Jessie Bender was about to be taken on a two-month trip to Pakistan. Why didn't her mother and stepfather just claim to investigators that their daughter was jumping to conclusions and overreacting?
The parents' elaborate lies suggest they had something to hide. Britain's forced-marriage investigators have seen many a case that started with the ruse of an extended "family vacation" overseas.
Child marriage persists in the Muslim world because Muhammad married a nine-year-old himself (in human years, not Galapagos turtle-years as desperate apologists are bound to claim some time), and Qur'an 33:21 upholds him as a "beautiful pattern of conduct" without exception. Jessie Bender's story shows that "pattern of conduct" can and does endanger girls in America. "Parents of Jessie Bender, 13, lied about daughter, cops say; Was trying to escape arranged marriage," from the New York Daily News, March 3 (thanks to all who sent this in):
A 13-year-old girl reported missing by her parents was really trying to escape an arranged marriage in Pakistan, police said Wednesday.
Jessie Bender's folks told authorities last month their daughter ran off because she didn't want to go on a two-month family trip to her step-father's native country. They then falsely claimed she was abducted by someone she met on Facebook, officials said.
However, after weeks of investigating leads that wrangled the FBI, the U.S. Marshals Office and police departments nationwide, authorities say it was all a lie.
"Bender family members misled detectives and withheld critical information," San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department spokeswoman Roxanne Walker said in a news release.
Police soon discovered that another family member had helped the young teen hide out in Apple Valley, about 30 miles from her hometown of Hesperia in Southern California, to avoid becoming a Pakistani man's bride.
Bender, as well as her three siblings, were taken into child protective custody while authorities decide whether to recommend filing charges against her family, San Bernardino County sheriff's spokeswoman Cindy Bachman said.
"All of the information that was obtained by investigators will be sent to the district attorney's office for review," she said.
They were willing to frame a man to save face:
The parents' claim that she had been kidnapped sparked a nationwide investigation, involving both local and federal agencies. At one point, a person in Chicago was considered a suspect in her disappearance because the girl's mother, Melissa, believed she had been communicating with him via Facebook.
"He was the last person she spoke to at 1:47 in the morning," she told KTLA last month, speaking with her husband, Mohammad Khan. "I don't know who he is ... He claims that he doesn't have her, but I don't believe it."
I saw the yesterday. Muhammed Khan is her step father, not her father. This poor girl is not Pakistani at all.
The use of the word "honor" in cases like this so confuses me.
I accept it is as ubiquitous as rice in moslem cultures to do the most henious and incredible things for "honor" as this case shows.
Perhaps JihadWatch could give us (or has aldready) an article to help us understand what exactly is going that leads people to think killing women, or framing innocent people, and lying is honorable?
Is honor just a clumsy translation like martyr?
Is it from islam's founding mo's example?
Is it because there is no honor in repentance and confession in islam?
Is it because washing 5 times a day makes a person "clean" from any evil act done that means they can even kill their own children and mothers?
Does it pre-date islam perhaps and islam maybe reduces but doesn't eliminate the problem?
I should be most interested in some expert analysis on this subject.
She, Melissa Bender, is a vile, evil, disgusting excuse for a mother. What kind of creature colludes in this against the welfare of her own daughter ? Thank God the poor child had SOMEONE in her family who was ready to help her, and hide her from this monstrous bitch and her vile muslim stepfather. I hope both of them are prosecuted, tried, and jailed. She should never be allowed contact with any of her children, ever again. As for him, he should be deported back to whatever islamic pus hole is the nastiest. Spoilt for choice there.
I hope this doesn't become another Rifqa Bary story.
I think it's reasonable to assume that Jesse Bender's genetic father (NOT Mohammed Khan) lost custody of her to Melissa just on a/c of being vaginally challenged - nothing more, nothing less.
The best punishment for Melissa in this case would be to find him and give him SOLE custody of Jessica. I hope he's a gun owner, and if Melissa or Mohammed dare come within a mile of Jessica, he should dispatch them to Allah so that they can do their virgins.
