Turkish-American CNN columnist: Kemalist secularism is dead

Not that we didn't know that already. Cagaptay doesn't say it outright, but Turkey is slowly, peacefully and inexorably restoring Sharia, and hints of that appear in his article. "Kemalism is dead, but not Ataturk," by Soner Cagaptay for CNN, May 2 (thanks to Joshua):

Has Turkey’s twentieth century experience with Kemalism - a Europe-oriented top-down Westernization model - come to an end?

To a large extent: Yes.

Symbolically speaking, nothing could portend the coming end of Kemalism better than the recent public exoneration of Iskilipli Atif Hoca, a rare resistance figure to Kemalism in the early twentieth century. However, even if Kemalism might be withering away, ironically its founder Ataturk and his way of doing business seem to be alive in Turkey.

But first the story of Iskilipli Atif Hoca: In November 1925, Ataturk carried out perhaps the most symbolic of his reforms, banning all Turkish males from wearing the Ottoman fez in order to cement his country's commitment to European ideals. Ataturk wanted make Turks European head to toe and the abolition of the fez embodied this effort.

Most Turks acquiesced to Ataturk’s reforms, not just to the “hat reform” but also to deeper ones such as the “alphabet reform,” which changed the Turks’ script from an Arab alphabet-based one to its current Latin-based form, further connecting the Turks to European culture.

Ataturk was able to achieve these reforms with minor resistance thanks to the weight of his persona. After all, Ataturk - who had just liberated Turkey from a massive Allied occupation - was considered nothing short of a father to all Turks.

Some Turks, however, objected to his reforms.

Enter Atif Hoca, a cleric in the small central Anatolian town of Iskilip, who refused to adhere to Ataturk's “hat reform.” Atif Hoca defended his use of the fez, couching his objections in Islam. He rallied to protest against the reforms and began publishing essays in local papers. He was executed in February 1926, becoming a rare icon of resistance to Kemalism.

Recently though, Atif Hoca’s legacy has been reversed in the public eye. In February 2012, the government decided to name a public hospital in Iskilip - Atif Hoca’s hometown - after him. This dedication carries remarkable symbolic significance, as it is tantamount to honoring one of the best known anti-Kemalists to date, as well as signaling Turkey’s move to a post-Kemalist era.

Kemalism appears to have lost its influence, not just symbolically but also politically. In the past decade, Turkey has undergone a complete transformation. The ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) has won three consecutive elections since 2002, with increasing majorities. The AKP, representing a brand of Islam-based social conservatism, has since replaced Turkey’s former Kemalist ideology and secular elites. Turkey seems to be moving to a post-Kemalist era....

| 11 Comments
del.icio.us | Digg this | Email | FaceBook | Twitter | Print | Tweet

11 Comments

| Leave a comment

I spent four years in Ankara and, once I became familiar with the destruction of Kemalism being carried out by Recep Erdoclown and his fellow Saudi-wannabes, I wondered if the Atatutk Mausoleum, or Anitkabir, might eventually be fitted with minarets and converted into a mosque. Judging by how things have been going, that sadly seems to be a real possibility.

Just more proof that Islam won't go quietly into the night. No, it's going to go kicking and screaming into the night before it finally disgusts the entire world with its many pathologies and heinous aspects. It ain't gonna' be pretty. Ataturk did what he could to get rid of the rotting corpse, but, in zombie like form, it's going to be around for one more final and bloody round.

No doubt the resurgence of the Ottoman Empire is next on Erdogan's to-do list.

"Kemalism is dead, but not Ataturk," by Soner Cagaptay for CNN...

However, even if Kemalism might be withering away, ironically its founder Ataturk and his way of doing business seem to be alive in Turkey.
..................................

In what way is Ataturk and his "way of doing business" still alive in Turkey—unless he means Erdogan still has a way to go before Turkey is Pakistan?

More likely, it's just one of those vacuous swerves sloppy journalists throw into stories to make them appear more nuanced.

