How he proposed to distinguish between benign, chummy Islam and radical Islam, he didn’t say — but that is not the key point here. Lynch has clearly thrown down the gauntlet on the freedom of speech. There needs to be a national conversation on the freedom of speech and why it matters, as well as what we must do in the face of the jihad threat — and whether prosecuting speech critical of the motivating and guiding ideology of jihad terrorists is really a good idea.
“Pataki Demands That AG Lynch Arrest Him For Urging War Against Islam,” by Neil Munro, Breitbart, December 4, 2015:
Former Gov. George Pataki made a dramatic lunge for publicity in the GOP’s 2016 primary race with a Twitter-broadcast demand that he be arrested by Attorney General Loretta Lynch.
Lynch made it easy for Pataki — who has approximately zero percent of the GOP’s primary vote — by suggesting Thursday that she would arrest people who criticize the ideology of orthodox Islam. “When we talk about the First amendment we [must] make it clear that actions predicated on violent talk are not American. They are not who we are, they are not what we do, and they will be prosecuted,” she said at the Thursday fund-raiser for a radical Muslim advocacy group.
Lynch will have a long, long list of Americans to arrest, because traditional Islam promotes many ideas that are very unpopular among Americans. For example, orthodox Islam urges the murder of people who cause “mischief,” targeted enemies, people who give up Islam, gays, non-Muslims, women who annoyed Mohammad, etc., etc., etc.
However, her phrase — “actions predicated on violent talk” — is vague, and may refer to actions, not statements….

somehistory says
This makes two…wonder how many others will dare her to arrest them? If there are enough, perhaps the tide can turn against the beast sooner rather than later.
Don McKellar says
I’m Spartacus!
Dr. Divinity says
Just another of bouncers flunkeys….just another mouth for him. She has to have a lot of loose nuts not to realize what islam is….Great gobs of goose s grease…can’t she read..for herself……. Surely I don’t need to send her a CD of the koran..The koran tells it all….If,say the Baptist or Methodist or any staple religion…(I’M NOT CLASSIFING ISLAM AS A RELIGION…IT IS A CULT) should teach or preach and act out what is in the Koran, then those religions would be destroyed..Wake up Me Lunch before you are swallowed up in the murky waters of Islam.
john spielman says
The fascist pig Lynch should try and arrest me ALSO! – because muhammed pbuh* was nothing but a demon possessed mass murderer thief liar misogynist and pedophile pervert! and islam is a doctrine of Satan/ (allah to muslims!)
pbuh*-PERPETUAL BANISHMENT UNTO HELL!
adobong_baboy_oinkoink says
you a funny man, john_spielman. you cuss mohammed, and yet wish “peace be upon him”…unless you don’t know what “pbuh” means. you serious ? joking ? or………….doing…………taqqiya.
john spielman says
I guess you didn’t bother to read my pbuh* explanation at the end, it says pbuh means PERPETUAL BANISHMENT UNTO HELL- not peace be upon him
ps I did not “CUSS’ him but merely describes muhammed according to his own haiths ( teaching of muhammed) which describes every one of these attributes to him
jihad3tracker says
The President’s ventriloquist dummy Loretta Lynch is speaking words that our Traitor-In-Chief Hussein O would say if he were not a coward.
Indonesian native / 3rd-World mindset / Western values hater / minority grievance pro : Barry Soetoro’s obvious wish is to hand us over to his faith-brother Muslims.
Obama is self-shredding so fast that I (who vividly remembers Richard Nixon’s Watergate meltdown in 1974) would not be surprised at any insane things he does.
The brilliant & courageous counter-jihadist Pam Geller gave us a chapter by chapter forecast of this several years ago in her book “The Post-American Presidency”.
jihad3tracker says
IF YOU CAN FIND AN EMAIL PATH TO GEORGE PATAKI — NOT TWITTER PLEASE — SEND HIM A NOTE OF THANKS.
We need every one who is brave enough to stand against Obama’s increasingly apparent supremacist / fascist agenda while he still remains in office.
Diane Harvey says
Not that I have any sympathy, but Lynch has put herself into a box.
Now it’s to her – Put up or shut up.
Will she attempt these dare-me prosecutions?
andtoto2? says
Get a clue! Force these smarmy creatures on the NYT editorial Board to defend themselves PERSONALLY. Expose every single one of their names.to the general public.
