Young children should learn about 9/11. Suriyah Bi’s agenda is obvious. And she is suing for race discrimination? What race is the jihad mass murder of innocent civilians again? I keep forgetting.
“Muslim teacher is suing a school for ‘race discrimination’ after she was sacked for objecting to a video of 9/11 being shown to 11-year-olds,” by Alex Matthews, Mailonline, September 25, 2016:
A Muslim teacher is taking legal action against a school over claims she was sacked for objecting to children being shown a video of the 9/11 terror attacks.
Suriyah Bi, 24, lost her job at Heartlands Academy in Birmingham, after just a week of being a teaching assistant in a year seven class there.
She claims that she was shown the door after she complained it was not appropriate for the 11 and 12-year-olds in her class to watch the ‘X-rated’ clip – that showed the horrors of the attacks on World Trade Center in New York, in September 2001.
Ms Bi, an Oxford University Graduate, from Yardley in Birmingham, is now pursuing claims against the school for unfair dismissal and religious discrimination.
The video was not mentioned in detail during the brief preliminary hearing which dealt with technical and legal matters.
But outside the hearing, Ms Bi said: ‘It was shown to some 30 children during class. I understand the video was shown without the permission of the authorities.
‘It raised questions about what safeguards there are in schools to protect children.
‘These were children aged 11, of whom many knew little, or nothing, about the 9/11 horror.
‘They were subjected to graphic scenes and some were shocked and upset. The video not only showed the plane crashing into the Twin Towers but also showed people committing suicide by jumping to their deaths from the tower blocks.
‘Such young children should not been shown things like that because it is well-known that it can play on their minds and even induce them to kill themselves.
‘I was in the classroom when the video was shown and I quickly objected. Later, I was told to leave the school.
‘There was an investigation into the matter but I was dismissed for making a whistle blowing complaint.’
Ms Bi said she believed no action was taken against the teacher who screened the video, but some people regarded the showing as ‘misguided’….

Jackson03 says
She may have a point. Though I don’t know the context surrounding the introduction and display of the 9/11 scenes I would question some parts for children that show people jumping out of the windows.
On the other hand her facial expression is hateful: It reeks of “I’m gonna get ya ya dirty Kafer”.
Caliph says
I bet many of these kids have a Playststion or XBox and play video games. How many parents allow kids to play 1st person shooter games? Or watch R rated movies once in a while? I’m guessing most of them do. So any footage of 911 attack would be quite mild compared to some video games – and, the kids would be equally dissociated from video games, movies and 911 footage.
Little miss jihad’s claim is nothing more than anger that these kids will have learned something of Islamic jihad and will no longer be easy targets for da’wah.
Spartakus says
Big difference: video *games* vs the reality of 9/11.
Agreed that her motives may be different, but I still think seeing people jumping from the buildings would be too harsh for such young children.
And many parents don’t allow violent games and movies, because they want to protect their children a bit longer.
gravenimage says
Children younger than this were *victims* on 9/11. The idea that children should know nothing about this is, I believe, misguided.
Jay Boo says
People jumping to their deaths to escape the flames was shown on the evening news.
We ought to show a film clip with Muslims celebrating on the rooftops of New Jersey after watching the news of the attack as well.
Robert Crawford says
And Palestinians handing out candy in the streets, ululating their heads off.
linnte says
Agreed Graven! Keeping our children in the dark about 9/11 is a lie. Why would we want to lie to our children, who later will say “why didn’t you TELL me about this? Why wasn’t it discussed?”. How many movies have people dying in them? Those are the lies! Kids need reality, not pretend, and if it makes them upset, fearful, angry even distraught it it is ridiculous to assume it will damage their poor little psyches forever. MILLIONS of American children witnessed the 9/11 attacks. It was on National TV for weeks. I hope the courts consider this fact.
gravenimage says
Linnte, I don’t think fiction is a bad thing for children at all–things like the Harry Potter books are very good, and take a moral stance.
But children also need to learn about history–especially recent history. 9/11 is still effecting all our lives.
linnte says
I agree that children need fiction. Harry Potter, Tolkien, everything! I am a HUGE fan of fiction Fantasy like The Shanara Series. Kids need Santa and other imaginary things. But yes, they do need reality, and it is a discredit to kids to underestimate how much reality they can handle.
gravenimage says
Absolutely, Linnte.