More:

Symbolically speaking, nothing could portend the coming end of Kemalism better than the recent public exoneration of Iskilipli Atif Hoca, a rare resistance figure to Kemalism in the early twentieth century...

Most Turks acquiesced to Ataturk’s reforms, not just to the “hat reform” but also to deeper ones such as the “alphabet reform,” which changed the Turks’ script from an Arab alphabet-based one to its current Latin-based form, further connecting the Turks to European culture...
..................................

"Acquiesced"—not embraced. Islam—that "rotting corpse"—was always just below the surface in Turkish life, waiting to resurface in all its nastiness.

More:

Ataturk was able to achieve these reforms with minor resistance thanks to the weight of his persona. After all, Ataturk - who had just liberated Turkey from a massive Allied occupation - was considered nothing short of a father to all Turks.
..................................

This is an odd way of looking at things—or maybe not. After all, getting rid of Infidels is still pretty "Islamic", no matter what Ataturk's other objections to it.

Even more salient, the Armenian Genocide—which rid the country not just of most Christian Armenians, but also most Christian Greeks, Christian "Levantines", and Jews—proceeded apace under Ataturk, just as it had under the Ottoman Empire and the transitional "Young Turks". Ataturk did nothing to stop it or blunt its savagery. Even he, likely, realized there areas where he would have *no* influence with his Muslim countrymen—or perhaps he approved himself.

More:

Enter Atif Hoca, a cleric in the small central Anatolian town of Iskilip, who refused to adhere to Ataturk's “hat reform.” Atif Hoca defended his use of the fez, couching his objections in Islam.
..................................

"Couching his objections in Islam"—of course he did.

More:

Recently though, Atif Hoca’s legacy has been reversed in the public eye. In February 2012, the government decided to name a public hospital in Iskilip - Atif Hoca’s hometown - after him. This dedication carries remarkable symbolic significance, as it is tantamount to honoring one of the best known anti-Kemalists to date, as well as signaling Turkey’s move to a post-Kemalist era.
..................................

Except for its history and modern weapons capabilities, I imagine this will be more like Turkey's *pre-Kemaliist* era—oppressing its religious minorities, mistreating its women, and threatening its Christian, Jewish, and atheist neighbors...

Can a national name-change be far behind?

Good-bye Turkey, hello Ottomania?

Well if we look at the history of Islam it was silenced before by force. Now it is much stronger than before thanks to our dependence on oil. With all the discussions going on as to how to fight against this evil doctrine, I dont see any other way but what has worked in the past will work again now and the future which is, yes, united infidel force. Unfortunately peace has always been achieved by FORCE.

With respect, Sam Arisan, I would argue that Islam is "stronger than before" not first and foremost due to the West's dependence on Middle Eastern oil (which would have never been extracted in the first place but for Western, i.e., non-Islamic, technology), but because a willful ignorance of Islam is still extensive in the West.

Most culpable here are the present Western elites in the media, academia, the political world and, sadly, even in the hierarchy of the militaries of the West. Yes, in the final analysis, ignorance is even more lethal than oil in the fight against what Islam ultimately intends for the West. Damn sad but damn true.

Maybe if we gave full membership of EU. If only we had done a deal with the Third Reich there would have been no WW2. (lol) No doubt Turkey will be connecting the muslim fifth column dots at some point EU or not.

"Turkish court hearing in Duchess of York secret filming case"

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17956643


"Turkey Blocks EU Participation in NATO Summit Unless OIC Attends"

http://stopturkey.blogspot.co.uk/2012/05/turkey-blocks-eu-participation-in-nato.html

Is Soner Cagaptay dismayed about this development, or does he welcome it?

Kepha wrote:

Is Soner Cagaptay dismayed about this development, or does he welcome it?
.................................

Damn good question, Kepha.

