Nobody's buying, 45ch, and you are simply not clever enough to pull that wool over our eyes. I've got to give you an "E" for effort though, even if you get an "F" for your lack of perception, attempting to shovel the same old same old here. Give us a break, will ya?
@45ch
The decision by the Florida court was wrong and you are wrong or ignorant on the subject of honor killings.
Don't you think it would be wise to error on caution regarding the girl (almost a woman).
Read a little more on the blog and do a little more studying about Islam. You don't know want you are talking about.
Here is an example. You say you are a Christian. If I disagreed with you according to Christ's teaching I could have you taken before the authorizes and possible have you stoned. This is what Islam teaches at its core. One last thing do you know when 99% of the muslims became muslims? When they were born into it. Is that how you became a Christian? Were is the free will in that? And remember if you apostate from Islam you are a dead man.
Lastly, from what I have studied and learned, Islam is antithetical to everything of virtue that is taught by Christ's love and example. This religion (I am being generous) is a cancer on this world and has been festering for 1400 years. Just another example of the sinfulness of man wouldn't you agree.
Here is an example. You say you are a Christian. If I disagreed with you according to Christ's teaching I could have you taken before the authorizes and possible have you stoned. This is what Islam teaches at its core. One last thing do you know when 99% of the muslims became muslims? When they were born into it. Is that how you became a Christian? Were is the free will in that? And remember if you apostate from Islam you are a dead man.
That was not the teachings of Christ - remember the parable of the woman caught in adultery or do you know it? This was the teaching of the Pharisees and other religious leaders of his time. True everyone by birth is a Muslim but in Christianity it is a free will chose to follow Christ, unless it is some weird cult- I mean today and not in history. so true - you are dead if you leave Islam! I spent time in Turkiye and taught so I have been immersed into an Islamic but at the same time a secular culture. Still Turkiye has limited religious freedom and this could happen there in secret. I witnessed the covert lack of religious freedoms there. love the Turkish people but I hate what is happening to Rifqa.
that is saying a lot also - I am half Greek my friend oh must rush off
45ch: If that preacher mentioned by 45 really did murder his wife, then he deserves to hang. See Genesis 9.6. Pull a dozen Christian fundamentalists out of a crowd at random, present the case to them, they'll probably say the same thing, rather than come up with an "honor killing" excuse.
I hope the world keeps watching the Rifqa Bary case. It's probably what's kept the girl from being murdered by now.
@eaglecap
You are correct. I was being sarcastic, talking to 45ch. This was just to drive home the point about Islam and everyone else when it come to doctrine. That is why I said what I said in my last paragraph.
45ch gives a list of "muslim countries that do not have sharia"
Yet all of these, except Bosnia, are signatories of the Cairo Islamic Declaration on Human Rights, which declares that Islamic law takes precedence over any other laws or treaties.
LET'S ALL SEND RIFQA BARY CHRISTMAS CARDS TO BELOW ADDRESS AND LET HER KNOW THAT WE ARE PRAYING FOR HER SAFETY.
Rifqa Bary
c/o Angela Lloyd
255C Drinko Hall
55 West 12th Avenue
Columbus, OH 43201
45ch wrote:
Reformation has already taken place in numerous muslim countries that do not have sharia :
Burkina Faso
Chad
Gambia
Guinea
Mali
Senegal
Somalia
..................
Is that the same Somalia that recently stoned two women to death (including a little 13-year-old rape victim), amputated the hands and feet of petty thieves, banned dancing and watching the World Cup, and is used as a base for Jihad pirates to kidnap Infidels and hold them for ransom?
Good thing Somalia's not a Shari'ah state!
Gravenimage,
Somalia is a non-sharia state.
The amputations and stoning probably were done by rebels and not the govt. of Somalia.
Amputations on slaves were done in the US , so a non-sharia state does not necessarily mean moderate, as the US only became moderate in the 1960s, after about 200 years of independence
Author Profile Page Mackie | November 30, 2009 7:47 PM | Reply
LET'S ALL SEND RIFQA BARY CHRISTMAS CARDS TO BELOW ADDRESS AND LET HER KNOW THAT WE ARE PRAYING FOR HER SAFETY.
Thank you for this address, i will certainly send her a card...
Author Profile Page Mackie | November 30, 2009 7:47 PM | Reply
LET'S ALL SEND RIFQA BARY CHRISTMAS CARDS TO BELOW ADDRESS AND LET HER KNOW THAT WE ARE PRAYING FOR HER SAFETY.
Thank you for this address, i will certainly send her a card...
"Somalia is a non-sharia state."
Lying again, 45. Sharia law is being enforced in Somalia by Somali Muslims. Therefore it is most certainly a Sharia state.
Isbella,
Somalia is a non-sharia state.
Rebels practicing sharia does not mean its sanctioned by the state
Ebony,
The declaration is not to impose sharia law; its just a guidance to member states.
The CDHRI was adopted on August 5, 1990 by 45 foreign ministers of the Organisation of the Islamic Conference to serve as a guidance for the member states in the matters of human rights.
There is nothing in the Cairo Declaration of Human Rights that are a threat to western civilization.
Kepha,
Two independent investigations in Ohio and Florida found no credible evidence that Rifqa Bary's life was in danger
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fathima_Rifqa_Bary_controversy
Honor killing is wrong and evil, no matter what the girl has done, just as the murder of a girl by her jealous boyfriend or husband in this country is wrong and evil, but sadly and tragically, more crimes of passion ( the murder of intimate partners) go on in this world than honor killings by muslims.
