This is just painting a large target on Hatun Tash’s back.
Islam mandates death for non-Muslim subjects of the Islamic state who mention “something impermissible about Allah, the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace), or Islam” (‘Umdat al-Salik, o11.10), and such laws are based upon passages in the Hadith and Sira in which Muhammad orders the murders of people who have insulted him.
These include Abu Afak, who was over one hundred years old, and the poetess Asma bint Marwan. Abu Afak was killed in his sleep, in response to Muhammad’s question, “Who will avenge me on this scoundrel?” Similarly, Muhammad on another occasion cried out, “Will no one rid me of this daughter of Marwan?” One of his followers, Umayr ibn Adi, went to her house that night, where he found her sleeping next to her children. The youngest, a nursing babe, was in her arms. But that didn’t stop Umayr from murdering her and the baby as well. Muhammad commended him: “You have done a great service to Allah and His Messenger, Umayr!” (Ibn Ishaq, 674-676)
Then there was Ka’b bin Al-Ashraf. Muhammad asked: “Who is willing to kill Ka’b bin Al-Ashraf who has hurt Allah and His Apostle?” One of the Muslims, Muhammad
bin Maslama answered, “O Allah’s Apostle! Would you like that I kill him?” When Muhammad said that he would, Muhammad bin Maslama said, “Then allow me to say a (false) thing (i.e. to deceive Kab).” Muhammad responded: “You may say it.” Muhammad bin Maslama duly lied to Ka’b, luring him into his trap, and murdered him. (Sahih Bukhari, volume 5, book 59, number 369)
Likewise the popular website Islam QA called for death for blasphemers, using both Qur’an and Hadith to make its argument. “The scholars are unanimously agreed,” the site explains, “that a Muslim who insults the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) becomes a kaafir [unbeliever] and an apostate who is to be executed. This consensus was narrated by more than one of the scholars, such as Imaam Ishaaq ibn Raahawayh, Ibn al-Mundhir, al-Qaadi ‘Iyaad, al-Khattaabi and others.”
“Police searching for assailant who stabbed ex-Muslim Hatun Tash,” 5Pillars, July 28, 2021 (thanks to The Religion of Peace):
Police are still searching for an assailant who stabbed the ex-Muslim Islamophobe Hatun Tash at Speakers’ Corner in London on Sunday.
Tash, 39, was stabbed several times while she was wearing a Charlie Hebdo T-Shirt and was “preaching the Gospel” to Muslims, but is said to be fine after receiving medical attention.
The assailant fled the scene as some of the other 30 people there confronted him/her. The knife used in the attack was recovered.
Tash, who is of Turkish origin, is known for insulting the Prophet (pbuh) and desecrating the Quran. She often goes down to Speakers’ Corner to debate and confront Muslims from her evangelical Christian perspective.
Hatun Tash leads DCCI ministries, which says it exists to defend Christ, critique Islam and preach the Gospel to Muslims using apologetics and polemics….
Detective Superintendent Alex Bingley, from the Central West Command Unit, which covers policing in Westminster, said: “This was clearly a very distressing incident for the woman involved and officers have spent time with her, whilst she was being treated for her injury, to get an account of what happened.
“We know that this assault was witnessed by a number of people, many of whom captured it on their phones. I would ask them, if they have not already done so, to contact police.
“We remain in the early stages of our investigation and are working hard to trace the person responsible. I would ask people not to speculate on the motive for the attack until we have established the full facts.”…
Jim says
The West needs to pass laws that specifically deny the resort to Sharia laws in their countries. Anyone who tries to apply them can be deported at once. But they won’t do it. The Muslims have Western countries in their pockets.
gravenimage says
Some US states have done this, Jim. More should follow.
mortimer says
Hatun Tash should write a book now that she is famous and get her message out to millions.
gravenimage says
I’d buy that book, Mortimer.
mortimer says
To GI: you are a fine writer, GI, perhaps you could be the ghost-writer who organizes and presents her thoughts and biography.
gravenimage says
Thank you, Mortimer–high praise from you.
James Lincoln says
gravenimage,
mortimer’s high praise is warranted!
gravenimage says
🙂
Otis says
My friend the biggest hindrance in stopping Muslims from taking over infidel countries are corrupt politicians/ elites as well as ignorant journalists.I have witnessed this here in Kenya severally.Politicians have invented various means of courting Muslims.Don’t be surprised to see them dorning Islamic attires and even attending Islamic celebrations e.g. breaking Iftar. For us to succeed in this fight, we must get rid of corrupt politicians in the first place.Corrupt politicians are the public enemy number one.
Raja says
Otis,
With all due respect to you, during my tenure as a journalist, I found that we hardly had any freedom. Blanket bans on news of some individuals and potentially uncomfortable episodes (for elites) were a simple no no. Those journalists who could create a niche for themselves in the social media were dependable as they were “free”. News was typically sourced from other giants like Reuters, AP, etc. So even if you were the wisest of the journalists you stood no chance of being heard. Almost all media and press want to tow the narrative of the elites.
gravenimage says
Thanks for that background, Raja.