Here's Soner Cagaptay appearing to decry "Islamism"—but at the same time claiming that the main thing that gives Al Qaeda its power is Western "Islamophobia":

"Please, Call Us Islamic"

http://www.cagaptay.com/6669/please-call-us-islamic

He is, essentially, asserting that Jihad has nothing to do with Islam—although he never uses the "J" word.

Here, in 2005, Cagaptay argues that Turkey has strict separation of mosque and state, and so "radical Islam" is no threat there, or among Turks in Europe. Of course, he is making this assertion in the context of arguing that Turkey be given full EU membership. Has he changed his mind on any of these points in the past seven years? Who knows?

"Turkey and Europe's Problem with Radical Islam"

http://www.cagaptay.com/679/turkey-and-europes-problem-with-radical-islam

He even uses a subhead in this article, "Turkish Secularism: Lessons for Europe"—which took a lot of gall, even back in 2005...

And here's an absolutely *shocking* assertion from him from two years ago:

"Turkey may be the most Muslim nation in the world. It was forged through blood and war as a state exclusively by and for Muslims -- a claim it shares only with Pakistan. Fleeing persecution in Europe, Russia, and the Caucasus, millions of Turkish and non-Turkish Muslims settled there, and today almost half of Turkey’s 73 million citizens are descendants of these disparate peoples. This little-known story is why modern Turkey was born a Muslim nation: when the Ottoman Empire finally collapsed at the end of World War I, Muslims from all over the empire joined with ethnic Turks to defend the new nation against Christian foes -- the Allied forces, Armenians, and Greeks...."

These "Christian foes" were their *own non-violent population of Christians*, whose heritage in Turkey much predated Islam. He is here speaking glowingly of the **Armenian genocide**.

"Sultan of the Muslim World
Why the AKP’s Turkey Will Be the East’s Next Leader"

http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/67009/soner-cagaptay/sultan-of-the-muslim-world?page=show

He is somewhat critical of some aspects of the AKP's Islamizing of Turkey, but these seem to be more strategic cavils than anything else.

Overall, he comes across as a pretty thorough-going Muslim apologist—and, especially, as a booster of Turkey—seemingly, in whatever form that might take.

Cagaptay's analysis in the article heading this thread is quite honest—that *does not* means we should regard his as any sort of critic of Islam.

Leave a comment

NOTE: The Comments section is provided in the interests of free speech only. It is mostly unmoderated, but comments that are off topic, offensive, slanderous, or otherwise annoying stand a chance of being deleted. The fact that any comment remains on the site IN NO WAY constitutes an endorsement by Jihad Watch, or by Robert Spencer or any other Jihad Watch writer, of any view expressed, fact alleged, or link provided in that comment.







Not Peace But A Sword by Robert SpencerDid Muhammad Exist? The Muslim Brotherhood in America, by Robert SpencerIslamophobia: Thoughtcrime of the Totalitarian FutureMuslim Persecution of Christians, by Robert Spencer Obama and IslamThe Ground Zero Mosque: Second Wave of the 9/11 Attacks
The Complete Infidel’s Guide to the Koran


Stealth Jihad


The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam


The Truth About Muhammad


What they’re saying about Robert Spencer
“My comrade-in-arms, my pal, my buddy.”
Oriana Fallaci

“Robert Spencer incarnates intellectual courage when, all over the world, governments, intellectuals, churches, universities and media crawl under a hegemonic Universal Caliphate’s New Order. His achievement in the battle for the survival of free speech and dignity of man will remain as a fundamental monument to the love of, and the self-sacrifice for, liberty.”
Bat Ye’or

“Robert Spencer is indefatigable. He is keeping up the good fight long after many have already given up. I do not know what we would do without him. I appreciate all the intelligence and courage it takes to keep going despite the appeasement of the West.”
Ibn Warraq

“America's most informed, fearless, and compelling voice on modern jihadism.”
Andrew C. McCarthy, Senior Fellow at National Review Institute