About 2000 annual murders of intimate partners in the US alone, compared to 5000 annual honor killings world wide, so you can imagine the total number of intimate partners being killed world wide in the non-muslim world.
ref : http://www.soundvision.com/Info/domesticviolence/statistics.asp
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honor_killing
Whether Islam is a cancer is really beside the point because most muslims are just like jews who do not follow controversial aspects of their religion but more important is how the religion has affected them and sadly, the facts show that muslims are not as violent as muslims :
Here are 10 areas pointing to non-muslims being more violent :
(1) 1400 islamic terrorist attacks should be compared to the number of attacks by the US military on targets and the number of sorties run by the US air force every day since 2001 which have resulted in hundreds of thousands of civilians dead according to the Lancet report and that is only in Iraq and does not include the tens of thousands dead in Afghanistan due to US collateral actions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancet_surveys_of_Iraq_War_casualties
(2) More than a hundred million have died due to genocides in non-muslim countries compared to the genocides in muslim countries
http://www.scaruffi.com/politics/dictat.html
(3) in non-war zones :
I am sure you have heard of stories or read the news about your town's murders etc and most of them were done by non-muslims and probably non by Al-Qaeda, so you are more in danger from your fellow citizens.
If you were living in a muslim country, there is a good chance you could be a victim of a muslim but at the same time, the murder rates in a place like Saudi Arabia (rank : 61) is much lower than in the US ( rank : 24) and several muslim countries have lower murder rates than the US.
ref : http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murders-per-capita
(4 ) In fact, the countries with the most murder rates, the top 12 are non-muslim.
ref : http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murders-per-capita
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate
(5) Here is a site that records the fact that there are more non-muslims committing mass murder than muslims :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_murderers_and_spree_killers_by_number_of_victims
(6) you do not find American muslims killing "infidels" in America today and in fact all the killing sprees in the world are overwhelmingly committed by non-muslims
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spree_killer
(7) Compared to American muslims targeting non-muslims, many more of the non-muslim majority target muslims in America .
The targeting of innocent minorities for alleged crimes/sins perpetrated by others is common everywhere, including the US : In 2001 after the 9/11 attacks, Arab Americans, Muslims, and Sikhs were victimized in nearly five percent of the total number of hate crimes reported that year (481 out of 9,730), a seventeen-fold increase over the prior year.
http://www.civilrights.org/publications/hatecrimes/arab-americans.html
(8) Jewish militias forced palestinians to flee their homes during the war of independence in 1948 when the Israeli army committed more atrocities and killed more civilians than the Arabs did, in large part because the Israelis captured 400 Arab towns and villages, whereas the Arabs took fewer than a dozen Israeli settlements.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killings_and_massacres_during_the_1948_Palestine_War
A Jerusalem-based Holocaust Studies Professor Yehuda Bauer stated : "As a Jew, I must live with the fact that the civilization I inherited ... encompasses the call for genocide in its canon.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocides_in_history#Before_1490
(9) About 2000 annual murders of intimate partners in the US alone, compared to 5000 annual honor killings world wide, so you can imagine the total number of intimate partners being killed world wide in the non-muslim world.
ref : http://www.soundvision.com/Info/domesticviolence/statistics.asp
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honor_killing
(10) Both violent and non-violent muslims in prison number about 9,600 Muslim inmates in federal prisons in 2003 out of a US prison population of 7.3 million, so out of one muslim (either violent or non-violent ) going into prison, there are about 760 non-muslims in prison, not considering converts to islam in prison since the crime was committed before their conversion.
ref : http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/03/02/record.prison.population/
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_States%27_prisons
Conservative estimate of the muslim population in the US taken from the Pew Research Center instead of the figures reported by the Council on American-Islamic Relations which reports 6-7 million muslims :
2.5 million muslims in 2009 out of 300 million Americans, meaning for every 1 muslim, there are about 120 Americans according to the Pew Research Center
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_States#Demographics
So muslims in prison ( both violent and non-violent) 1 for every 760 non-muslims
Muslims in the general US population : 1 muslim for every 120 Americans meaning there are about 6.3 times less muslims in prison as compared to the general muslim population in the US.
Non-muslims in the general US population : 297,500,000 which is about 99% of the population according to the 2009 data from the Pew Research Center
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_States#Demographics
Non-muslims (before converting in prison) in the prison population : 7,290,400 which is about 99% of the prison population.
If muslims in prison are 6.3 times less in number than the general muslim population in America and non-muslims in prison represent about the same proportion as the general population,so is it right to say that muslims are on the whole much less violent than non-muslims ? or even if the data is horribly skewed for some inconceivable reason, we still cannot say that muslims in America are more violent than the non-muslims in America
Isabella,
How many muslims who leave islam are actually killed today ?
Compare that figure with those who get murdered here in the US on a daily basis for other ideological reasons.
So the bottom line is that you are safer in several muslim countries compared to the murder rates in the US.
I am sure you have heard of stories or read the news about your town's murders etc and most of them were done by non-muslims and probably non by Al-Qaeda, so you are more in danger from your fellow citizens.
If you were living in a muslim country, there is a good chance you could be a victim of a muslim but at the same time, the murder rates in a place like Saudi Arabia (rank : 61) is much lower than in the US ( rank : 24) and several muslim countries have lower murder rates than the US.
ref : http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murders-per-capita
(4 ) In fact, the countries with the most murder rates, the top 12 are non-muslim.
ref : http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murders-per-capita
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate
OK, 45ch
I'm laying it on the line.
Here's the Barnabas Fund online petition for the abolition of the Islamic Apostasy Law.
http://www.barnabasfund.org/UK/Action/Campaigns/Why-should-they-be-secret/Online-petition/
Will you sign it? Yes or No?