Just imagine - born non-Muslim, nothing to do w/ Muslims until your mom has her libido needs fulfilled by a tilth-owner. Where are the Menendez brothers when you need them? Or Lorena Bobbitt, for that matter?
^^^oh, sole custody of Jessica AND her siblings!!!
"She, Melissa Bender, is a vile, evil, disgusting excuse for a mother".
If she is married with a Mohammedan, he brainwashed her. Like the mother of Aminah & Sara.
She, the mother has become a mohammedan zombie.
Good on the girl that she ran away. But what next?
Look at the mother - she's become a mindless slave married to a Mohammedan. She needs mental health treatment.
She would force a Pakistani man in Pakistan on her American non-Muslim daughter. It's just incredible, outrageous. She and Mohammed should both be deported to a Crapistan away from Jessica.
Just wondering why do these American/British/European ladies(more broadly non-Muslim ladies) marry any Muslim. Haven't they heard of all terrible tales of such marriages??? Or they are just as brain dead as the guys they marry!!!
The koranimal Khan only married Mellisa Bender to get his green card and he probably was trying to get his step-daughter married off to one of his relatives so that another of the jihadists is safely ensconced in America.
"Today" just featured this story. The girl is a very pretty, very American (i.e. not "Pakistani-American" but 100% European by all appearances) like her mother. If this guy had gotten her to Pakistan, he would have been a ***total rock star*** within his Islamic circles for this "catch." Perhaps then the mother would have had the scales lifted from her eyes and we would have another "Not without my Daughter" horror story.
Any household with children and a Muslim father should be a candidate for a visit from Child Protective Services. And if the father is a MO married to a Western, non-Muslim woman, the children should be flat-out placed in foster care.
Most likely she would have been sold...There's a payoff in there somewhere...I'm not sure, but I think selling a human is illegal...
Also lying to the police is illegal...
But illegal in this case is man made illegal, it's based on kufr...It's not illegal in Allah's laws...Of course we all know that sharia law, or adherence to it, is not legal in the US...Except for Oklahoma, thanks to the superior wisdom of Judge Vicky...Every family member involved in this plot, or who knew about it and said nothing, should be arrested...2-5 would be about right...
Islamic Honor...According to me...Islam is a hyper patriarchal system...Not only is the 'man' in charge, he is 'expected' to be in charge, he is expected to keep his family sharia compliant...His rule must not be challenged...When his daughter falls out of compliance (a form of apostasy), it is a reflection on 'him', it makes 'him' look weak and ineffectual to Allah, and his brothers down at the mosque...It shames him, and by reflection his whole family...If he seems incapable of doing the 'right' thing to fix the problem he loses his stature and honor, and the brothers just might do the 'right thing' for him...Sharia law enables honor killings because there is no Islamic penalty for killing your children or your childrens children...There is also no meaningful penalty for killing an apostate...
Only doing the 'right thing' restores or preserves honor...Allah willing, and he usually is...
"She, Melissa Bender, is a vile, evil, disgusting excuse for a mother. What kind of creature colludes in this against the welfare of her own daughter ?"
Well, Jan, welcome to the club. You've just touched on what is wrong with western women who convert to islam and/or marry mohammadan men.
They are sick, sad, desperate women with low self esteem often obese and usually just plain ugly with emotional and psychological problems. Their willingness to condone engage in and force these vile 7th century custons on their own children is usually in direct proportion to their mental illness and obesity. I would love to see a photo of this woman. I imagine she's a beast.
How do I make these assumptions? I don't. I was one of those sad, desperate and emotionally unstable broads who converted (albeit without help from a mohammadan male-I'm not an idiot)and lived in dar al islam for almost 6 years and in that time I met close to 200 real fruitcakes who also converted.
This woman should lose custody of her child and her and her paki partner should be shipped off to pakiland. And just think-This is just one case that we know of. How many non-mohammadan American children are being abused and exploited so their fat, ugly, emotionally screwed up mothers can pretend that some third world savage "loves" them?
