Preorder Did Muhammad Exist?: An Inquiry into Islam’s Obscure Origins―Revised and Expanded Editionhere.
Comments
Otissays
Jihadists and their sympathizers will embark on shading crocodile tears lamenting that their so called prohet is being slandered.It has reached a point whereby we want nothing than the truth concerning Islam and it’s origins. If Muslims can’t prove that Muhammad existed and looking at what his surmons has caused to infidels,then world leaders should take this opportunity to declare Islam a political scam,mental disease and bann it forever in civilized nations.
Beneath the Veil of Consciousnesssays
+1 Otis. Strike while the iron is hot!
Nokturnlsays
What time zone please ?
rooaresays
Doesn’t matter if Muhammad existed or not Muslims believe he did, consider him the ‘most perfect man’, and worthy of emulation i.e. if Muhammad did it then we Muslims should or must do it no matter how wicked, backward, and/or evil it is. And they have 14 hundred years of violent jihad to prove it with no end in sight.
Ecosse1314says
It does matter. Everything has to be put in its historical context.
It makes it easier to argue if it is proved Mecca did not exist in the 6 or 7th century. That would disprove the sunna and the hadiths.
It means we don’t have to argue purely on a theological basis but more importantly on a historical one.
rooaresays
No debate or critique is allowed in Islam therefore the argument of Muhammad’s existence only matters to infidels (i.e. non-Muslims) for we consider real history important to the issues at hand.
Rima Lagissays
No. Never.
There is np doubt that nobody saw him or any other prophets.
The believers believe that they must believe before they belie ve in God.
Too complicated? This is what I was instructed by Saadi. He is a very well known anti Israeli activist.
Discover more from
Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.
Otis says
Jihadists and their sympathizers will embark on shading crocodile tears lamenting that their so called prohet is being slandered.It has reached a point whereby we want nothing than the truth concerning Islam and it’s origins. If Muslims can’t prove that Muhammad existed and looking at what his surmons has caused to infidels,then world leaders should take this opportunity to declare Islam a political scam,mental disease and bann it forever in civilized nations.
Beneath the Veil of Consciousness says
+1 Otis. Strike while the iron is hot!
Nokturnl says
What time zone please ?
rooare says
Doesn’t matter if Muhammad existed or not Muslims believe he did, consider him the ‘most perfect man’, and worthy of emulation i.e. if Muhammad did it then we Muslims should or must do it no matter how wicked, backward, and/or evil it is. And they have 14 hundred years of violent jihad to prove it with no end in sight.
Ecosse1314 says
It does matter. Everything has to be put in its historical context.
It makes it easier to argue if it is proved Mecca did not exist in the 6 or 7th century. That would disprove the sunna and the hadiths.
It means we don’t have to argue purely on a theological basis but more importantly on a historical one.
rooare says
No debate or critique is allowed in Islam therefore the argument of Muhammad’s existence only matters to infidels (i.e. non-Muslims) for we consider real history important to the issues at hand.
Rima Lagis says
No. Never.
There is np doubt that nobody saw him or any other prophets.
The believers believe that they must believe before they belie ve in God.
Too complicated? This is what I was instructed by Saadi. He is a very well known anti Israeli activist.