This is what the Barnabas Fund - founded by Canon Dr Patrick Sookhdeo, himself a convert from Islam to Christianity - has to say, in connection with their campaign against the Apostasy Law:
http://www.barnabasfund.org/UK/Action/Campaigns/Why-should-they-be-secret/
"Islam is a one-way street.
"You can convert to Islam but you are not allowed to convert from Islam.
"All schools of Islamic law, shari‘a, agree on this rule and specify the death sentence for an adult male Muslim who chooses to leave his Islamic faith.
"Most also impose the death penalty on women apostates.
"The rule was established many centuries ago by Islamic scholars, but even today most Islamic religious leaders and many ordinary Muslim people agree with it.
"The death penalty is rarely put into practice {by today's majority-Muslim states, I think, is what is meant here - dda}, *but the existence of this “apostasy law” is so well known amongst Muslims that it generates strong hostility towards apostates, whether from family or community, from religious or secular leaders, from police or judiciary* {my emphasis - dda}.
" So it is normal for converts from Islam to face persecution and violence. They may be arrested, either for apostasy or on a pretext.
"They may be attacked, beaten or even murdered by their own relatives.
"*And those who commit the violence will probably not be punished for it* {my emphasis - dda}.
"A further range of penalties for apostasy is laid down in shari‘a, including losing one’s spouse and children and forfeiting one’s property and inheritance.
"These are imposed in many Muslim contexts today.
"It is not surprising that many converts from Islam to Christianity keep their new faith secret, but why should they have to do so?
"Islam actively encourages non-Muslims to convert to Islam,
but it is the only world faith with a death sentence for those who leave it.
'The Islamic apostasy law also stands in stark contrast to Article 18 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, published sixty years ago this month, which states that “Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief...”'.
Canon Dr Sookhdeo is an apostate from Islam to Christianity; he has studied the Islamic texts very extensively; and he has broad and deep knowledge of the situation of the churches in Islamic lands, and of the predicament of apostates from Islam...who, even within the UK, not being as 'high profile' as he is, are overwhelmingly forced to flee their families of origin, live in secret, move house often, change their names, etc., exactly as if they were escapees from something like the Mafia.
Here is what the Barnabas Fund prayer booklet for November/December 2009 has to say about Rifqa Bary: whose case was the prayer point set down for November 29th.
"Rifqa Bary (17) from a Sri Lankan Muslim background, lives in the USA and has become a Christian. After death threats from her father she fled the family home. Because she is a minor the authorities have to face the question of whether or not to return her to her parents.
"Some American commentators ridiculed her claims and could not believe that a father might hurt or kill his own child 'just' because she had changed her faith.
"Pray for a much better understanding amongst non-Muslims in the West of the Islamic law of apostasy, and the way it has conditioned the minds of zealous Muslims to view converts as traitors, so that they [western non-Muslims] will realise *the very real danger facing those who leave Islam* {my emphasis - dda}.
"Pray particularly for those who have power to decide Rifqa's future, that they will protect her from harm". END EXCERPT.
45ch seems to think Rifqa is in no danger.
The Barnabas Fund, founded and informed by Canon Dr Sookhdeo who is an apostate from Islam, disagrees with 45ch; they are convinced (as is Mr Spencer, and also many members of Former Muslims United) that Rifqa *is* in danger; or, certainly, that there is such a high probability of her being harmed, that she should NOT be sent back into a Muslim family and milieu.
I believe the Barnabas Fund, and Mr Spencer - and, for that matter, Rifqa herself.
I DON'T believe 45ch's bland and baseless assurances, nor his blind trust in the (demonstrably utterly clueless and ill-informed) Ohio and Florida law enforcement 'investigations'.
DDA.
Since people like Rifqa Bary do leave Islam, there is no evidence that Islam has a hold on people and can over ride their free will and since Islam is not more powerful than christianity and since most christians are not able to follow the pacifism of Christ, likewise, since Islam is not more powerful than christianity, most muslims are not able to follow the call to jihad and many have even left islam like Rifqa has.
Rifqa is not in any danger but at the same time, she should be allowed to live wherever she wants, away from her parents.
45ch says 'Rifqa is not in any danger'.
NONSENSE.
"there is no evidence that Islam has a hold on people"
I dunno - The death penalty for apostates is written in the Qur'an, the Ahadiths, 1400 years of Islamic exegesis and incorporated in Shariah "law". It even seems to be practiced in Ohio...........
The taquiyya can go on and on, but if you've read the Qur'an, the taquiyya stops here.
Tanstaafl,
The death penalty is also written the bible :
Deuteronomy 13:6-10:
If thy brother, the son of thy mother, or thy son, or thy daughter, or the wife of thy bosom, or thy friend, which [is] as thine own soul, entice thee secretly, saying, Let us go and serve other gods, which thou hast not known, thou, nor thy fathers; [Namely], of the gods of the people which [are] round about you, nigh unto thee, or far off from thee, from the [one] end of the earth even unto the [other] end of the earth; Thou shalt not consent unto him, nor hearken unto him; neither shall thine eye pity him, neither shalt thou spare, neither shalt thou conceal him: But thou shalt surely kill him; thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death, and afterwards the hand of all the people. And thou shalt stone him with stones, that he die; because he hath sought to thrust thee away from the LORD thy God, which brought thee out of the land of Egypt, from the house of bondage (end of quote )
Just as Jews have abandoned having a state religion, numerous muslim countries do not have sharia, so it is possible for muslims to reform and even leave Islam
Wrong again, 45. The rebels are running the asylum. They are making the laws and establishing Sharia. But you already know that. Don't you.