Stephanie says
… islamophobe™, nazi™, bigot™, right-winger™, hatemonger™ & racist™
‘pure’ vs. ‘IMpure’ 8:37, 55 http://www.usc.edu/org/cmje/religious-texts/quran/verses/008-qmt.php#008.037
J-pal says
Her argumentation sounds correct, indeed…but how come the “racist”? No matter how “correct” she sounds, here is a fad taste in it all… She is using this platform to win more “friends” to her cause, which is private, and not public…why let her do that? And, she is “so caring” for the kids…at the same time she represents and will induce, indoctrinate, these kids by the lure of her face (not race!) into the “great religion” who cause 9/11… come on… Stop using “racist” / and make up for your atrocities against the Yazidis, sex slave women, punishment on small kids, mutilation, stoning….etc.
WHY says
anything she disagrees with is racist. These shit-stains are such victims as they kill and rape
Angemon says
Race is, after all, on the top of the progressive stack:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCP-pH3JtWA
Remember when ISIS told its members not to attack black Americans to avoid charges of “hate crimes”?
Lion of Judah's Cub says
Another case of “lawfare”. Lawsuits are common when muslims are a small but growing minority as a means of imposing creeping sharia law.
gravenimage says
Exactly.
mgoldberg says
actually had they shown the repeated dancing in the streets around the muslim world, and in areas of the west where muslims live and the dancing and happiness at the destruction… then the kids would be confused as hell, and traumatized.
It would show that those folks are acting against the human race, such as it is.
Lion of Judah's Cub says
Where are the crocodile tears for the children 9 or younger forced to marry old men according to the teachings of the koran and the example of their prophet. Or for the children mutilated by FGM?
WHY says
or the 5 year olds these goats raped in Idaho and the local govt called it all lies?
Tracey says
Great point! I wonder if this woman was as concerned with the grooming scandal in Rotherham? Some of the girls involved were around this age.
gravenimage says
Good questions, Lion of Judah’s Cub, WHY, and Tracey.
abad says
Race discrimination?
Last time I checked, the surname Bi is Chinese.
And she looks like she has some Chinese heritage, too.
I realize China does not have a very high opinion of Islam within its borders – perhaps Bi should consider moving to Syria instead.
Baucent says
My guess is she is Indonesian or Malaysian.
gravenimage says
Sounds like an educated guess, Baucent.
Martin says
Birmingham, like the Heartlands Academy Ms Bi worked for, is stuffed full of Muslims. Anyone taking a casual glance at the academy’s website might think it’s a Muslim school: http://www.heartlands-academy.org.uk/
The Mail’s article, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3806551/Muslim-teacher-suing-school-race-discrimination-sacked-objecting-video-9-11-shown-11-year-olds.html, also contains this: “E-Act, who run the academy, told the tribunal judge Ron Broughton that the teacher no longer wanted to work for them.”
Apparently, the video was shown to a class who “…had been studying a poem called Out of the Blue, by Simon Armitage, about a victim of the 9/11 terrorist attack. The poem is part of the AQA GCSE syllabus.” Therefore, there appears to have been a good reason to show it.
gravenimage says
Thanks for the background, Martin.
Here is the poem in question:
http://www.scottishpoetrylibrary.org.uk/poetry/poems/out-blue-12
The poem itself is fairly mediocre.
But while it is about a deeply troubling subject–those who had to jump from the towers–it is not graphic, nor is there any indication of who flew into the towers or why.
I wonder how the Mohammedans in this school reacted to this terrible Infidel suffering?
There have been times when Muslim children *cheer* Jihad terror:
“Muslim Children in Belgian School Applaud and Cheered Brussels Attacks”
https://themuslimissue.wordpress.com/2016/03/23/muslim-children-in-belgium-school-applaud-and-cheered-brussels-attacks/
Buford says
The Hog needs to go back to the Middle East Probably one of her stinking relatives had something to do with 9/11 I am so sick of these Malcontents coming here with no intention of assimilation only to invade & create chaos go home you Barbarian nitwits.
bobm says
WE need a massive class action lawsuit..on the matter of threatening death in quran…if I threaten death …I am charged before the law… ISLAM is a massive death threat .. it cannot deny its culpability..make islam ILLEGAL..
