FrontPageMag.com By Robert Spencer By Hugh Fitzgerald Books Dhimmi Watch Islam 101 Qur'an Blog Raymond Ibrahim Robert Spencer
 
« The Iran Factor | Main | Videotape Shows Captive American Soldier »

April 17, 2004

Italy: outraged or ready to cave in to terror?

wirq16.jpeg
The Italian hostages

This Telegraph story shows that after the Italian hostage was killed, in Italy there is both defiance and signs of quavering dhimmitude and caving in to terrorism a la Madrid: "if only we had negotiated with the kidnappers" etc. Few seem to remember that if you pay the Danegeld, you never get rid of the Dane. (Thanks to Jeffrey Imm for the link.)

The Italian hostage executed in Iraq tried to tear off his hood seconds before he was shot dead and screamed: "Now I'll show you how an Italian dies."

Details of the final moments of Fabrizio Quattrocchi deepened Italy's shock and outrage at the hostage crisis as it awaited further news of the three other men seized with him on Monday.

The Italian foreign minister, Franco Frattini, yesterday hailed as a hero Mr Quattrocchi, 36, a former baker. The killers filmed the murder and Mr Frattini revealed details after Italy's ambassador to Qatar was shown the footage by the Arab television station Al-Jazeera, which has not broadcast the video.

"I have been authorised by the [victim's] family . . . to reveal the final words of this boy who died what I would call a courageous death, I would say like a hero," Mr Frattini said.

"When his assassins were pointing a gun at him, this boy tried to remove the hood and shouted: 'Now I'll show you how an Italian dies.' And they killed him."

Mr Quattrocchi's abductors shot him in the neck at close range. Al-Jazeera said that he had been forced to dig his own grave.

Foreign minister Franco Frattini confirmed the news during a TV awards show
Millions of Italians, including the victim's family in Genoa, learned of his death while watching a chat show on Wednesday night.

Relatives of the other hostages were in the audience. They had an agonising wait to discover which man had died after hearing that a hostage had been killed before the programme was aired. Although Mr Frattini was among the programme's guests, it was the show's host, Bruno Vespa, who made the announcement at midnight. Then Mr Frattini confirmed the grim news of Mr Quattrocchi's death.

Francesco Cupertino, the brother of one of the other hostages, asked the foreign minister: "What will happen now?" Mr Frattini replied: "We have to work hard to bring them out." He said Italy would do "what is possible and impossible". But he underlined that it would not negotiate with the kidnappers, who call themselves the Green Brigade of the Prophet.

Mr Quattrocchi was born in Sicily and moved to Genoa with his family. He had become a bodyguard after doing a stint as a nightclub bouncer then signed up to work in Iraq.

He was said to have accepted a job as a security guard working in Iraq for an American company, to earn enough for a home in Italy and to get married.

"Fabrizio was a wonderful man, a man of iron but who had never hurt a fly," his fiancee, Alice, told Italian television yesterday. "He was supposed to come back to me and we were to be married.

"The only consolation is that he died with honour."

But relatives of one of the other hostages, Salvatore Stefio, 34, reacted with despondency and despair. "He may have died a hero but he is still dead," said Mr Stefio's younger brother Christian. Mr Stefio's wife Emanuala, said: "With the murder of Fabrizio Quattrocchi, part of us has also died."

Mr Stefio's father Angelo called on Italians to "take to the streets in order to stop all this". He appealed for the peacekeeping coalition to try to broker an exchange to secure the remaining hostages' release.

Al-Jazeera said a statement sent with the video had given a warning that three other Italians who were working for an American company and were kidnapped with Mr Quattrocchi near Fallujah would be killed "one by one".

Most Italian politicians closed ranks around Silvio Berlusconi, the centre-Right prime minister, who has said he will not be bullied into withdrawing 3,000 Italian troops from Iraq. "They have cut short a life," Mr Berlusconi said. "They have not damaged our values and commitment to peace."