Maybe you could sell it to the liberals in Congress.
Taqiyyah.
Isabella,
Are you talking about the Somalian rebels ?
In any rebellion, the most despicable things happen, as also happened during the American revolutionary war.
When a foreign power occupies another country or when separatist movements reject the govt., it tends to result in terrorism, as was seen by the torture that many loyalist Americans/British went through by being tarred ( boiling tar being poured on them) because they were seen as loyal to the occupying British forces by the American rebels.
Another form of terrorism was the killing of british troops by the American rebels, after the British troops had surrendered.
ref : http://home.golden.net/~marg/bansite/banecdotes/96quarter.html
Lynchings were ordered by American Patriot Judge Charles Lynch on the terrorized American loyalists who were loyal to the British Crown.
So terrorism can be the result of being in a war zone and its either terrorism from the occupying force through collateral actions or the terrorism of the rebels against those loyal to the occupying force.
The fact that most American loyalists, who were loyal to Britain, fled the US, shows the terror they faced, not only from being tarred or properties confiscated but being lynched to death.
ref : http://www.redcoat.me.uk/
dumbledoresarmy, you stated :
"You can convert to Islam but you are not allowed to convert from Islam.
"All schools of Islamic law, shari‘a, agree on this rule and specify the death sentence for an adult male Muslim who chooses to leave his Islamic faith.
Comment :
If Jews can abandon their apostasy laws, I don't see any reason why muslims cannot abandon it, in the light of the fact that there are numerous muslim countries that do not follow sharia.
Not all muslims agree on the death penalty for apostates but more importantly, what is the record of deaths due to apostasy ?
Regarding apostasy laws, to what extent have they been followed ? and how many apostates have actually been put to death in the 20th or 21st centuries ?
Some Islamic jurists, such as Hanafi jurist Sarakhsi, Maliki jurist Abu al-Walid al-Baji, and Hanbali jurist Ibn Taymiyyah, and some contemporary Islamic jurists, such as Shafi`i Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa and Shi'a Grand Ayatollah Hossein-Ali Montazeri, argued or issued fatwas that either the changing of religion is not punishable or is only punishable under restricted circumstances.
Some groups within Islam such as the Shi'a Ismaili reject death for apostasy altogether
From an article in the Times Online, February 5 2005, which featured the stories of former Muslims in the UK.
Perhaps 45ch will tell us that the first example given, one Nissar Hussein, is a liar? And that the many Muslims who are routinely and regularly attacking Mr Hussein because of his apostasy, are not 'true' Muslims?
"THE first brick was thrown through the sitting room window at one in the morning, waking Nissar Hussein, his wife and five children with a terrifying start. The second brick went through his car window.
"It was a shock, but hardly a surprise. The week before, another brick had been thrown through the window as the family were preparing for bed in their Bradford home.
"The victim of a three-year campaign of religious hatred, Mr Hussein’s car has also been rammed and torched, and the steps to his home have been strewn with rubbish.
"He and his family have been regularly jostled, abused, attacked, shouted at to move out of the area, and given death threats in the street. His wife has been held hostage inside their home for two hours by a mob. His car, walls and windows have been daubed in graffiti: “Christian bastard”.
"The problem isn’t so much what Mr Hussein, whose parents came from Pakistan, believes, but what he doesn’t believe.
"Born into Islam, he converted eight years ago to Christianity, and his wife, also from Pakistan, followed suit.
"While those who convert to Islam, such as Cat Stevens, Jemima Khan, and the sons of the Frank Dobson, the former Health Secretary, and Lord Birt, the former BBC Director-General, can publicly celebrate their new religion, those whose faith goes in the other direction face persecution.
"Mr Hussein, a 39-year-old hospital nurse in Bradford, is one of a growing number of former Muslims in Britain who face
not just being shunned by family and community, but attacked, kidnapped, and in some cases killed.
*There is even a secret underground network to support and protect those who leave Islam* {my emphasis - dda}...
"Muslims who lose their faith face execution or imprisonment, in line with traditional Muslim teaching, in many Islamic countries, including Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Egypt and Yemen. In the Netherlands, the former Muslim MP Ayan Hirsi Ali had to go into hiding after renouncing her faith on television."
Perhaps 45ch will tell us that this lady, too, is a liar, and that he, 45ch, understands Islam better than she does?
"Yasmin, who was raised in the North of England, has been forced out of her town once, and is now trying to resist being chased out again.
"Brought up in a Muslim family, she converted after having a vision of Jesus when she gave birth to her youngest son, and was baptised in her thirties..
“My family completely disowned me. They thought I had committed the biggest sin — I was born a Muslim, and so I must die a Muslim. When my husband found out, he totally disowned my sons. *One friend tried to strangle me when I told him I was converting* ,” she said.
{Got that, everyone? she told a Muslim friend she was leaving Islam, and *he tried to strangle her*. Do friends normally do that to friends, in Western countries, if the friend announces s/he is embracing a new belief system? - dda}.
“We had bricks though our windows, I was spat at in the street because they thought I was dishonouring Islam.
'We had to call the police so many times. I had to go to court to get an injunction against my husband because he was inciting others to attack me.”
'She fled to another part of Britain, but the attacks soon started again as locals found out about her.
“I wasn’t going to leave again,” she said, adding that it was the double standards of her attackers that made her most angry. “They are such hypocrites — they want us to be tolerant of everything they want, but they are intolerant of everything about us.”
'Although some are beaten “black and blue” for their faith, others suffer even more.