Duh-Swami, that was well-written and informative.
Only wednesday I had a discussion with a young Muslim and participating also was a young "black" lady. We had met because of duty on election-day and after our shift was over we talked politically for a while. (By the way the Freedom Party won substantially!)
I put it to the young Muslim that I was pro-full-democracy and against death-penalty for apostasy in Islam. He responded by reasoning that Muslims consider apostasy something wholly unnatural, regressing if you will, from 3 to 2. But then that Islam really was opposed to all violence, killing and that Iran and Saudi Arabia had it all wrong. Either he used Taqqiya or was "Taqqiya-ed" to by his Imam.
The young woman presented him also with a few challenging questions and in general I think that parties like the Freedom Party should propagate anti-patriarchal values and also much different honor-values than those based on Islam or at least very prevalent among Muslims (saying this because Muslims and Islam-apologists are always quick to deny Islam's role in every detrimental behavior).
There's a picture at the NY Daily News link above. Insofar as one can take it as indicative of the mother's mindset, I think it says something.
Just saw the vile Melissa Bender on Fox. Your assumptions are correct. The invaders in our midst were claiming that their daughter had been kidnapped. Notice how Muslims always accuse someone else of doing what they are going to do.
This child cannot be returned to her "parents" and the other children should be removed from this "family". Mom and Dad can be returned to "the land of the pure".
Thanks for pointing out the link, Marisol.
It looks like the b*&^% doesn't have any teeth!
She reminds me of some British whore I met while in Istanbul. I was looking for a cat-sitter and she came to my flat so I could meet her.
48, a mother of 2 teenagers, married, ugly as sin. She left her children and husband to carry on with some barman who was almost 30 years her junior. He spoke poor English (her words) and she didn't speak a lick of Turkish. She was railing on about how hard this relationship was.
I came unglued. Told her it was not a relationship, she was a desperate, ugly old b&%$# who abandoned her family just so she could feel good about herself. I told her in no way would I trust her with my cat and to leave my flat immediately. She begged me to call a taxi for her as she didn't know Turkish. I told her "oh fats and matures are desirable in Turkish culture, I'm sure you'll find some "romantic" young man to help you out because he has so much respect for foreign womens" and promptly slammed the door in her ugly face.
If there's any justice in the world she learned exactly what mohammadan "repect" towards yabnci orospular(foreign whores)means that night trying to find her way back to the rock she crawled out from under.
The Uncle hid her in a motel for 8 days instead of taking her to the police department?
Her siblings didn't know about the arranged marriage to a man she's probably never met in a country to which she's never been?
Or they did and didn't tell anyone?
For how long had this whole mess been planned?
Had this white American girl--as is appropriate and most likely--said no?
How on earth did these parents expect to pull this off without raising the concern/outrage of other family members.
I suspect the dear old step dad had her lined up for such a ceremony back home (and the green card for another Muslim dirtbag that was sure to follow), but there are many oddities in this story.
And a lot more to be learned, I'm sure.
From the article:
"Bender, as well as her three siblings, were taken into child protective custody while authorities decide whether to recommend filing charges against her family, San Bernardino County sheriff's spokeswoman Cindy Bachman said."
While authorities 'decide whether to recommed filing charges?' Huh? What are the other options? This is CA.
Are the parents in custody after lying to authorities, including the FBI? They definitely seem like flight risks.
http://www.vvdailypress.com/news/hesperia-26283-missing-safe.html
One of the local papers where the DA has never run across forced child marriages before.
Interesting that the grandfather is concerned about another kid.
"Most likely she would have been sold...There's a payoff in there somewhere...I'm not sure, but I think selling a human is illegal..."
What gave you such an absurd idea? Never heard about the labour market? ;-)
Yech. Shows what marriage to a muslim can do. Unless of course she was a total moron in the first place. Whoops, oxymoron.
this mother and step father not only should be tried for lying they also should be tried for child endangerment. this poor young girl. had she been taken to Paksitan, she would have been forced to marry some 50 year old guy and never to be seen again. I bet you they had arranged with some rich pedophile over there.
