“Abbyasov said that the militants had taken elements of the Koran out of context.” We hear this endlessly; yet when have you ever heard a Muslim explain the proper context that renders the Qur’an’s violent verses benign? The most they say in the West is that these verses apply to long bygone days — a manifestly inadequate explanation, since it contradicts the express teachings of Muslim scholars beginning with Muhammad’s first biographer, Ibn Ishaq, who argue that the violent verses actually supersede and take precedence over the peaceful ones.
Abbyasov also “recalled that a group of over 120 Muslim scholars had released an open letter to IS militants and followers recently.” Indeed. It was a skillful piece, but ultimately deceptive, not dealing with the real justifications Islamic jihadists use to make recruits among peaceful Muslims — as I explained here and here.
So essentially Abbyasov is, like so many other Muslim spokesmen, demanding that non-Muslims not note the Islamic character of the Islamic State — which will make it all the harder to counter it. He is not saying anything that will actually make any Muslims who support the Islamic State change their minds.
“Don’t Refer To IS As ‘Islamic,’ Urges Russian Council Of Muftis,” by Joanna Paraszczuk, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, March 3, 2015:
The international community should not use the word “Islamic” when referring to the militant group Islamic State, according to the first deputy chairman of the Council of Muftis of Russia, Rushan Abbyasov.
Abbyasov said that leaders of the Council of Muftis of Russia had joined representatives of several Arab countries in calling for the use of the word “Islamic” to be dropped when referring to IS in the media and elsewhere in public discourse.
Abbyasov made his comments in a live interview with Russia’s Vesti FM radio station ahead of a meeting in Moscow with diplomatic representatives of Yemen, Iraq, Palestine, Kuwait, Algeria, Jordan, and Sudan, pro-Moscow Russian news site RIA Novosti reported on March 3.
“We have arrived at this idea, that today we can try to neutralize these groups ideologically. At the minimum, we should remove the prefix ‘Islamic’ [from Islamic State],” Abbyasov was quoted as saying.
The Russian Council of Muftis deputy chairman said that the media and others should refer to thIS “just as [the militants] are positioning themselves — as terrorists, bandits, and radicals, but we should try to remove the prefix [of “Islamic”] that they have given themselves and which they are trying to play with,” Abbyasov told Vesti FM.
Abbyasov said he believed that dropping the term “Islamic” from the name of the militant group would have a significant impact.
“If the international community would not call them ‘Islamic’ then believe me, they can be destroyed ideologically,” he said.
Abbyasov recalled that a group of over 120 Muslim scholars had released an open letter to IS militants and followers recently.
The letter declared that the militant group’s ideology was “completely contrary to the essence of Islam,” Abbyasov said.
The letter, released in September 2014, used Koranic sources to refute the militants’ ideology.
Abbyasov said that the militants had taken elements of the Koran out of context.
“You can pull out any [Koran] quote out of context. To deal with the Koran, you don’t only need knowledge of Arabic, but of the many sciences that make it possible to reveal the full meaning of the verses and all the meanings that are inherent in the Holy Koran,” he concluded.
Abbyasov’s comments come amid increasing concerns in Russia about the threat posed by IS to the country’s security. Russia is not only concerned that Russian nationals who fight in Syria could return and commit terrorist acts on Russian soil, but also that the group’s ideology could prove a pervasive source of radicalization for Russian Muslims or Muslim foreign laborers from Central Asian countries.
Recent attempts to combat the threats Russia believes are posed by IS include a December 2014 ruling by the Supreme Court that deemed IS a terrorist group. Russia’s Federal Security Service (FSB) included the IS group on a “unified list” of 22 terrorist groups published on its website last week.