Until the 1967 war, many in Western Europe saw Israel -- correctly -- as a tiny and besieged state, surrounded by enemies who wished to destroy it. In this respect, they were helped along by the fact that the leader of those who would after the Six-Day War be carefully renamed as the "Palestinians," were not yet called "Palestinians" but simply "the Arabs" or "the Arab refugees." And their putative leader, Ahmed Shukairy (who was himself half-Turkish), had the habit of expressing himself as a truthful Muslim, and told the world that his goal was the destruction of Israel.
The Arab leaders said the same thing. And those Arab leaders, at the time, did not have the enormous oil wealth that the member-states of OPEC really began to acquire only in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Then they enjoyed a really fantastic jump in oil revenues, and thus an equally fantastic increase in perceived power and real ability to buy all kinds of influence along with other, more tangible goods and services, only when OPEC quadrupled the price of oil in the fall of 1973.
And beginning with their defeat in the Six-Day War, the Arabs realized that they would not be able to defeat Israel militarily, at least not yet, not under the new conditions, and with Israel now in possession of "the West Bank" and Gaza and all of the Sinai (some 95% of the territory Israel won by force of arms in that war). They would have to formulate a new strategy to force Israel to disgorge what it had won, to make Israel appear not to be what in fact it still was, a tiny state subject to this unending Arab and Muslim hostility, that no concessions by Israel would ever truly assuage (at least not for the Muslims who took Islam seriously, and that meant, at least, all of the Arab Muslims). So they did several things. They decided on a campaign of diplomatic and economic warfare, accompanied by terrorist acts within Israel and against Israelis overseas, and on a campaign to weaken Israel and to force its former friends to sever ties, or at least to cease being friendly toward Israel, and ready to misunderstand its plight, and the real nature of the war -- the Jihad -- being waged against it.
The first to be won over, largely by bribery of African rulers, were the black African states that had enjoyed good relations with Israel and had benefited greatly from Israel's extensive, and intelligent, aid program in Black Africa, which encouraged the development of small-scale agriculture. All of these countries, or almost all, within a year or two after the Six-Day War, had been persuaded by Arab money and the promise -- never fulfilled -- of more money to come if they did what the Arabs wanted, cut off diplomatic relations with the Jewish state.
In Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union, there was no need to change tactics. The Communists were anti-Zionist and the policy of the Soviet government was almost forthrightly antisemitic, though all the best people in Russia -- think of Sakharov -- deplored such a policy, and the most advanced non-Jewish Russians took, as if reflexively, Israel's side.
In the countries of Western Europe, the Arabs played on the exaggerated guilt over colonialism. They pretended that the Jews, who had bought land and revived the ancient Jewish commonwealth in the tiny territory that for thousands of years had been associated, by Jews and by many others, with the Jewish nation, were in fact "colonialists" who had come to "colonize." Strange colonists, these, who drained the Huleh marshes, made the desert famously bloom, and did all the work -- the Arabs, in fact, flocked into what in the West was known as "Palestine" in numbers greater than the Jews from 1920 to 1940, and even before, from the turn of the century to 1920, because the Zionist settlers created economic opportunities that, until they arrived, had simply not existed.
All this, however, was forgotten -- not at once, but slowly, as the Arabs kept talking about a newly invented "Palestinian people." Within a decade or two, by dint of constant repetition, this people came to be accepted as real, and not a propagandistic fiction, created -- along with supposedly "Palestinian" folktales and folksongs (in reality, all of them simply standard Arab folktales and folksongs) -- for the sole purpose of disguising the war, the Jihad against Israel. The shock troops of that war were those local Arabs who were now so absurdly called "Palestinians." Arab Muslims led the campaign. Many non-Arab Muslims have naturally joined in. The less they have anything other than Islam, any other identity, to fall back on -- such as the Pakistanis (as compared to Berbers and Kurds and even Iranians before the Islamic Republic of Iran came along to prove itself even more Islamic than the Arabs) - the more this campaign turned out to be a success.
Pim Fortuyn had great sympathy for Israel. He noted in his book "Israel: 50 Years, and Then?" that an intelligent understanding of Israel's situation and of its real history, was fading from European consciousnesses. Now we hear, and not only on the BBC, and read, and not only in The Guardian, that juridically ridiculous phrase, "occupied Arab lands," or "occupied West Bank," for territories which were assigned to Mandatory Palestine by the League of Nations for the sole purpose of creating, from that particular Mandatory territory, the Jewish National Home.