''I was one of those sad, desperate and emotionally unstable broads who converted (albeit without help from a mohammadan male-I'm not an idiot)and lived in dar al islam for almost 6 years and in that time I met close to 200 real fruitcakes who also converted.''
Istanbul chick, I've read your posts with great interest, since I started reading JW. And I applaud the courage with which you got yourself out of it. I confess however, to curiosity as to how you got INTO it. You say it wasn't because of any involvement with a mohammadan : what exactly about it appealed to you ? If you've already discussed this in a thread I missed, my apologies, equally, I don't mean to be intrusive (posh for nosey), so if you don't wish to discuss it, then of course it's your business. It's just that clearly, there is SOMETHING about it that appeals to some - there was a James Eaton on a previous thread who said he had converted from Catholicism to islam. Also the muslim troll Gerbiltea who used to post here, was also apparently a convert. I suppose I'm thinking that if one could pinpoint WHAT the attraction is for people like you, when 'luurve' was obviously not a factor, we might be able to muster some defence against whatever it is that attracts. Again, my apologies if I'm being nosey.
''How many non-mohammadan American children are being abused and exploited so their fat, ugly, emotionally screwed up mothers can pretend that some third world savage "loves" them?''
Yes, indeed. Also, children in the UK, Eurabia ... someone posted above that such cases should be IMMEDIATELY be investigated by Child Protection Services - I concur, but certainly in the UK, this will never happen when social services are locked into the PC/MC pathetic mindset. All you have to do is look at the case of Baby P. I don't know how these creatures can bear to get up in the morning and look at themselves in the mirror. Slime.
pople generally convert to a different religion because they are missing something. going say from Islam to Christianity or some other way. there is nothing in Islam that is attractive. unless you are a hard line parcticing muslim male and living say in Afghanistan. you have then made it in the shade!! you can have countless wives, marry them as young as 9 year old, be a homosexual pedophile having a 5 year old boy around for your personal pleasure without being bothered by the law, beat the shit of women, and convince an uneducated man to go and blow him self up to have 70 virgins and so on... does this make any sense?
m
"I told her in no way would I trust her with my cat and to leave my flat immediately."
Brava. Because your sweet kitty is so much more valuable than this pathetic Mohammedan human waste. My kitty's too, and everyone else's.
"Also the muslim troll Gerbiltea who used to post here"
Yeah, whatever happened to that Muslim troll? Who cares! Good Riddance.
''If she is married with a Mohammedan, he brainwashed her. Like the mother of Aminah & Sara.''
So, do you think this is some kind of excuse ? ANY mother has one duty first and foremost, and that is to protect her child. There is NO EXCUSE whatsoever, for any abrogation of this responsibility.
OT maybe, but this smacks to me of the sort of attitude which has been discussed on earlier threads, ie: about the bomber who used as his defence that the FBI had inveigled/coaxed him to strap on a murder vest, and this somehow gave him an excuse. The response from Mr. Spencer and others on the thread, was: 'what would it take for you to strap on a murder vest and murder thousands of innocents at the behest of the FBI - ' or something along those lines. The answer of course, was, that no decent human being would never even contemplate such a thing. End of.
In a nutshell I was a libtarded moral and cultural relativist anti-American (angry about Iraq and Afghanistan) with severe depression (basically just feeling sorry for myself).
Everyone there was so nice and inviting and just love bombed me (especially the women) about allah loves good people like me. I was not strong in the faith of my parents and I swallowed the "islam is peace" and "islam respects women" kool-aid. And I thought "while in Rome..." and of course when asked "do you believe there is one God and mohammad is his prohet?" like an idiot I said sure and "praise be to allah! you are muslim!" depsite my having never studied mein kuranmpf (other than a cursory reading 20+ years earlier for a comparative religions course).