Paul Clark says
Good the demon needs to be gone. Wait, what liberal judge appointed by Obama and Billy ” I never had sex with that woman” Clinton will award a massive settlement. The odds are good. In NC the democrat leader have taken the political party affiliation off some of the judges because too may conservatives judges were being elected. Even the democrats were voting for conservative judges. Tell you something? The Republican are in power, but they have not changed this? This is why I ask: Where have all the Christians gone? Have they fled in the cross. They have set in their pews and remained mute. They should demand repeal or reinstatement of the party designations on ballots. You know the liberal judges will take as much as your religion freedom that they can get away with. Pick up your crosses and demand from your legislators the reinstatement.
gravenimage says
Obama and Bill Clinton have no power to award legal settlements in the United Kingdom.
Guest says
Age 11 is an appropriate age to learn the evils of the world.
gravenimage says
Very true, Guest.
gravenimage says
UK: Muslim teacher sues school for racism after being fired for objecting to 9/11 video
……………………………
What “race” compels the whitewash of Jihad savagery, and bars any objection to it? sarc/off
More:
She claims that she was shown the door after she complained it was not appropriate for the 11 and 12-year-olds in her class to watch the ‘X-rated’ clip – that showed the horrors of the attacks on World Trade Center in New York, in September 2001.
It raised questions about what safeguards there are in schools to protect children…
‘These were children aged 11, of whom many knew little, or nothing, about the 9/11 horror.
‘They were subjected to graphic scenes and some were shocked and upset. The video not only showed the plane crashing into the Twin Towers but also showed people committing suicide by jumping to their deaths from the tower blocks.
‘Such young children should not been shown things like that because it is well-known that it can play on their minds and even induce them to kill themselves…
……………………………
What *absolute crap*. Notice that this Muslimah stated *no* objection to the perpetration of 9/11 itself–in which eight children were murdered along with almost 3000 other innocent people–but just to anyone learning that it happened.
That eleven-year old children *didn’t* know about it is, in fact, appalling. This would be like children in 1957 never having heard of Pearl Harbor. Actually, it is far worse, since the Axis was no longer a threat then–would that we could say that about Jihad now.
All of these children are still under direct threat from the ideology that caused 9/11–the same ideology that this teacher follows.
Here was a recent terror threat in the Birmingham area:
“UK: Five Muslims arrested on terror charges, bomb disposal team called in”
https://www.jihadwatch.org/2016/08/uk-five-muslims-arrested-on-terror-charges-bomb-disposal-team-called-in
And here is a Muslim rapist in Birmingham:
“Convicted Muslim rapist ‘did not understand what is acceptable in UK’”
https://www.jihadwatch.org/2016/07/uk-convicted-muslim-rapist-did-not-understand-what-is-acceptable-in-uk
There are many other such stories.
jayell says
Why did she lose her job as a T.A. after only one week? This sort of thing is almost unheard of! She must have done more than a couple of things wrong for that to happen, but of course Muslims are never wrong, are they? Plus the sense of entitlement she might have with an Oxford degree (assuming she went to one of the main colleges there). No, this sounds like pure opportunistic spite, as we have a often seen from the likes of the Islamic Ms. Bi. And the sheer hypcritical nerve of this sort of objection to THIS particular subject matter coming from a MUSLIM will not be lost on the court, bearing in mind the underlying reason for the case being brought – which was nothing to do with the sensibilities of the children but everything to do with the frustrated arrogance of Ms. BI
Jay Boo says
Look at me.
“I am so much better than you because I were a fancy headscarf.”
Muslim women never wash their lice infested hair.
JIMJFOX says
‘Muslim women never wash their lice infested hair’
Evidence, please? Getting carries away, making ridiculous statements destroys your credibility.
Come on, you CAN’T really believe that??
brane pilot says
If you do not hire them, they sue you for discrimination and you are screwed.
If you do hire them, they dictate their cultural and political terms, and sue you for any deviance.
Either way, under the Law you are screwed.
The Law is wrong and needs to be scrapped..
Once humanistic Law has been weaponized by those who would use it to destroy you, the Law has outlived its term.
It is back to kicking ass to the curb. The only question is will it be yours, or theirs.
The awful truth says
Nadia Hussein winner of British Bake Off halalled five species of animal by the time she was five: ducks, chickens, goats, sheep and cattle (or a similar combination). If it’s OK for Muslim children to wallow in blood by the age of five I don’t know how this Muslima can complain.