“Robert Spencer is the leading voice of scholarship and reason in a world gone mad. If the West is to be saved, we will owe Robert Spencer an incalculable debt.”
Pamela Geller, Atlas Shrugs

"The consummate Islam critic and expert." — Bruce Bawer

“Over the years, we have become friends, and I have received his assistance on several pieces of legislation I proposed.”
Former Congressman Tom Tancredo

“Few people are capable of applying scholarship, analytical reasoning, and objectivity to their topic -- while simultaneously being readable and witty -- as can Robert Spencer.”
Raymond Ibrahim

“A national treasure...The acclaimed scholar of Islam.”
Frank Gaffney, Center for Security Policy

“I am indeed honored to call him my friend.”
Brad Thor, novelist

“A top American analyst of Islam....A serious scholar...I learn from him.”
Daniel Pipes

“A brilliant scholar and writer.”
Douglas Murray

"One of my best teachers."
Ashraf Ramelah, Voice of the Copts

“Thank God there’s at least one man with balls left in the West.”
Kathy Shaidle, Five Feet of Fury

“I read people like [Mark Steyn] and Bob Spencer and the rest of them, and I say, ‘Boortz, you’re pretending you’re an author. These people really are. They really write some entertaining, some standup stuff.’”
Neal Boortz

“Robert Spencer is the Stephen King of Jihad.”
Chris Gaubatz, Muslim Mafia

“Armed with facts and fearlessness, Spencer stands up for Western civilization.”
Michelle Malkin

“Widely read in conservative foreign policy circles.”
New York Times

“Widely read in many quarters in Washington.”
Washington Post

“A canny operative who likely has the inside track on the State Department’s Middle East affairs desk should the tea party win the White House.”
New York Magazine

“A hero of the American right.”
Karen Armstrong

"The leading anti-Islamic intellectual in the United States....The go-to Islam expert for the right wing."
Salon Magazine

“Robert Spencer is an Edward Said turned upside down.”
Stephen Suleyman Schwartz

“One of the nation's most notorious Islamophobes.”
Hamas-linked CAIR

"Geller and Spencer are probably the most important propagandizing Islamophobes in the world. These people's voices speak very loudly — not just here in the United States but overseas."
Heidi Beirach, Southern Poverty Law Center

“Satanic ignoramus.”
Khaleel Mohammed

“The Likud anti-Christ.”
Dar al-Hayat newspaper (Saudi Arabia)

“Zionist Crusader, missionary of hate, counter-Islam consultant.”
Al-Qaeda’s Adam Gadahn, “Azzam the American”



Follow me on Twitter
facebook islam
RSS feed

Monthly Archives



Donate
Jihad Watch is a 501 (c) 3 organization. Donations are tax-deductible.


Robert Spencer debates on The Quran Teaches WarVideo: Robert Spencer on CPAC Breitbart News
SIOAFreedom Defense InitiativeJihad Watch VideosAmerican Freedom Law Center
Note: Listing here does not imply endorsement of every view expressed at every linked site.