Things became very bleak for Israel in Western Europe. But now things are changing, and they are not changing because of anything the Israelis have done. They remain as inept as ever in the proper presentation of their own history, their own claims, their own rights, their own case. No, what has changed is that, over the last thirty years, the political and media elites of the countries of Western Europe allowed into their midst, into the midst of their countries, and their by-now long-suffering peoples, far too many, even millions, of Muslims. The behavior of those Muslims makes clear that behind that behavior is something else, a Total Belief-System, that is not susceptible of change, and that rests on the idea, inculcated by Qur'an, Hadith, and Sira, that between Believer and Unbeliever, Muslim and Infidel, a state of permanent war, though not always of open warfare, must and does exist. And the texts of Islam, the tenets of Islam, are coming into view -- slowly but surely. The behavior of Muslims themselves is by now obviously more threatening and intransigent than the behavior of any of the other many immigrant groups that have arrived in Western Europe.
They are most threatening, it seems, in those very countries, Denmark and the Netherlands, which have elevated Tolerance practically to the level of state religions. And since it is not the Chinese, not the Hindus, not the sub-Saharan but Christian black Africans, not the Filipinos or the South Americans, but always and everywhere the Muslims who are the cause of such trouble and anxiety, and since they are the cause of such trouble and anxiety for non-Muslims not in one, or two, or five countries of Western Europe, but absolutely everywhere that they go, that they live, in numbers large enough -- 2 or 5 will apparently do -- it has become clear that there is Something About Islam. It is that very Something that many inhabitants of Western Europe can no longer pretend does not exist. They are now determined to find out just exactly what that Something is.
As soon as the peoples of Western Europe come to realize what Islam is all about -- and they are being forced to realize, for the Muslims in their midst are doing the forcing -- they will, slowly, come to understand not the non-existent "plight" of the non-existent "Palestinian people." They will change, and change in favor of Israel. They will come to realize that, as they become aware of what is truly happening in their own countries. Those countries are now faced from within with what is a quite-unnecessary danger, that of Muslim populations that cannot, save at the edges, among the least-Muslim of Muslims, integrate, and that believe they have not only have a right but a duty to remove all obstacles to the spread, and then the dominance, of Islam. That goal will be, is being, pursued by all means. Those means include, in addition to terrorism and its ever-present threat, such means as the Money Weapon, campaigns of Da'wa, and demographic conquest (discussed openly among Muslims, and sometimes even, as by Boumediene at the U.N. in 1974, and Qaddafy a few years ago, Arab or other Muslim rulers). That goal requires the slow or rapid undoing of the political and legal institutions of Infidel nation-states, the undoing of social arrangements and understandings, the undoing of the very freedoms, and solicitousness for the individual, that characterize advanced Western democracies, and are regarded as the accomplishment of many centuries of thought.
And as they begin to better comprehend Islam, those Europeans will, necessarily, begin to realize as well that the war against Israel has no end and is unsusceptible of a "solution." For the Arab and Muslim claim, or the Arab Muslim claim, is not to be met, nor assuaged, by any reduction in Israel's size. Already absurdly tiny, Israel is now, in its current borders (including the "West Bank," which is the name the Jordanians gave to those parts of Judea and Samaria, part of the Mandate for Palestine that was always intended to be included in the tiny territory allocated for the Jewish National Home by the League of Nations), existing in a state of permanent peril that no other state must endure. For any of those other states to lecture or hector Israel on why it should surrender more territory, is both cruel and absurd. Once Islam is grasped, both that cruelty, and that absurdity, of such pressures and demands on Israel, will be clear.
The confused and ineffectual Obama Administration has no idea how to deal with Islam, and is very likely going to stick with the folly in Afghanistan because it did not prepare the proper framework. The Cairo speech and what it signified for now still makes it impossible for the Obama Administration to see things aright, to recognize and act on the recognition that Islam is the problem. The American government must stop squandering men, money, materiel, morale, and attention (needed for many other things) on hopeless efforts to make Muslim societies happier or more prosperous and Muslim states more unified, but instead welcome every fissure, ethnic, sectarian, and economic, pre-existing within the Camp of Islam.