Richard says
Best take a look at those traumatised for a lifetime in the madrassa; the world has seen what that experience can do to the sympathies of a partially formed mind, as some would say …
Louise M. says
Islamic women headgears are getting bigger and bigger…..
Are there reports on Muslim’s heads growing bigger ???
This Islam poster girl, with a twinkle of righteous pride in her eye, looks just like a peackock making the wheel !
JIMJFOX says
‘like a peackock [sic] making the wheel’
No idea what this means- another odd Americanism?
‘Jumping the shark’, etc?
Louise M. says
Thank you for briging my distraction mistake to my attention.
May I illustrate for you the expression ”peacock making the wheel” ?
gravenimage says
I think Louise means that large, showy Hijabs are intended to attract attention, saying “I am extra-Islamic”.
Louise M. says
Thanks for your help, Gravenimage ! Yes, I tought of the expression ”proud as a peacock” in the sense of vanity.
After having watched (on TV) a few Muslimas wearing surprisingly expanded hijabs, I felt that these types of garbs had accentuated their owner’s inclination to talk down to the rest of us !
As we could say in French: elles ont la grosse tête !
gravenimage says
Thanks, Louise.
Ali Bey says
Eleven years old students are not in Primary School and they should not be left ignorant of the world they live on nor of its story specially what concerning their parents generation.
Charli Main says
Another Muslim Trojan Horse that’s infiltrated the British educational system.
Primary objective of these people is to imprint Islamic values on impressionable young minds.
Consequently, the viewing of a Muslim atrocity, inflicted on thousands of innocent people must be prevented, at all costs.
God, I hate Muslims.
Keith Jordan says
How and when did Islam become a “race”? Do people really believe that Saudis, Iranians, and Indonesians are all the same race? I have read that there are Caucasians who are Muslim. Are they the same race as the Easterners? People need to learn what a race is before they accuse others of “racism”.
Florida Jim says
Simply ask Obama, Jarrett, Brennan, Kerry, Comey, Lynch, Holder, and all who roam the government halls late at night to conduct a seminar to be shown on MSNBC and ABC, the Clinton Networks.
thomas says
The newspaper story fails to explain the facts.
Exactly how did this woman make the protest?
Did she make a scene in the students presence?
Was she insubordinate? (This is the easiest way to get fired.)
Merely expressing her views privately with management should not have gotten her fired.
duh swani says
Allah is a racist who clearly favors Arab Muslims…They are the best of people which means the rest are not…Allah should be sued for racism with the Quran as evidence…But do0n’t expect a monetary award, Allah never pays off…
Mark Brunner says
I’m certain it had nothing to do with the content, there are worse images on TV on a daily basis. More that it was to do with her beliefs. Childrem should be shown this and never forget in the same way we remember the dead f the first and second world wars.
This teacher should go and teach in Alepo as her ideology seems more fitting there.
JIMJFOX says
Could not find any reference to “religious discrimination”.
Even Oxford, the World’s top university now gives out degrees in every box of corn flakes??
Teacher’s Assistant must be a most valued position…
Dazed & Confused says
When you locate this creature on Twitter…..https://twitter.com/suriyahbi
You then quickly realise that she has a blog…..And guess what she’s whining about….You guessed it “Islamophobia and racism”…
https://voicesofadiaspora.wordpress.com/2015/07/19/catherine-tate-hijabs-and-aubergine-muffins/#comments
Slavonian says
The judge who handles this case should agree with her that it’s inappropriate to expose kids to this level of violence and act accordingly: ban this clip, and also ban kids from access to the Koran, which is so full of unimaginably vicious threats by an alleged all-powerful god that any kid who is exposed to it must in all likelihood become traumatized. Koran’s viciousness in relegating most humanity to eternal tortures in Hell far outdoes any violence ever perpetrated in this world. Ban all youth under eighteen access to mosques, and make criminally liable any adults who facilitates exposure of the young to Islam. Proscribe Muslim parents from teaching their kids about Islam. Make mosques pay a special tax which will provide meaningful compensation to families whose members became victims of Muslim terror, or face closure.
Gbox says
A teacher too ignorant to know the difference between religion and race.
gravenimage says
I doubt she is ignorant–accusing those who oppose Jihad of “racism” has proven to be very effective with a lot of ninnies.