» ACT for America
» Always on Watch
» American Center for Democracy
» American Coptic Association
» American Council for Kosovo
» American Freedom Alliance
» American Freedom Law Center
» American Islamic Forum for Democracy
» American Sheepdogs
» American Thinker
» Americans Against Hate
» Americans for Legal Immigration
» Amerisrael
» Amillennialist Contra Mundum
» Annaqed
» A New Dark Age Is Dawning
» Answering Islam
» Answering Muslims
» Anti-CAIR
» Apostates of Islam
» Aramaic Broadcasting Network (ABN)
» Armies of Liberation
» Assyrian International News Agency
» Atlas Shrugs
» Atour — The State of Assyria
» Australian Islamist Monitor
» Biafra Nation
» Blazing Cat Fur
» Bosch Fawstin
» Brad Thor
» Brussels Journal
» CAIR Watch
» Campus Watch
» Caroline Glick
» Christians Under Attack
» Citizen Warrior
» Coalition for the Defense of Human Rights
» Conservative Nation News
» Copts.com
» Creeping Sharia
» Daniel Pipes
» David Horowitz Freedom Center
» The David Project
» David Thompson
» David Yerushalmi Law
» D. C. Watson
» Dearborn Underground
» DEBKAfile
» Dhimmitude.org
» Dry Bones
» Ellis Washington Report
» Europe News
» Eye On Islam
» Ezra Levant
» Faith Freedom International
» Father Zakaria
» Federale
» Five Feet of Fury
» Foundation for Democracy in Iran
» Free Congress Foundation
» The Free Copts
» Freedom Defense Initiative
» FrontPage Magazine.com
» Geert Wilders
» Genocide1915.info
» Global Research in International Affairs (GLORIA) Center
» History of Jihad
» Hizb ut-Tahrir Watch
» Honest Reporting
» Honor Killings
» Human Rights Congress for Bangladesh Minorities
» India Defence
» Infidel Blogger’s Alliance
» Infidels Are Cool
» The Intelligence Summit
» International Analyst Network
» International Free Press Society
» Internet Haganah
» The Investigative Project on Terrorism
» IOwnTheWorld.com
» IranPressNews
» Iran va Jahan
» Islam Review
» Islam Speaks
» Islam Versus Europe
» Islam Watch
» Islamic Terrorism in India
» Islamist Watch — Middle East Forum
» Israel Matzav
» JihadOnBuddhists.org
» Kejda Gjermani
» KRSI: Radio Sedaye Iran
» Liberated
» Logan's Warning
» Looking At the Left
» Mahdi Watch
» Mapping Sharia
» Mark Steyn
» Martin Kramer
» MEMRI TV
» Middle East Facts
» Middle East Quarterly
» Middle-East-Info.org
» Middle East Media Research Institute
» Middle East Review of International Affairs (MERIA)
» Militant Islam Monitor
» Morning Star
» Muhammad Tube
» The Muslim Issue
» Muslim World Today
» Myths and Facts
» National Vietnam & Gulf War Veterans Coalition
» NewsReal Blog
» No Mosques At Ground Zero
» Nonie Darwish
» Northeast Intelligence Network
» Occidental Jihadist
» One Jerusalem
» Open Speech
» Operation Give
» Operation Gratitude
» Organiser
» Orwellian Culture
» Palestinian Media Watch
» PamelaGeller.com
» Panun Kashmir
» Pedestrian Infidel
» The People's Cube
» The People of the Book
» Persecution Project
» Political Islam
» Politically Incorrect
» Politiskt Inkorrekt
» Q Society of Australia
» Radio Farda
» Radio Jihad
» RAWA: Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan
» Raymond Ibrahim
» Red Alerts
» Refugee Resettlement Watch
» Religion of Peace
» Republican Riot
» Reuters Middle East Watch
» The “Reverend” Jim Sutter
» SANE: Society of Americans for National Existence
» The Second Draft
» Shire Network News
» SITE Intelligence Group
» Small Wars Journal
» Smoke-Filled World
» The Snooper Report
» Snow Report Blog
» StandWithUs
» Steve Lackner
» The Stiletto Blog
» STOP! Honour Killings
» Sultan Knish
» Tell the Children the Truth
» Terrorism Awareness Project
» Theodore’s World
» Tom Gross Media
» Translating Jihad
» Una via per Oriana
» Undaunted
» United States Central Command
» Urban Infidel
» Walid Shoebat
» Winds of Jihad
» Women Against Shariah
» World Council for the Cedars Revolution
» Yid With Lid
» Z Street
» Zilla of the Resistance
» Zionist Conspiracy
Crucified Again by Raymond IbrahimDavid LittmanOriana Fallaci Thousands of Deadly Terror Attacks Since 9/11The incredible Reza Aslan automated insult generator! iGoogle Gadget
Site Meter