Many who never knew, or forgot, the real story of the wars or War being made on Israel. We now understand it well enough to describe that war, accurately, as a Jihad against Israel. This Jihad began against the Jews even before the existence of the State, during the Mandatory period, when it was clear that the Jews would not behave as submissive dhimmis. This Jihad has been pursued steadily ever since, by the Muslim Arabs, against the Infidel nation-state of Israel, by open warfare, by terrorism, by economic boycotts, by diplomatic pressure, by every means. This Jihad will never come to an end, but it can be held intelligently in check if Israel remains overwhelmingly stronger militarily, and if in addition the Arabs and other Muslims are convinced that Israel is overwhelmingly stronger. And Israel, if pushed back still further, as dhimmis, if cruelly pressured to give up control of the "West Bank" to which it has a legal, moral, and historic claim, will be far weaker and will be perceived as much much weaker by its enemies. They will not for one minute be assuaged, but will merely have their appetites for Jihad whetted -- and not only for Jihad against Israel, but against all Infidels, including most importantly those in Western Europe.
Despite the BBC and The Guardian and Agence France-Presse and Der Spiegel and so on, the peoples of Western Europe will come to understand Islam. They will come to realize that the narrative, the cunning re-packaging of the unappeasable murderous hostility to Israel as merely a fight for "national liberation" for the "Palestinians," is false. This "tiny people" was invented precisely after the Six-Day War, by Arab propagandists and their able, and well paid, Western advisers and collaborators. By now such words as "occupied" have worked their daily poison. But despite all this, relief is on the way. The cavalry is coming, and the cavalry is being summoned because of the aggressive and violent behavior of Muslims worldwide. That cavalry is nothing more, and nothing less, than an awakening to the texts, the tenets, the attitudes, the atmospherics, of Islam -- and, inexorably, to the real nature of the conflict between Arab and Jew, which is merely a local case of the permanent Jihad against all Infidels, everywhere, who oppose the dominance, over themselves, of Islam.
Such words of hope.. we can only hope they're true. Perhaps what brought this article on was the latest development of the banning of Minarets in a European country? It remains to be seen if this is the start of a new intellectual era or if it's merely a fluke..
The 'sleeping giant' awakes..............
How much effort would it take to wean ourselves from imported oil? There is evidence that we can drill for oil off the West and Eastern coasts. There are large shale oil deposits in the Midwest and we have a huge capacity for the generation of electricity that has gone untapped.
But, of course, we have a President that responds with the ignorant line - "We can't drill our way out of this problem", when asked about offshore drilling.
Can anyone imagine how the world would look if the engine that drives Jihad runs out of money? Would Islam be able to wage war without the trillions of jizya that the civilized world pays in oil revenue? Imagine the jihadi, begging on the street corners of the MiddleEast, hoping for enough pocket change to buy a hand grenade?
Quran verse 9:123 says "Muslims must attack non-Muslims near by (Israel) before attacking non-Muslims far away (USA and Europe)". However the words "near by" and "far away" can be re-interpreted as nations with weak resolve and nations with strong will. Israel showed strong will by making nuclear bombs and building stronger military. So, the Islamic ideologues led by Al Qaeda switched their attention to Europeans, the weakest links in the coalition of the free.
"... most threatening [in] the Netherlands [are] not the Chinese, not the Hindus, not the sub-Saharan but Christian black Africans, not the Filipinos or the South Americans, but always and everywhere the Muslims..."
Alas, not entirely correct - immigrants from the Netherlands Antilles (where I live) are as much trouble in Holland. Doesn't take away from what you say.
Well said, as usual, Hugh. I am forwarding this article to my limited e-mail group and encourage others to do so also simply to cause them to pause, and to consider, the larger picture of what Islam truly is and to open their eyes to the 1,400 year Islamic goal of worldwide domination and subjugation of all peoples everywhere, regardless of political persuasion, religion, or system of governance.
Hugh --
Thanks for a concise summary of the perpetual jihad against Israel. To destroy her would be the ultimate prize -- but even that wouldn't satiate Islamic lust. The goal of world dominance obviously doesn't rule out total destruction, up to and including the last human being on earth.
And the texts of Islam, the tenets of Islam, are coming into view -- slowly but surely.
