By reminding the world of the nun’s murder, the Pope intentionally or unintentionally puts the focus back where it should be: not on those whose words hurt others, which includes all of us at one time or another, but on those who kill because they are hurt by the words of others. From the Telegraph via the New York Sun, with thanks to Ruth King:
ROME “” Pope Benedict condemned the killing of an Italian nun in Somalia, whose death has been blamed on a backlash by Muslims offended by his contentious speech last week.
Sister Leonella, born Rosa Sgorbati, 65, was shot in the back in Mogadishu last Sunday, a day after the Vatican issued a statement of regret for the worldwide uproar that followed the pope’s decision to quote a 14th-century emperor who called Islam “evil and inhuman.”
The pontiff said yesterday that Sister Leonella had been “barbarously killed” but expressed hope that her “spilled blood would become the seed of hope to build a real relationship between people.” In a telegram of condolence to the nun’s missionary order, Benedict XVI said he deplored “every form of violence” and that there should be more “respect for each other’s religious beliefs.”
Three people have now been arrested in Somalia for Sister Leonella’s murder, although one accomplice is still on the run. The head of security for the Islamic party currently running Mogadishu, Sheik Yusuf Mohamed Siad, said the motive for the killing is still unclear.
President Bush and Secretary of State Rice underlined their support for the pope yesterday, as Western leaders rallied to defuse the crisis.
President Bush said Benedict XVI had been “sincere” in his apology, while Ms. Rice said the pope had a “love for humanity.” She tried to portray the pope’s use of the quote during a speech at Regensberg University as a naïve slip. “We all need to understand that offense can sometimes be taken when perhaps we do not see it,” she said.
Of course he was sincere. He just wasn’t apologizing for anything but that he had been misunderstood, and that those who misunderstood him took their misunderstanding to violent extremes.
But in any case, it is unseemly for Bush and Rice to be hastening to assure the Islamic world that the Pope’s apology was sincere. In doing this they are both acting as if he did something that was actually wrong, which he did not, and that the Muslim response to his words was reasonable, which it wasn’t. Instead, they should both be saying that the Muslim response of violent protests and killings is outrageous and intolerable, and that the protestors should find something more important to be upset about. Or even better, they should concentrate on trying to live productive lives as decent human beings.