However, Mr Quattrocchi's family said he might have lived if Mr Berlusconi had not made "rash" comments after the kidnappings.

"Before making declarations of force, the government would have done better to have opened talks with the kidnappers," the family said.

"There is the feeling that the government wanted to make a show of strength by playing with the lives of those [Italians] in Iraq."

Colleagues of Mr Quattrocchi said he had been captured while accompanying a group of clients on the road to Amman in Jordan.

Posted by Robert at April 17, 2004 8:53 AM
Print this entry | Email this entry | Digg this | del.icio.us |

Comments
(Note: The Comments section is provided in the interests of free speech only. It is mostly unmoderated, but comments that are off-topic, offensive, slanderous, or otherwise annoying stand a chance of being deleted. The fact that any comment remains on the site IN NO WAY constitutes an endorsement by Jihad Watch or Dhimmi Watch, or by Robert Spencer or any other Jihad Watch or Dhimmi Watch writer, of any view expressed, fact alleged, or link provided in that comment.)

I'm glad to tell you that THIS Italian government will never withdraw the troops from Iraq. The great majority of the Italian people is against the withdrawl. As far as the video is concerned, al-Jazeera has decided against the broadcast not because it is gruesome, but because the whole civilised world would revolt, after seeing the scene of the hostage looking (some say helping) at the assassins digging his grave!

Posted by: spartacus at April 17, 2004 11:38 AM

MR Quatrtrochi was a Sicilian.
In Sicily HOnor dictates that such a horrific killing cannot go unavenged.
The murderers have picked the wrong man.
After the other Italian Hostages have been released or murdered Al Jazeera will be receiving a new "Video tape" from Sicily.
retaliation is the only language these scum ill understand.

Posted by: David at April 17, 2004 12:56 PM

David: Why should they wait until the others are released or killed? The roundup of Muslims should begin now!

By the way, an Israeli missile strike has just killed Hamas leader, Rantisi and his two bodyguards. No one else was killed. It was an exact hit!

Posted by: Chaya Eitan at April 17, 2004 2:43 PM

La Forza del Ragione has sold several hundred thousand copies. On the television, Magdi Allam, a Venetian named Jaccha, and another man whose name I forget are all offering explanations of Islam, and geopolitics, superior to anything here.

The great crook of modern Italian politics -- it has been all down hill since De Gasperi -- was the sinister bridge-playing, too-pious Andreotti, when the Christian Democrats were at the height of their corruption.

Andreotti was accused of having close ties to the Mafia in Sicily. (If I remember rightly, it was Tommaso Buscetta who spilled the beans). He was specifically accused of ordering the killing of a too-inquisitve journalist. There are so many stories about him, so many reports, so many tales, that only a fool would have thought him innocent. But he did manage to beat the rap (I think the trial took place in Perugia, as trials will). He beat the rap, but everyone of sense knows he was, and remains, a crook.

But the other thing to remember about Andreotti, aisde from his being linked to every scandal, and the shadow of every scandal, in recent Italian history -- Banco Ambrosiano, Licio Gelli and Pdue,, if-there's-a-scandal-there's-got-to-be-an-Andreotti-connection, all the matters that used to take up, the first 8-10 pages of virtually every issue of the Corriere della Sera -- is that he was at the very heart of a sinister philo-Arab policy, with not all of its tentacles exposed. In Italy, he was the Arabs' main man. Exactly what he did, in the early days of the Euro-Arab Dialogue, is likely laid out by Fallaci in La Forza della Ragione.

It may be that the pious President Pertini's folly, more than a decade ago, of giving 7 acres of prime, government-owned real estate in Rome to the Muslims so that the Saudis could build a huge mosque (a beachhead for the Army of Allah), not one mile from the Vatican, was not his idea alone -- he may have been manipulated by Andreotti, whose own link to Western civilization consists largely of his favorite pastime, playing bridge with Roman ladies. About Andreotti, nothing would surprise me.