BlueRaven says
Ms. Lynch – you are a moron for publicly defending an ideology which is bent to harming American people and our Constitutal rights.
john spielman says
Lynch should be impeached and removed from office for agreeing to violate our Bill of Rights!
BlueRaven says
Correction – “bent on harming”
E Ward says
I listened very carefully to Lynches words at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qBkPcRSi03o, and at this particular point (1:01) threatens prosecution for RHETORIC. Not violent rhetoric, just rhetoric. She sandwiched this fine point between condemnations of rhetoric advocating violence, but very clearly threatens “rhetoric” with prosecution. Slick, but it won’t fly here in America.
mortimer says
An attack on free speech by the attorney general is unacceptable. Lynch should be forced by outraged public opinion to resign.
Everybody…write about it…email to your reps about it…write to the newspaper about…SAVE FREE SPEECH. FIRE LYNCH.
Creole Gumbo says
It is really the job of Congress to get rid of Lynch.
Jeremiah says
Radical Islam is another layer of the Politically correct onion. There is no Moderate version of Islam. There is no Radical Islam. There is only Islam. We are at war with the Islam of the Koran. We must eradicate the teachings of Islam.
PRCS says
To plagiarize Wellington,
We didn’t fight “radical Nazis” during WWII, and the post WWII cold war did not pit us against “radical communism”.
Whomever first used the idiotic phrase “radical Islam” has left a legacy of uninformed citizens that has proven extremely difficult to eradicate.
Budvarakbar says
Ban and burn the Koran
john spielman says
burning the koran contributes to air pollution . I say shred korans and use them for bedding for swine
mortimer says
How can an attorney general of the United States and how can a president not understand the First Amendment? Did they study the Constitution at law school?
Did Obama even attend law school? His ‘classmates’ (if they were) did not SEE HIM in class. Can Obama provide a single person who saw him in law school?
Islam’s war against the world (called jihad) was declared by MOHAMMED in the name of Allah.
(If someone today said, ‘God told me to declare war on the world’, he would be considered insane.)
The jihad doctrine of Islam is the doctrine of someone who was truly insane!
Budvarakbar says
“Did Obama even attend law school? His ‘classmates’ (if they were) did not SEE HIM in class. Can Obama provide a single person who saw him in law school?”
The word was that he was at Patrice Lumumba U. in Moscow, RUSSIA during the time that he claims Columbia — kinda fits in with the way he stopped the missile shield for Poland the minute the SOB got in office – and fumble prick way this admin has handled all of the International items — handling Crimea, Ukrane, Iraq, over to Russia and Iran —
Before this dam SOB bastard goes any further – we need to see ALL the records — and we need to stomp the daylights out of all the stupid shitheads that put this bastard in the WH — I am not talking about the pathetic stupid voters — instead the bastards behind and IN the demo-COMMUNIST party and their dam RINO a$$kissers
Budvarakbar says
“(If someone today said, ‘God told me to declare war on the world’, he would be considered insane.)”
Kinda sounds like Hitler – eh?
Michael Copeland says
Insane?
What does Koran 68:51 say about Mohammed?
“Indeed, he is mad.”
“Surely he is possessed!”
“He is certainly insane”.
“Verily, he is a madman!”
http://corpus.quran.com/translation.jsp?chapter=68&verse=51
Kevin Nicholson says
Yup!
mortimer says
Lynch will have to arrest everyone who reads from the Koran and hadiths in public! She will have to arrest those who read the fatwas about jihad or sell books advocating jihad!
She will have to arrest Muslims that approve of jihad…theoretically ALL MUSLIMS APPROVE OF JIHAD, a supremacist, military campaign of political overthrow…such as overthrowing the Constitution of the United States to impose SHARIA LAW in its place.
The original source documents of Islam are more violent than the sacred text of nine other world religions:
Danish researcher Tina Magaard, Ph.D. concluded that Islam is the most warlike religion. After three years analyzing the original texts of ten different religions, Tina Magaard concluded that the Islamic texts stand out by encouraging terror and violence to a larger degree than other religions do. She stated that ‘Islamic texts encourage terror and fighting to a far larger degree than the original texts of other religions. The texts in Islam distinguish themselves from the texts of other religions by encouraging violence and aggression against people with other religious beliefs to a larger degree.’