Carmel says
I do not believe one moment to the narrative of this women. She is the front for someone else ( Soros ? US-Arab friendship committee?) to weakened our system . How many young teachers do you know that after loosing their job have the money to sue a school board ?
It is like the burkini in Nice and many , many ,many other cases.Islamist undermining .
They do so since Muhammad .
Transmaster says
What this Burka Bitch is objecting to is teaching Muslim Children about the facts of 9/11. Look at this school’s home page. These Muslim children, especially the girls are getting an education that is impossible where they came from.
http://www.heartlands-academy.org.uk/
DAI says
My opinion is that showing the events of 9- 11- 01 to 11 yr olds is a bit much. The Paki teacher was looking for a large payment for discrimination thats real only in her mind She was waiting for an opportunity..We dont need teachers like her teaching our kids.
S Brown says
As a teacher of 25 years, I would hesitate showing that video to 11-12 year old students. They ARE too young. Fifteen to 18 year olds, yes but not these ones. Whether Ms Bi had another agenda is moot as her stated point if view us enough. But I’m sure there’s more to this story that led to her sacking.
linnte says
All due respect, I was wondering if you have noticed any psychological mal functions in the children who DID watch the original 9/11 attacks? Is there data to show they were harmed or grew up traumatized?
gravenimage says
Linnte, here are the results of an ABC News poll taken just a year after 9/11, which deals with American children as young as twelve, who were eleven on 9/11. And these are not just kids who heard about 9/11 in a controlled classroom setting, but who *can remember it happening*:
“Just two emotions measured in this poll haven’t subsided, both almost universally held: Ninety-two percent of teenagers say they’re angry with the perpetrators of the Sept. 11 attacks. And 88 percent say they’re confident in the United States’ response.”
http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=90400&page=1
S Brown says
Here are some studies….
.https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/here-there-and-everywhere/201109/the-case-against-watching-911-tv-coverage
https://consumer.healthday.com/kids-health-information-23/kids-ailments-health-news-434/helping-kids-cope-with-9-11-all-over-again-508137.html
http://www.oneindia.com/2008/02/05/911-had-increased-impact-on-traumatised-children-1202225538.html
So I’m not sure you can assert that watching graphic 9/11 videos will not have any traumatic effect on young teens.
gravenimage says
With all respect, S Brown, the idea that no one younger than fifteen should learn that disturbing things have happened in history is just ridiculous. It is impossible for children to develop a real moral sense if they don’t understand that some people do bad things.
This is especially egregious in this case, because these kids are *themselves* at risk from violent Jihad. Do you believe that Jihadists don’t target children?
“Toulouse Jihad Murderer Videotaped Himself Pulling 8-Year-Old Girl By Her Hair & Holding Her Hair To Shoot Her In The Head”
http://beforeitsnews.com/alternative/2012/03/1935513-1935513.html
Then there was the horror of Beslan. And children themselves were murdered on 9/11.
The idea that no one should watch a video about 9/11 until they are half way through high school might explain in part why so many people are completely ignorant of the Jihad threat.
S Brown says
You misread my post. We’re talking about the showing of a particular video not the discussion of 9/11. Discussing 9/11 is important at any age especially if students are questioning the jihad that continues to thus day. But showing a video of the people jumping out the windows may not yet be appropriate at that age. There is no need to show that particular video to discuss the events and consequences of what happened that day. And yes child development DOES play a factor in what you discuss and when whether we
like it ir not.
gravenimage says
S Brown, we are not talking about preschool children who would be unable to process this and would just be frightened. Eleven year olds are more mature than this. I think you underestimate the capacity of older children to understand things.
Did you read the ABC poll of children as young as twelve and their reaction a year after 9/11?
S Brown says
11 and 12 year olds cannot be traumatized by horrifying things? You raised tough kids. You feed them nails? The videos I’ve seem of the victims falling to their deaths have horrified me and many adults I’ve known. There is no compelling need to show THIS video in order to discuss 9/11 with this age group, none.
Yes I read your poll. A significant number in teens to twenty percent claim high anxiety due to 9/11. These are collateral damage then and well worth the attempt to show highly graphic images to very young teens? When a plethora other ways are available to discuss the events and issues? Do you really believe this?
linnte says
BOOM!