'The family of an 18-year-old girl whom Yasmin was helping found that she had been hiding a Bible in her room, and visiting church secretly.
“I tried to do as much as possible to help her, but they took her to Pakistan ‘on holiday’. Three weeks later, she was drowned — they said that she went out in the middle of the night and slipped in the river, but she just wouldn ’t have done that,” said Yasmin."
END EXCERPTS.
That last case, of the Pakistani teenager, reminds me eerily of Rifqa Bary. That girl was 18; Rifqa is 17. Like Rifqa, she converted secretly, but then was 'found out'.
Her family took her from the UK to Pakistan and she had an 'accident'. How convenient.
If Rifqa Bary's family gets her back, I'd be prepared to bet that within the year - most likely after being taken back to Sri Lanka - she too has an 'accident'.
And 45ch wants us to think there's nothing to worry about.
I will leave the last word (from the same Anthony Browne Times Online article) to Ibn Warraq, apostate:
"The most high-profile British apostate is Ibn Warraq, a Pakistani-born intellectual and former teacher from London, who lost his faith after the Salman Rushdie affair and set out his reasons in the book Why I am not a Muslim.
'He recently edited the book Leaving Islam, but finds it hard to explain the hostility.
“It’s very strange.
Even the most liberal Muslim can become incredibly fierce if you criticise Islam, or, horror of horrors, leave it.” END QUOTE
In other words: the apparent moderation and 'liberality' of this or that Muslim can evaporate like spit on a hot pan, replaced with rage (sometimes murderous rage) if confronted with a case of actual or intended apostasy in a friend, a family member, or community member.
As for outright killings, I know of quite a few that have been reported here at jihadwatch in the past couple of years - an apostate girl in Saudi Arabia, a young woman in Jordan, at least half a dozen in Somalia: Muslim-background Christians hunted down, seized, and either shot or beheaded; and two Turkish Muslim-background Christians who were systematically tortured to death for the double crime of 1. leaving Islam and 2. promulgating their Christian faith in a Muslim country.
Nonie Darwish notes in her book on sharia that apostasy is one of the 'crimes' with regard to which ANY individual Muslim can appoint himself judge, jury and executioner; the existence of a Muslim state with the 'apostasy law' on the books, is not necessary; all that is necessary is that a Muslim perceive the crime and choose to carry out the punishment. All that's needed is one or two freelance self-appointed sharia enforcers, here and there, to terrorise whole communities into conformity...because you never know who's watching, you never know who will decide to bring down the scimitar.
I am quite, quite sure that within the Muslim population in the USA there would be those - perhaps quite a lot of people - who believe it would be Islamically correct, and their bounden duty, to kill Rifqa Bary at the first opportunity.
DDA,
Compared to the thousands of incidences of the torturous lynching of blacks in the US by right wing mobs, the actual killings of apostates is not very common and which are done by criminal muslims and not the state, just as the actual killing of blacks were done by criminal Americans and not the US govt.
There are many laws that are written in books, which are never carried out in practice, likewise, there are laws in the bible and the Koran that in reality are never carried out in real life by the state of Israel or muslim states.
Yes, people should not be persecuted or killed for leaving Islam but people make it sound like certain criminal muslims are the only ones prone to violence, which the facts do not support.
STOP with the tu quoque.
I am getting sick and tired of it. You hardly seem to be able to write anything without resorting to that particular logical fallacy.
The activities of the Ku Klux Klan have nothing to do with the case. Utterly irrelevant.
What matters is that *sharia prescribes that apostates should be killed*.
Sharia DOES affect Muslim behaviour, quite noticeably, whether there is a 'state' to enforce it or not. *Any* devout Muslim, whether in an 'Islamic' state or not, whether in a majority-Muslim society or not, can decide to become a sharia-enforcer: Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong (and one must remember that 'right' and 'wrong' DON'T mean, in Islamspeak, what they mean for the average westerner or non-Muslim easterner).
IF you are a non-Muslim - and I mean this even if you are a mindlessly malicious Internet Troll who is only here to mess with our heads for fun - read Nonie Darwish, 'Cruel and Usual Punishment'. She talks about 'Allah's enforcers'. It might shake you up a bit.
Of course, if you are a Mohammedan in a mask, you'll go right on doing what you've been doing here for a month or so: lying, denying, throwing sand, and the whole taqiyya-and-tu-quoque bit, determinedly impervious to reason and facts.
NOTHING you say can convince me that Rifqa Bary - and others like her - are perfectly safe, no worries. The precautionary principle applies: Rifqa Bary MUST NOT be sent back to her family, and should be assisted, by the authorities, to start a new life in secure anonymity.
I don't want her to meet the same end as Fr Daniel Sysoyev or Theo Van Gogh.
DDA,
Yes, religious texts like in the Old Testament and in the Koran do influence people, but to what extent ?
The evidence points to hate being more of an influence than just religious texts.
I am sure a loving family will not kill their own children but in America, sadly, there have been numerous cases of fathers and mothers killing their own children.
There are criminals in every community who take the law into their own hands.
Is Rifqa's life in danger in the US ? probably not , according to every police investigation.
Is it better for her to live away from her parents ? probably.
You have pointed a few cases of criminal muslims committing horrendous crimes but why should people dismiss non-muslims committing hate crimes against their own children ?
Observe, ladies and gentlemen, 45ch's absolute inability to discuss this subject without resorting to tu quoque; and his dogged insistence on obfuscating the reality that sharia prescribes the death of the apostate and that sharia-inspired attitudes do in fact suffuse Muslim communities.