Don't be so optimistic. Sooner or later the Judeo-Christians are gonna punch back, and that will fuel more obfuscation and errant opinion programming.
*** 92:8 ***
The Moslems, natually aligned with the Marxists, the other world takeover belief system, have the schools, the universities, the newspapers, the judiciary, the legislators, the TV, the churches and synagogues, the consumer market pull, the bureaucracies, the artists, the oil, the intelligentsia, the ruling elites... they have it all. And that's formidable. So far they're batting about .950, and that's a strong pattern that makes for a high confidence interval.
I must disagree with your conclusions. As Islamic violence increases in Europe, people will naturally look for a way of "evening out" their fear of Muslim immigration with condemnation of Israel. This way, they do not appear racist.
After all, condemning Israel is absolutely free (Israel does not attack its critics) and has the great pay-off of winning over, however temporary, European Muslims hearts and minds (and votes).
Plus, its an easy way to explain the Jihadist mind set rather than blame an entire religion which makes Europeans very uncomfortable.
Precisely. Islam is a cult of death and is an enemy of all life and free thought - not only of Israel. Islam is an Orwellian nightmare the like of which not even Orwell may have imagined. Yes, Islam would destroy ALL of life: there would be no end of feuding among the surviving clans. However, our support of Israel - a renewed, strengthened, EXPANDED Israel is the world's best first defense against Islamic supremacism. Also, we must do everything possible - as quickly as possible - to end the strategic importance of oil. AND, we must do exactly as Hugh has suggested: discredit the idiocy of Islam's ideas. I suggest derisive laughter - whenever possible - in LARGE doses. Thank Heaven for Robert and Hugh and Marisol and for commenters like you. We have no time to waste.
The other canary in the coal mine right now is Bosnia, and R.S. Serbs want independence, but the Muslims in Bosnia don't want to let them go. I think mainly because they need Bosnia to be considered as multi-cultural to get into the EU. Bosnian Serbs, and Croatians have had some of the red tape removed visas, but not for the Muslims.
Here is an interesting article on the Mufti of Bosnia and his opinion on the Minaret ban ... note many bosnian Muslims went to Switzerland.
http://www.adnkronos.com/AKI/English/Religion/?id=3.0.4060665936
We can't sell out Serbs in R.S. for ease and simplicity from our perspective. It is an important thing to talk about, whith what Hugh mentions here, remember R.S. Also note during the Bosnian war in the 90's Serbs were smuggling Jews out of Muslim controlled area ... Israel was arming Bosnia .... many recovered shells had Hebrew script. Important not to miss the connection.
WOW I should have reviewed that. have like 4 things going on at work ... you get the point though.
LOL! ROFL! THANK YOU, Tanstaafl! Maybe we could get them some push-carts so they could sell Kosher Hot Dogs to raise money for "jihad". LOL! Maybe it was you that introduced me to precious Anne Korin -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7MVwL2PcCG8
Whoever it was, I'm grateful. We WILL discredit, deride, decrease and deport the death cult of Islam from every freedom loving shore of planet Earth. And laugh at them while they go...
Wonderin1
Great article. The one thing that stopped the muslim advance was meeting a trained army. And once they were turned back they could no longer depend on slaves to to thier bidding and faultered. The West needs to form and mobililze its citizrens army and stand against Islam.
In the natural world, predators have to live among, or follow their prey. In human society, there is also a natural order. The world of workers, and another that lives by raiding the resources of workers. Islam is par excellence a raider society, as exemplified by its founder. Muslims, like predators, have to immigrate to where the prey lives, and live of the excess production of Infidels, or demand Jizya. Quite naturally, they see any attempt to limit the number of predators in Infidel societies, as an existential threat.
So far oil money has kept Muslim societies from bankruptcy. But when the oil money runs out, and immigration of predators to the West is curtailed, we will begin to see very insistent demands by Muslims, even backed up by nuclear threats, to be made part of the Europe. Again, can’t blame them; in the same way I cant blame lions or foxes to get into deer enclosures.
DP111, just look to the investments in the West that current oil money is buying, you'll see how they intend to continue once the oil revenue runs out.
I suppose one could look at these Muslim investments, themselves the creation of workers, as investments in the continued growth of the stock of prey. This comes naturaly to Muslims, for they regard slavery of non-Muslims as quite natural.