Whether Quatrocchi is remembered for his heroism, and his murderers for being murderers, or whether it will be somehow twisted so that America is blamed, Muslim killers absolved, one simply cannot predict. But it is safe to predict that should the demographic conquest of Itlay succeed, the statues and paintings in Rome and Florence, in Umbria and the Veneto, will have to be preserved by being shipped over to America, in its redoubtable redoubt.

It would be fitting. From 1933 on, the United States, and to a lesser extent Great Britain, were the grateful recipients of the greatest group of art historians in the history of the world. But the murderous Nazis were willing to preserve, for their own Nazi delectation, the statues and the paintings of that civilization which they were making war upon. In that line, think of Goering's loot, all those stacked paintings.

Muslims, while no slouches in the murdering line, when it comes to Jews (or Christians, Hindus, Sikhs, for that matter), go even further than the Nazis when it comes to art. The Qur'an is absolutely clear, and all its learned doctors agree: no statuary, and no depictions of the human form (Mughal paintings were produced despite, in violation, of Islam).

Before and during World War II, the United States was the beneficiary of its own political stability and decency, when so many sought refuge. There were the scientists, hounded out whether young or old, from Nazi Germany or from Italy after the racial laws: in biology, a whole list, from Otto Loewi to Konrad Bloch, might be supplied. In physics, from Budapest alone came John von Neumann, Leo Szilard, Edward Teller. The racial laws of Italy gave Enrico Fermi (because of his wife), Cesare Segre, Franco Modigliani (if economics can be included here.

But, making landfall safely at NYU. and Harvard. and the Institute for Advanced Study. and the Warburg. and the Courtauld were a host of art historians, trained in the most rigorous manner, were also a great many art historians who not only produced important work, but trained the generation that trained the generation that...well, you know. Their names will immediately be recognized: the inimitable Panofsky, Walter Friedlaender, Jakob Rosenberg, Ernst Kitzinger, John Rewald, E. H. Gombrich, Walter Giedion, Rudolf Wittkower, and on, and on.

And now, having received a large gift of art historians as a result of one cataclysmic horror, the United States may, in coming years, receive a second donation, for a different kind of body-blow to civilisation -- the takeover, through nothing more than over-breeding, of Western Europe by its Muslim population. For today one out of every three children born in France is Muslim. That means, in 20 years one out of every three French children will be a Muslim, and 20 years after that, half of the population of 20 year olds will be Muslim -- if nothing is done. Does it matter? Should we care? Is procreation a personal matter, and should a mere counting of heads decide our collective fate? Is there nothing that can be done?

Curators of America, dream your dreams, and scheme your schemes, and built those buildings. If you build them, don't worry -- the real art will come. Alas.

Those who ask if the muezzin's wail will one day be heard in Rome can be answered: It already is. Will the dream of Muhammad, contained in a hadith, and in recent years widely circulated on the Islamic websites, in which he predicts that "first Constantinople, and then Rome" will fall to Islam, become a reality?

Forse che si, forse che no. Mebbe yes, and mebbe no.

It depends on you, reader.

Posted by: Hugh at April 17, 2004 3:42 PM

Very nice post Hugh! I can assure you that muslims will never fool the Italians! Muslims can be crafty, but, trust me, Italians are toooo clever to be fooled by them!

Posted by: spartacus at April 17, 2004 4:33 PM

Fabrizio Quattrocchi is certainly a most courageous and honorable man. He and the other Coalition forces are the front line in this war to preserve civilization against the barbarians, and set for all of us a sterling example of the valor required to overcome this enemy. May his family and country find comfort and strength in his noble stand against the evil jihadists.

Posted by: ted at April 17, 2004 8:53 PM

The sicilian padrinos should invite a few muftis and imams for a chat,treat them well and then send video tapes to al jazeera,with the promise that more will follow...actually about 1000 italian muslims for every italian killed.

Posted by: adela at April 18, 2004 3:39 AM

Web Site Counter