A Palestinian who was imprisoned for murdering four Israelis in four separate attacks has died of cancer. According to the PA, Abu Wa’er was himself “murdered” by the Israelis who neglected to provide him with medical care for the throat cancer that killed him. The story – that is, its Palestinian version, is here: “Palestinians Blame Israel for ‘Premeditated’ Murder of Terrorist (and Child Killer) Who Died of Throat Cancer,” Elder of Ziyon, Algemeiner, November 12, 2020:
Cancer-stricken Palestinian detainee, Kamal Abu Wa’er, 46, died today in Israeli occupation jails following a severe deterioration in his health due to medical negligence….
Qadri Abu Bakr, head of the Prisoners and Ex-Prisoners Commission in the Palestinian Authority, held the Israeli authorities fully responsible for the death of Abu Wa’er, slamming his death as a premeditated crime committed by the Israeli prison service, which was fully aware of the seriousness of his health condition and refused to release him despite many calls made for his immediate release.
There was no “medical negligence.” Nor was Abu Wa’er’s death a “premeditated crime.” Abu Waer was receiving the best possible care from the Israelis: two complicated surgeries, and six months of chemotherapy and other, ameliorative, treatment for his laryngeal cancer. Had he been released, he would then have received the substandard care the Palestinians provide, instead of the superior care provided by Israeli doctors. It was that difference in care that recently caused the late PLO propagandist and “peace” negotiator Saeb Erekat to insist on being treated for COVID-19 at Hadassah Hospital, rather than at any of the Palestinian medical facilities available to him. Instead of a “premeditated crime” against Abu Wa’er by the Israelis who supposedly allowed him to die without treatment, Israeli doctors did everything they could to save him. But those surgeries, those six months of chemothereapy, are carefully left out of the PLO’s narrative.
The PLO also blamed Israel for “medical negligence.” Hanan Ashrawi said Israel was “directly responsible” for Waer’s death. This “negligence” included multiple surgeries and months of cancer treatments.
Here are the facts of that so-called “medical negligence”: Abu Wa’er was transferred from prison to Assaf Harofeh Medical Center near Tel Aviv and had surgery on his larynx to insert a tube to his stomach to deliver liquid food. That was in addition to another tube that two months previously had been surgically inserted into his neck to help him breathe. He was then given six months of cancer treatment sessions, before finally dying of the cancer. In other words, the PLO’s charge of “medical negligence” was absurd, and Hanan Ashrawi’s claim that Israel was “directly responsible” for Wa’er’s death was – as so many of her remarks are – simply obscene. Nothing was withheld from him; there was no “medical negligence”; he was given the same first-rate medical attention that would be given to any Israeli. And the Palestinians know it. That’s why the leader of Hamas, Ismail Haniyeh, brought his daughter to Ichilov Hospital to be treated for complications that arose from her treatment in a Gazan hospital. And that’s why Erekat insisted that he be treated for COVID-19 in Hadassah Hospital instead of a Palestinian one.
Besides that obvious lie, the Palestinian media also lies about why he was serving six life terms. According to the PLO and Arabic Wikipedia, he was arrested in 2003 for “resisting the occupation” and “repelling Israeli invasions.” Wattan says he stabbed a soldier while defending a young girl from harassment, doubting that the soldier even died.
In reality, Abu Wa’er was a cold-blooded child killer for Fatah’s Force 17 involved in a number of murders, including:
The drive by shooting of Aliza Malka, 17, near Kibbutz Merav.
The shooting and murder of Arnaldo Agranionic, 48, a guard from Itamar.
The murder of Rabbi Binyamin Herling, 64, at Mount Ebal in 2000; and
The murder of Israeli Druze border policeman Madhat Yousef as he guarded Joseph’s Tomb.
These murders are what the PLO today extols as “resisting the occupation.”…
Here is how Israel should respond to these latest Palestinian calumnies about the treatment, and death, of Abu Wa’er:
The prisoner Abu Wa’er was not the victim of “medical negligence,” as various Palestinians, including Hanan Ashrawi, have claimed. On the contrary: he was given the best possible care after having been diagnosed with throat cancer. He was transferred from prison to Assaf Harofeh Medical Center near Tel Aviv, where he had a tube surgically inserted into his neck to help him breathe. Two months later, he underwent another surgery, this time on his larynx to insert a tube to his stomach to deliver liquid food. Both surgeries were complicated, and both were successful. The patient could again breathe, and take in a liquid diet. These were therapies, not cures, for his laryngeal cancer. He was then given six full months of chemotherapy treatment. We are saddened that all our efforts to fight his cancer and ease his pain are now being described by some Palestinians as “medical negligence” and, even worse, as “premeditated murder,” when our medical staff of doctors and nurses, that included both Jews and Arabs, did everything we could to treat the cancer that, in the end, did not relent.
mortimer says
Next time, the Israeli jailers should insist that Pally prisoners be medically treated in the Pally medical system, thus assuring that Israel’s doctors will not be accused of improper health care.
Brenrod says
Good riddance to bad rubbish, Israelis are nuts for not executing these terrorists immediately after they are caught and debriefed.
Boycott Turkey says
I recently know somebody who died of throat cancer it’s a very aggressive cancer little chance of survival and he had the same treatment as this Palestinians terrorist did he also had to be fed through a tube in his stomach to just like the terrorist did so I know he had the right treatment there’s little chance of survival with throat cancer dispite the very best treatment
muurad says
No matter how justly Jews treat muslims, it is next to impossible for muslims to be satisfied, especially when they accuse Israel with “murder” many in the west and most media will believe muslims out of cowafrdice.
The best doctors and hospitals in the world are Israelis. All Israel enemies go to Israeli hospitals for treatment, when they leave they become enemy again.
Does anyone go to Cairo or Riyadh? Ask yourselves … why? Because in Israeli hospital, they are patients and need care just like any other patient.
A sentiment and attitude you ‘ll never find in any muslim country.
Keith O says
WTF? So now according to the PA, not having a cure for cancer is murder?
gravenimage says
Palestinian Prisoner Dies of Throat Cancer, PLO Charges Israel with ‘Murder’
…………………….
Just grotesque calumny. This Jihadist had the best of care.
Norman Gardner says
Ashrawi is very deceitful, that is why no sensible person believes the Palestinians . One foolish woman was going to blow up the Israeli hospital that successfully treated her injured son. When they require medical help they run to Israel, when they don`t they want to destroy Israel. No brains.
Elliott Wartski says
Although it may be considered “immoral”, I strongly recommend that Israel enacts a new law: Call it the “Saeb Erekat Law”, which would state:
‘You can make any statement you like about Israel, in particular it’s medical facilities, but if any part of your statement includes even one lie / smear / anti-Semitic comment; you can NEVER be treated in an Israeli hospital’.
A list of people who break this law, should be published on a weekly basis.
Anyone agree?
Leonard says
Had he been released, he would not bother getting even the mediocre care that Palestinians give. He would have gone out a martyr, killing again.
The only medical treatment a killer should get is to prevent him passing on his illness to another, but surgery is not deserved, and even chemo is too much.
Lorensacho says
The Palestinians should be asked to forbid any of their people receiving cancer treatment at Israeli hospitals.
Brenrod says
When your enemy is deceitful about you you should not Treat him in your hospitals.