And as someone here mentioned about the paki pig that was the intended groom for the American girl being treated like a rock star for bagging such a prize: American, blonde, pretty, young I was a prize: American, blonde, pretty and now MUSLIM! I was treated like a visiting royal everywhere I went. What was not to love about it! Never mind I had no idea what being mohammadan entailed.
But, that's what saved me (sitting down and actually reading the unholy trinity: mein kuranmpf, sirat rasul allah and hadiths), that and the true ugly natures of mohammadans. I learned that their tongues speak different words depending on their audiences. When around non-mohammadans they are all sugar and spice but when around just fellow mohammadans what drips out is ugly, racist, supremacist and utter evil hatred for anything and anyone non-mohammadan. In other words they are world class hypocrites.
So for me being angry, unhappy and just plain bored with being just another average Jane and not being strong in any faith was the catch and being treated like a "rock star" was the hook. I exiled myself, in dar al islam, for many years after my apostasy because I did and still do believe that any westerner who converts, especially taking the shahada in arabic has NO right to live in and enjoy the freedoms of the west.
Hope my answer was not too long. :)
There are many kinds of converts -
1) Those that convert because of marriage (marriage of a muslim women to a non muslim is not permitted, marriage of a muslim man to a jew or christian woman is permitted but all other women/men must convert). People like gerbittea belong to this category
2) Those that convert because of low self esteem, depression. There are also societal misfits and those who are poor performing in their fields/school/work - find it easier to pretend that they belong to something different, something superior to their peers. There are also the weak minded who can be easily brainwashed. I had a friend who was converted in this manner and who tried his best to convert me. However, silly positions such as "those who do not believe will burn in hellfire for eternity" cannot convince any rational thinker. (Especially when believing that mohammad is a "prophet" necessitates the willing suspension of rationality and intelligence).
3)There are those who are inclined to violence for whom islam offers easy prey. The shoe bomber and many other idiots belong to this category
4) There are those who at some point in their life feel the need get their lives under control. Islam is controlling enough to appeal to them (people like Laura Booth belong to this category)
5) Those that fall for the sufi strain (which is nothing but a copy of eastern mysticism)).
6) There are those that convert for material benefits and security. Many of the muslims in Pakistan fall under this category. Once they convert their family member follow suit.
But no sensible person who has read the quran and the wonderful life of mohammad, can possibly be convinced that this is the work of God or that this man was a prophet of God
Istanbul_Chick, you were spot on about the mother being obese and plain looking(not ugly). Anyway here is the link, you can see for yourself.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1362442/Missing-13-year-old-girl-fled-avoid-arranged-marriage-Pakistan.html
That was really interesting, and very honest ! Thanks for indulging my curiosity.
Excellent post, very well reasoned. Thanks. BTW, what exactly are the 'material benefits'? Do they get money from the mosque/imam? ( I can see where the 'security' comes in !)
Yes ! Thanks.
The mother is pathetic. Thank God her American non-Muslim daughter had wits about her and was astute enough to smell something foul: pretty good for a 13-year-old. The fact she had normal friend saved her from life of misery and bondage. I am hoping that she will serve as a good example for those young Muslim girls needing protection from their own families and also serve as a warning for the community.
There are enough gullible women out there who often fall for abusive men. To these insecure women with low self esteem Muslim men can use their exotic charm with their polite and mild manner. Have you not heard that "Muslim men treat their women like queens"?
Clicked on the link and read some of the comments at the end.
I can understand the uncle waiting to come forward with the young lady. Perhaps he wanted to give the mother and stepfather time to tell a bunch of lies so when he did bring her forward or they were found out, the girl would be given protection from her mother and stepfather.
Hopefully, the girl and her siblings will be given life-long protection from these two who were trusted with her care and failed to put her interests ahead of their own sick ones.
Istanbul Chick: "I exiled myself, in dar al islam, for many years after my apostasy because I did and still do believe that any westerner who converts, especially taking the shahada in arabic has NO right to live in and enjoy the freedoms of the west."
Aw, you are really hard on yourself, ease up a bit, you made a terrible mistake but you rectified it! Converts who apostacize are really needed in the West, to tell their stories and warn others and expose the Muslim tactics!