He wants us to suppose that 'criminals' are the same in Islamic and non-Islamic societies.
He obscures the fact that what Islam defines as 'crime' and what we in the west define as 'crime' are not necessarily the same kinds of thing.
A non-Muslim who kills his or her child is a criminal. (It might be added, also, that people who have studied these things - Chesler and Walker - have observed that it is *very rare* in the Western world for a father to kill his teenage daughter, and likewise rare for a brother to kill his sister or a male cousin to kill his female cousin; whereas the reverse is the case, in the Islamic world - there, one of the commoner forms of murder is a father killing his teenage daughter, or else a girl being killed by her brother or male cousin).
A Muslim who kills his own child for whatever reason, incurs no punishment under sharia. Nonie Darwish - who grew up in a society in which all kinds of sharia-based practices were very much alive even if some of them weren't officially on the books - makes this very clear.
Islamic law also says that *anyone* who kills an apostate from Islam, incurs no penalty. This, as Darwish points out, encourages and *licenses* vigilante behaviour.
Whereas vigilante behaviour, in the modern west, would be classified as a crime, and punished.
So the act of murdering one's daughter because she has changed to a different religion or because she is perceived as 'uppity' is simply NOT A CRIME under Islamic law; there is no punishment laid down for it. It is a crime among non-Muslims; it is *not a crime* among Muslims.
And I repeat that sharia does not have to be officially 'on the books', in order to be in large part practised and enforced among any given lot of Muslims. They can't get away with stonings - though there was one case in France, that I recall - but 'disappearing' a recalcitrant teenage girl or young woman - or even assassinating her in broad daylight - has been happening rather a lot, among Muslims in the West, of late.
DDA,
Here are the facts from the US dept. of justice:
JUST IN THE US ALONE : American men and women who have killed their own children or loved ones or relatives or ex-spouses or intimate partners between 1976 and 1997 number at 116,814 ( annual rate of 5562 murders )
ref : http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/ascii/wo.txt
Annual WORLDWIDE ( high end ) estimate of honor killings : 5000 per year
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honor_killing
Muslims don't follow sharia as much as non-muslims who tragically follow the ideology of hate in killing their daughters/children, loved ones, intimate partners or ex-spouses or relatives.
No matter how much sharia is out there, the sad fact is that non-muslims have been more violent towards their relatives/daughters/loved ones/ex-spouses/children/intimate partners than muslims have been been
ref : http://crime.about.com/b/2004/10/29/parents-killing-their-children.htm
Ladies and gentlemen
every time anyone - as 45ch has just done - attempts to use the Tu Quoque sophism in here, let's just all remember this brilliant little posting, made a couple of days ago in this thread
http://www.jihadwatch.org/2009/11/six-honor-killings-in-the-us-in-two-years.html
by one 'Taylor Neal Grayson':
TaylorNealGrayson | November 30, 2009 4:41 AM | Reply
'The argument, "But other people do it," has absolutely no logic.
'Other people doing it does not negate the fact that THESE people do it.
'Other people doing it for *different* reasons does not cancel out the fact that THESE people do it for religious reasons.
'Other people doing it does not make THESE people doing it less wrong or less abhorrent.
'The old "other people do it" argument is simply a deflection of responsibility."
I will add that with each additional posting that 45ch makes in this thread he (or she?) has been digging a deeper and deeper hole for themselves.
For I am waiting for something to happen. (Intelligent non-Muslim readers of this ever-lengthening exchange should be able to work out for themselves, what that is).
So far that something has not happened.
The longer it continues to not happen, the more firmly I become convinced that 45ch is - despite all its dissembling - a Mohammedan who fully approves of and agrees with the sharia rule about what should be done with apostates, and who would be quite content for Rifqa Bary to be killed by her parents or by any other Muslim who chooses to do the deed.
DDA,
I wish the facts back up what you say, but tragically, non-muslims are far more dangerous than muslims according to the statistics and here are ten areas where it clearly shows non-muslims much more dangerous than muslims :
Just as Jews/Christians do not follow the
controversial aspects of the bible, muslims do
not follow the controversial aspects of the Koran
and the statistics prove that too.
Here is what the statistics say :
The problem lies more among non-muslims than
muslims, according to every major statistics
regarding violence.
I wish the opposite were true so I can be on your
side, but I have to go with the facts and not
emotions.
Here are 10 areas pointing to non-muslims being
more violent :
(1) 1400 islamic terrorist attacks should be
compared to the number of attacks by the US
military on targets and the number of sorties run
by the US air force every day since 2001 which
have resulted in hundreds of thousands of
civilians dead according to the Lancet report and
that is only in Iraq and does not include the
tens of thousands dead in Afghanistan due to US
collateral actions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancet_surveys_of_Ir
aq_War_casualties
(2) More than a hundred million have died due to
genocides in non-muslim countries compared to the
genocides in muslim countries
http://www.scaruffi.com/politics/dictat.html
(3) in non-war zones :
I am sure you have heard of stories or read the
news about your town's murders etc and most of
them were done by non-muslims and probably non by
Al-Qaeda, so you are more in danger from your
fellow citizens.
If you were living in a muslim country, there is
a good chance you could be a victim of a muslim
but at the same time, the murder rates in a place
like Saudi Arabia (rank : 61) is much lower than
in the US ( rank : 24) and several muslim
countries have lower murder rates than the US.
ref :
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap
-crime-murders-per-capita
(4 ) In fact, the countries with the most murder
rates, the top 12 are non-muslim.
ref :
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap
-crime-murders-per-capita
ref :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by
_intentional_homicide_rate
(5) Here is a site that records the fact that
there are more non-muslims committing mass murder
than muslims :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mass_murdere
rs_and_spree_killers_by_number_of_victims
(6) you do not find American muslims killing
"infidels" in America today and in fact all the
killing sprees in the world are overwhelmingly
committed by non-muslims
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spree_killer
(7) Compared to American muslims targeting non-
muslims, many more of the non-muslim majority
target muslims in America .