Loretta, Islam is the most violent religion by far. You lost this one already. We want to make our day and argue in court that Islam isn’t violent!
MAKE OUR DAY!
Edward Cline says
I sent to both Muslim Advocates — whose anniversary dinner Lynch addressed — and to Lynch c/o the DOJ a link to one of my latest columns, “The Ugly American Muslim,” http://ruleofreason.blogspot.com/2015/12/the-ugly-american-muslim.html No response yet. Very likely the DOJ is being swamped with dares and defiance.
BlueHawK says
Truly excellent blog post, thank you!
Kevin Nicholson says
Very good and reasonable blog. Common sense is alive and well! The enemy is within the gates and now we must fight them (political Islam) and cast them out!
logdon says
‘They are not who we are, they are not what we do’
Right down to her master’s voice.
When the suggestion that Syrian Christian refugees be given priority Obama leapt to his mic of outrage, thundering to Americans, ‘it’s not what America is’.
So by subverting the US openness to immigration and religion, he clearly would rather have Muslims pouring in.
The very thought that he represents America sends shudders down my spine.
He in fact, represents anything but
duh_swami says
Sharia Court of the Islamic Republic of America…What’s wrong with that?
Ren says
Loretta Lynch, you stupid blind woman who does not see an evil ideology when there is one… and it is called “islam”.
john spielman says
that is because lynch is evil herself
Buraq says
Lynch Lynch, now!
Jim Peters says
What worries me the most is why POTUS, these politicians, DOJers, etc. are so brazen in their pronouncements? They make it sound like there is not going to be an election in 2016 in which the people will throw them out and hopefully overturn their bad decisions. They seem to talk with impunity. This is very troubling.
Carolyne says
Loretta Lynch took the Oath of Office to “Defend the Constitution against all enemies, both foreign and domestic. That includes defending the First Amendment. Her “Worst fear” is backlash against Muslims? Shouldn’t her worst fear be attack on the US by Muslims? Shouldn’t she fear beheaded American soldiers lying in the streets of New York as happened to Lee Rigby in London?
Here’s a newsflash for Loretta Lynch. I will say whatever I wish, whenever I wish, about any subject I wish, including Muslims and Islam, wherever I wish, in accordance with my Constitutional rights under the First Amendment whose only restriction is to not advocate the overthrow of the US Government by force, which Muslims do every day of the week and are never prosecuted for it.
For starters, Mohammed was a pedophile, slave-holding assassin, warlord, thief and plunderer and may
pigshitr be upon him.
Kevin Nicholson says
Amen…
Michael Harris says
I had hope that based on her reputation General Lynch would not prostitute herself the Obama mission to favor Islam. Sadly I am wrong. We Ned to increase our surveillance of the radical mosques and send the preachers of hate back to where they came from if they are not U.S. citizens. So General please go ahead and arrest me too. My wife and granddaughters will never wear a burka.
Angemon says
Lynch strikes me as the kind of person who, if she had lived in the correct time frame, would have lynched anyone proposing armed resistance against the British.
Dag says
Yes, it’s easy for me to challenge someone in New York to arrest me, but here goes anyway.
Below are links to two of my books. If the first doesn’t strike most people as hate speech, then I failed in a big way. The second link is a smart and funny illustrated bio. of Mohammed. Some people will find that hateful too if they have any understanding of Western culture.
http://www.amazon.com/Motoons-D-W-Walker/dp/0987761579
http://www.amazon.com/Snootom-D-W-Walker/dp/0987761587/ref=sr_1_cc_1?s=aps&ie=UTF8&qid=1449430770&sr=1-1-catcorr&keywords=snootom
Harry III says
American citizens should call for her resignation immediately!!!
Georg says
Sorry to be so boorish, but…
LOL!!
SierraFaith says
Let’s be plain: Loretta Lynch is an ass.
Her hatred of our First Amendment only deepens my loathing of her, and others of her ilk — including President Obama, present and past Secretaries of States Kerry and Clinton, et al.
To these people, Freedom is a legacy that was not paid for by the blood of thousands.
But a nuisance that must be curtailed at once.
I will crawl over broken glass to elect a Constitutionalist as President — Senator Ted Cruz. . . .