What I find very difficult to understand, is our morbid desire to be like the Eloi. Cant understand why this rush to suicide, or to become the domesticated stock for Muslims.
Hate to disagree with you, Hugh, I really do, and I hope I'm wrong, but here is what I think:
Muslims will make mischief etc for Western Europeans as is their wont, and W, Europe will suffer for it. A part of me thinks - Good! now you'll see what Israel has to put up with. And some of W.Europe will react against Muslims in some ineffectual, PC way, and the rest will kepp putting up with it.
Europe in gweneral will keep haitng Jews and Israel, and will blame Jews and Israelis even more for the Muslim oppression engulfing them becaseu they can't blame Muslims becasue Muslims are crazy F**** who will go machete on their a** and trape and kill their way to domination.
Europeans will take out their fear and rage on Jews, who Muslims are already oppressing in W.Europe and will not lift a FINGER to help or supprt Israel or the Jews being driven out and oppressed by Muslims.
Why? Cos they're too scared of Muslims and Jews have always been a handy target.
Europe - with an honourable few exceptions of the Geert Wilders type - does not stand up for what is right. They are complacent conformists out for money and theuir notion of power. That is their main concern. They want Arab oil and will compromise themselves and the world to get it.
Jews and Israel are on their own, despite the sympathy and support of a few friends, because the European "elites" and the leftists, students, rogue Jew idiots and Muslims all hate Jews and what they stand for.
I'd like to be wrong. I hope I am. No-one will be more delighted to be proved incorrect.
test
excuse spelling mistakes - the screen kept shivering.
carpediadem,
I also disagree with usual HF optimism. The narrative of Israel as 'Goliath' to the palestinian's 'David' runs to deep. It is the pre-eminent story archetype used by the world opinion makers I.E. the MSMedia. The powerless and disenfranchised (palestinians) striving to overcome the rich powerful oppressor overloads (The Jews) and reclaim what is rightfully theirs ( er... Israel). The Pluralistic ( palestinians who have many tribes,ethnicities, religions) will triumph over the racists ( The Jews and there klepto-Jewish apartheid State). Good God , I heard these very undertones on a recent BBC report ...
Of course in reality it is Israel who has the weaker position as world opinion is well against them and they need to lose only once. A lonely position that time wearies...
carpediadem,
I also disagree with usual HF optimism. The narrative of Israel as 'Goliath' to the palestinian's 'David' runs to deep. It is the pre-eminent story archetype used by the world opinion makers I.E. the MSMedia. The powerless and disenfranchised (palestinians) striving to overcome the rich powerful oppressor overloads (The Jews) and reclaim what is rightfully theirs ( er... Israel). The Pluralistic ( palestinians who have many tribes,ethnicities, religions) will triumph over the racists ( The Jews and their klepto-Jewish apartheid State). Good God , I heard these very undertones on a recent BBC report ...
Of course in reality it is Israel who has the weaker position as world opinion is well against them and they need to lose only once. A lonely position that time wearies...
"The behavior of Muslims themselves is by now obviously more threatening and intransigent than the behavior of any of the other many immigrant groups that have arrived in Western Europe."
This sounds uncannily like a Nazi propogandist talking about Europe been swamped by Jews, better turn the clock back to 1933.
Why? I say take the oil as reparation for the world wide bloodletting the Muslims have unleashed upon the world. Sound harsh? We (the US) dismantled Shintoism in Japan after WWII, the Brits squashed the Thuggies (a ritual strangulation & theft religious sect), the Spaniards did away with the Mayans (or was it the Incas?) who sacrificed a person each day in order to help the sun rise. And, I almost forgot, the Roman crushed the Druids (a 1,000 yr old religion that engaged in ritual sacrifice) during their conquest of Britian.
This is a multi-generational conflict that will easily outlast the hundred years war. It started with the formation of Israel. We in the west were just to clueless to see it for what it was. ISLAM is at war with world. Imagine this - The US, Russia, Europe, India & China all united against a common enemy - the totalitarian, backward religion of ISLAM. It's destruction & defeat are possible. You just have to think on the proper scale. I say force reparartions out of the middle east at the point of a bayonet. Who gets the money? Primarily India, and every other country that has suffered under the yoke of ISLAM. What a boon to worldwide economic development - free oil for the victims of ISLAM!