The targeting of innocent minorities for alleged
crimes/sins perpetrated by others is common
everywhere, including the US : In 2001 after the
9/11 attacks, Arab Americans, Muslims, and Sikhs
were victimized in nearly five percent of the
total number of hate crimes reported that year
(481 out of 9,730), a seventeen-fold increase
over the prior year.
http://www.civilrights.org/publications/hatecrime
s/arab-americans.html
(8) Jewish militias forced palestinians to flee
their homes during the war of independence in
1948 when the Israeli army committed more
atrocities and killed more civilians than the
Arabs did, in large part because the Israelis
captured 400 Arab towns and villages, whereas the
Arabs took fewer than a dozen Israeli
settlements.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killings_and_massacr
es_during_the_1948_Palestine_War
Regarding genocides committed by Jews in Old
Testament times :
A Jerusalem-based Holocaust Studies Professor
Yehuda Bauer stated : "As a Jew, I must live with
the fact that the civilization I inherited ...
encompasses the call for genocide in its canon.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocides_in_history
#Before_1490
(9) Here are the facts from the US dept. of justice:
American men and women who have killed their own children or loved ones or relatives or ex-spouses between 1976 and 1997 number at 116,814 ( annual rate of 5562 )
ref : http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/ascii/wo.txt
Annual worldwide high end estimate of honor killings : 5000 per year
ref : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honor_killing
Tragically, Muslims don't follow sharia as much as non-muslims follow the ideology of hate in killing their daughters/children, loved ones, intimate partners or ex-spouses or relatives.
No matter how much sharia is out there, the sad fact is that non-muslims have been more violent towards their relatives/daughters/loved ones/ex-spouses/children/intimate partners than muslims have been been
ref : http://crime.about.com/b/2004/10/29/parents-killing-their-children.htm
(10) Both violent and non-violent muslims in
prison number about 9,600 Muslim inmates in
federal prisons in 2003 out of a US prison
population of 7.3 million, so out of one muslim
(either violent or non-violent ) going into
prison, there are about 760 non-muslims in
prison, not considering converts to islam in
prison since the crime was committed before their
conversion.
ref :
http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/03/02/record.prison
.population/
ref :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_Unit
ed_States%27_prisons
Conservative estimate of the muslim population in
the US taken from the Pew Research Center
instead of the figures reported by the Council
on American-Islamic Relations which reports 6-7
million muslims :
2.5 million muslims in 2009 out of 300 million
Americans, meaning for every 1 muslim, there are
about 120 Americans according to the Pew Research
Center
ref :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_
States#Demographics
So muslims in prison ( both violent and non-
violent) 1 for every 760 non-muslims
Muslims in the general US population : 1 muslim
for every 120 Americans meaning there are about
6.3 times less muslims in prison as compared to
the general muslim population in the US.
Non-muslims in the general US population :
297,500,000 which is about 99% of the population
according to the 2009 data from the Pew Research
Center
ref :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_
States#Demographics
Non-muslims (before converting in prison) in the
prison population : 7,290,400 which is about 99%
of the prison population.
If muslims in prison are 6.3 times less in number
than the general muslim population in America and
non-muslims in prison represent about the same
proportion as the general population,so is it
right to say that muslims are on the whole much
less violent than non-muslims ? or even if the
data is horribly skewed for some inconceivable
reason, we still cannot say that muslims in
America are more violent than the non-muslims in
America.
Islam does not have a hold on muslims as seen in
numerous muslims leaving Islam and Islam does not
make muslims follow Sharia as can be seen in
numerous muslim countries that do not have sharia
:
Burkina Faso
Chad
Gambia
Guinea
Mali
Senegal
Somalia
Kazakhstan
Kyrgystan
Tajikstan
Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan
Albania
Azerbaijan
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Kosovo
Turkey
The Mohammedtroll did it again...
DDA,
I want to be on your side, but you got to help me out by clearly showing that muslims are much more dangerous than non-muslims according to the facts and not emotions.
So far all I can see is that sharia does not affect muslims as much as the ideology of hate affects non-muslims in 10 different areas; from genocides to spree killings to massacres to mass killings to domestic violence to prison populations etc etc
Now, since 45ch is convinced that dar al Islam is a region of peace, perfect peace (unless, of course, the horrible Infidels interfere with it) and that sharia is perfect, and Muslims live in peace with one another and with their neighbours, and that everyone is so much nicer than in those horrible non-Muslim countries, I will cite some contrary data-points.
First up, testimony from Muslims who have become Christians, and the reasons they give for so doing.
First, from Algeria:
'"Dis" was from an Arab [Muslim] family, *taught from an early age to hate Christians and Americans* {nota bene - dda}.
"But when I learned about Jesus in the Qur'an," he explained, "I liked Him. I thought, If God gave me a choice, I would follow Jesus. He is not a man of war."
'The attraction grew as he listened to Christian radio. Then, one night, Dis had a vision of a heavenly being who informed him that Jesus was Lord.
'At that moment, his heart was transformed. Now he is full of love, not hate; dedicated to bringing reconciliation between Arabs and Kabyles."
(Christianity Today, January 2007)
So: while a Muslim this young man learned hate; after he believed in Jesus, he learned love and seeks to reconcile two warring ethnic groups.
