Zimmermann doesn’t mention the Catholic suicide bombers, the Catholic calls for holy war against Protestants and triumphant predictions of the imminent establishment of a Catholic state in America, the Catholic threats against unveiled women, the Catholic stoning of adulterers and execution of homosexuals, and the Catholic riots and murders of innocent people when someone said or did something that Catholics deemed Catholicophobic. Nor does she mention the Catholic campaigns to smear and destroy anyone who spoke out against those Catholic actions.
Yet if she had mentioned all those things, she would have a much stronger case that anti-Catholic sentiment and suspicion of Muslims today are equivalent.
“Anti-Muslim sentiment reminds some Catholics of own experience,” by Carol Zimmermann for Catholic News Service, April 8:
When Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill., led the first Senate Judiciary Committee hearing examining the civil rights of American Muslims March 29, he held aloft a small yellow prayer book no bigger than his hand.
The senator described the Catholic prayer book, written in Lithuanian and published in 1863, as a “family treasure” that his grandmother brought with her when she immigrated to the United States in 1911. The book, the only remaining item from that journey, was considered contraband in her homeland at the time because all prayer books were ordered to be written in Russian.
Durbin, assistant majority leader in the Senate, described his grandmother as “no constitutional scholar” but someone who knew that she would be able to use that prayer book freely in the United States.
“She knew America granted that freedom (of religion) and that’s what this hearing is all about,” said Durbin at the first hearing of the new Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights and Human Rights.
In opening remarks, Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., chairman of the Judiciary Committee, also shared anecdotal stories about family faith, but his observations were less upbeat as he recalled anti-Catholic bigotry that his Irish father and Italian grandparents experienced in the United States.
The senators’ comments reflect the range of experience of many religious groups in the United States. While some felt religious freedom for the first time when they came to America, others — simply because of their beliefs — have been threatened and discriminated.
The focus of the March 29 hearing was to closely examine a reported backlash of attacks against American Muslims since the 9/11 terrorist attacks. The hearing took place just weeks after Rep. Peter King, R-N.Y., chaired a House Homeland Security Committee hearing on Islamic radicalization and terrorism in America.
In the packed Senate hearing room during Durbin’s hearing, many speakers said the prejudice and discrimination faced by American Muslims today was no different from what other groups have experienced and should not be allowed to continue, just as it has stopped for the most part for other groups….