Wow, thanks for your honesty, courage and humour. I found myself attracted and almost fooled by a muslim who wanted me to convert to islam. from a brown-skinned hindu family, unlike you, I knew about islam and how islam had caused the murder of millions of hindus for 14 centuries. I KNEW IT and YET I was almost taken in by love jihad.
Please do not be hard on yourself. Muslim men can be very cocky, charming...they know what to say. Maybe okay to have fun with (if they are not violent) but not marriage material. Many hindu women have told me that muslim men are sexy - look at the pakistani muslim cricketeers and hindu bollywood actress phenomena Now, perhaps emulating their rapist prophet leads to them to try to conquer us kafir women, I don't know, but the appeal wears off pretty quickly.
"BTW, what exactly are the 'material benefits'? Do they get money from the mosque/imam?"
For example, in Pakistan, christian landowners are less likely to have their land grabbed for paltry reasons if they convert. The friend that I was talking about was able to get a really great job in Saudi after converting.
These vile, reprehensible scumbags should be charged with sex-slave trafficking; they were about to subject this poor child to a life of unimaginable horror. How could a mother who was once 'normal' sacrifice her own flesh and blood to please a filthy muslim pig?
This poor girl was betrayed by her mother. No doubt her step-father married her mother in order to eventually use her daughter to bring someone into the U.S. As the Italian Mafia would marry vulnerable American women so they could obtain citizenship and have the freedom of travel in and out of the country (at least 2-year marriages which usually ended in death for the bride), so the global jihad uses the same system. Of course, with the Islamic domination and control and abuse of women, it would either be less likely the bride would disappear unless she rebelled, or harder to clearly recognize another motive for the disappearance/death.
I did not convert for a man. Please, re-read my post.
There is nothing in there to even suggest I was a complete idiot.
Before converting and even after I had zero interest in any mohammadan males. There is nothing attractive about them, physically(even the "educated" ones dress, look and act like some grotesque charicature of the greasy-slimy pimp/playboy stereotype), emotionally or psychologically.
And why would a Hindu or Sikh girl find them attractive? As you said YOU KNEW what they were capable of.
I admit, I like Shah Ruhk and Amir Khan but to even imagine a relationship with them turns my stomach.
Besides, Hindu boys are a hoot. I know, I married one.
I've known U.S. women who have married Muslims and converted. One in particular was not ugly, but was tall and felt awkward about being taller than a lot of men. The Muslim man stepped in and treated her like a queen, was extremely polite to her, complimented her constantly, all his Muslim friends treated her with respect (there is an Arabic word for a women being seduced, and the second he said it they would snap on the charm), gave her gifts, charmed her family. She swooned.
The second he married her, she was whisked away to the Middle East for six months to be gotten under control by him and his family. She came back conditioned and unsure of herself. She became more and more isolated as he forbid one after another of her friendships. Whereas before she had been engaged and glib/sarcastic, she became more and more careful about what she said. I once saw her husband punch her in the leg for not verbally agreeing with something (minor) he said. After she had his son, she was completely isolated. Even her family was not allowed to see her. She was eventually found dead (beaten to death) and her husband and son had disappeared, gone back to the Middle East. Of course, her son was a U.S. citizen and would eventually be able to bring his whole family to the U.S., like he had told her he wanted.
Sorry, but there's something psychologically wrong with women who fall in love with "charm."
These women will run background checks on American men who are courting them, yet they jump into marriage with these slimeballs without wholly knowing them.
Even American wife beaters show signs of their sickness before they "trap the chick." These women are so sick and convinced that these slimeballs are "prince charming" (thanks Rudolph Valentino for creating the FALSE image of the charming bedouin savage)that they ignore the obvious signs. And let's face it, unless you've been living under a rock for the past 20 years, you're a nincompoop if you think there's anything romantic or charming about mohammadan males.
These women are cut from the same cloth as women who get into "relationships" with convicted killers and rapists.