Again, in Algeria, the extreme violence of sharia-pushing jihadis backfired on them:
http://www.meforum.org/article/104
"The Islamist campaign of violence in Algeria has turned some Muslims, especially Berbers, away from Islam and toward Christianity, reports the Algiers daily Al-Yawm in late December 2000, as reprinted in Courrier International, January 4-10, 2001, p. 29. The following extracts are translated from the French.
'In Kabylie, people of all ages are converting to Christianity..
'What is happening and what has happened in Algeria, *such as the massacres and killings in the name of Islam* {my emphasis -dda} has [sic] led many, when asked what the difference, in their view, was between Islam and Christianity, to declare: "Christianity is life, Islam is death."
Funny that they should think that, if Islam is more peaceful than Christianity.
And now, from the opposite end of the Mediterranean:
A Muslim Kurd in Turkey, translating the New Testament into Kurdish, discovered the following:
“*Christianity’s culture was different from that of Islam* {my emphasis - dda}
'Certain Bible teachings highlighted the differences strikingly. ‘It totally changed me to deal with how you are taught to forgive people, to love people and live with them in peace. The Bible says, ‘Love your enemies and your neighbours’ and ‘treat your neighbour as you would like to be treated’…From then on, ‘in my heart,’ he says, ‘I believed in Jesus’…
"He adds: ‘When I recognized the Bible, I learned to be flexible, to listen to people, to forgive them, and to be more patient. *For example, if you are among Muslims, you would always fight* {my emphasis - dda}. I don’t want to fight. I always wanted to convince people, to argue with them. … to understand them.” (Bible Society World Report 399/ 33, 10.2. 2006).
He found in the Bible a teaching that fulfilled the longing he already felt, for something other than the ‘always fight’ mentality of Islam.
I stress that this is an educated man, raised in Turkey, in a reasonably ‘middle class’ urban milieu, in a family that was not fanatically observant. So he must be describing the Turkish ‘moderate’ Islam he grew up with.
And he is still saying that the Biblical injunction to ‘do as you would be done by’ was a radically novel idea.
And he defines the 'default' Muslim mindset by contrast, thus: "if you are among Muslims, you would always fight". Doesn't sound very peaceful, to me.
Nonie Darwish confirms that same observation out of her own experience of 30 years inside an Islamic society, in overwhelmingly-Muslim Egypt: in her book on sharia, 'Cruel and Usual Punishment', she describes an all-pervasive and indeed suffocating atmosphere of suspicion, aggression, violence and UNforgiveness. A teenage maid who worked for Nonie's family when Nonie was young, had come to the Darwish home after being raped by her previous employer and then sacked by his wife; but one day she 'disappeared'. "We later learned her fate from the agent who had placed her in our home [as a maid, after the rape]. He never used the word 'killed' but he whispered that her father and brother 'took care of their honor'." *Nowhere* in the West in the 1950s would a girl raped by her employer, have been murdered by her own father and brothers; the person in danger would have been the rapist.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali, too, speaks of the default mode of suspicion and aggression that defined interpersonal relations in overwhelmingly-Muslim Somalia and the atmosphere of cruelty in Saudi Arabia, contrasting it with the 'kindness' that many people showed to one another in majority-Christian Ethiopia, and then the order and peace that prevailed in the Netherlands. Furthermore: Ayaan observed during her work as a translator that women and girls from Muslim families formed the vast majority of those seeking refuge in Dutch shelters for battered women.
Post scriptum.
45ch.
Are you resident in a non-Muslim country or in a Muslim country?
If you are resident in a non-Muslim country, and you are so convinced that sharia law is just peachy, and you are also convinced that the non-Muslim world is and always has been a complete sh*t-hole, then I suggest that you cancel your current citizenship and migrate ASAP to a full-sharia or high-sharia Muslim country.
Take yourself off to beautiful, wonderful, peaceful Saudi Arabia, the heartland and Holy Land of your favourite religion, Islam (after all, it *is* your favourite, isn't it, since you spend so much of your time singing its praises) where -so you were telling us in an earlier posting - all those be-burka'd girls look like little angels (except when they're being stoned to death on the lying say-so of a harridan with a grudge)
http://pajamasmedia.com/phyllischesler/2009/11/24/why-is-america-still-allied-with-saudi-arabia/
or being murdered by daddy after he finds out about the secret conversion to Christianity
http://www.jihadwatch.org/2008/08/saudi-man-cuts-daughters-tongue-burns-her-to-death.html
Get thee to a sharia land; NOW.
Leave.
And good riddance.
DDA,
I never said that muslims live in perfect peace.
What I have been saying is that all the facts point to non-muslims being more violent than muslims.
Why is that ?
I have a theory; could it be because muslims are more family oriented and because of that, crime is lower in muslim countries, since close family ties makes a person less prone to a life of crime.
Muslims are more 'family-oriented' sez 45ch.
Sure they are.
Lots and lots of them, especially in the oh-so-holy heartland of Islam, Saudi Arabia, marry their first cousins; and then the kids from *those* marriages marry *their* first cousins, and so on, and on, and on, generation after generation...
http://www.consang.net/index.php/Global_prevalence
With the wretched results that any experienced modern geneticist could predict.
Continual intense inbreeding is bad for any species. For the human species which already has a low level of genetic diversity, it is really, really bad news.
I recall seeing a newspaper report on the level of damaging recessive genetic disorders manifesting in the children of the ethnically Pakistani Muslim population in the UK. It is much higher than among the non-Muslim groups within the UK.