Otis says
Thanks ? Raja for more enlightenment. But politicians are indeed betraying their citizens.
john smith says
Mortimer, It takes a lot of skill and talent in order to write a book which only a few posses. I for
one wouldn’t no were to start, but you Mortimer certainly do posses such a talent so does Gravenimage.
gravenimage says
Thank you, John. I agree with you about Mortimer.
Maureen Chaloner says
I agree. If I had MY way there would not be a single Muslim in the UK- not ONE!
Keith O says
In all likelihood nothing will be done to try and find the criminal who tried to kill this woman.
Although, if it had been a mudslime who had been attacked by a Christian or Hindu, there would be a nation wide manhunt in progress within minutes of it happening.
gravenimage says
Sadly this is likely true, Keith.
David M says
Sadiq Khan is frantic trying to find the perpetrator……..not! He hasn’t even mentioned the incident. I bet he is gloating over it, the good Muslim he is.
gravenimage says
David, Sadiq Khan was asked about the stabbing, and responded with these weasel words:
“As you know, freedom of speech is a principle that I hold dear. One of the best things about London is the fierce way in which we protect this right and people’s ability to exercise it. However, as I’m sure you will appreciate, the police have to balance this right with managing behaviour that could lead to public disorder. It is crucial that healthy debates do not lead to violence, and I support the rights of police officers to remove individuals in order to prevent a breach of the peace. ”
https://unherd.com/thepost/the-meaning-of-the-speakers-corner-stabbing/
In other words, we just *love* freedom of speech, but if it upsets Muslims and they become violent then we will arrest anyone who peacefully speaks out, while allowing those who are violent free to shut down anyone from speaking out.
This of course perfectly fits the Muslim agenda.
This is a good article at the link, by the way.
James Lincoln says
Perfectly stated, gravenimage.
gravenimage says
Thank you so much, James.
PMK says
“I would ask people not to speculate on the motive for the attack until we have established the full facts.”
My guess is that if they do manage to locate the assailant, he will be deemed ‘mentally ill’ and so will not face any criminal charges.
gravenimage says
Likely so, PMK.
And great to see you posting again!
PMK says
Thank you, gravenimage. It’s been a while.
gravenimage says
🙂
Maureen Chaloner says
The ‘motive’ is clear. Muslims want to impose Sharia law in or country. They can sod right off in my opinion, back to their own sh,,tholes and kill one another for all I care. The assailant would not have stabbed a big man, no the cowardly little sh…t attacked a small defenseless woman. Just goes to show you what complete weak brainwashed arses they really are!
Maureen Chaloner says
Sadly true and WE let this happen in OUR country. Just HOW stupid are we?
nicholas tesdorf says
You cannot insult the Prophet if he did not exist.
Jayell says
And even if this specimen did exist in some shape or form, there’s no good reason to accept that he even remotely resembled a ‘prophet’.
gravenimage says
Also true, Jayell. Muhammed was either a warlord, caravan raider, pedophile, slaver, rapist, and mass murderer–or else this was someone’s idea of the ideal man. Grotesque in either case.
mortimer says
Right, GI. The Mohammed described in the Sira and the hadiths is a reprehensible villain who in our day would be arrested and sentenced to life imprisonment for crimes against humanity. Insults to this evil sadist (whether fictional or real) are entirely deserved!
gravenimage says
So true, Mortimer.
mortimer says
To Jayell: Mohammed is the world’s most obvious FALSE prophet.
Wellington says
I think what is far more accurate, whether actual or fictional, is “The Profit.”
mortimer says
Wellington is correct ‘The Profit’ … the Koran contains a chapter titled ‘THE BOOTY’.
Bukhari 4:52:220: “Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah’s Apostle said, “I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror, and while I was sleeping, the KEYS OF THE TREASURE OF THE WORLD were brought to me and put in my hand.” Abu Huraira added: Allah’s Apostle has left the world and now you, (MUSLIM PEOPLE), are bringing out those treasures (i.e. the Prophet did not benefit by them).”
Muslims consider the wealth of the earth to be ‘booty’ to be plundered by Muslims and the people of the earth to be potential slaves for the Muslims.
James Lincoln says
?
revereridesagain says
Since when has it been possible to “insult” Mohammed the child-raping “Prophet” (PSBH = Pig $#it Be Upon Him)?
francis says
another variation is pbuh = piss be upon him
gravenimage says
UK Muslim publication says Christian stabbed at Speakers’ Corner ‘is known for insulting the Prophet’
………….
Note that 5Pillars does not condemn this appalling attack. No surprise there…
And the comment on this thread suggests that she stabbed herself–despite there being easily accessed video footage of the attack. *Ugh*.
Other disgusting articles on 5Pillars include one saying that the slaughter of up to 2 million Armenians was not a genocide, describing the Muslim community of Sri Lanka as “vibrant” and supposedly persecuted while deliberately ignoring the Jihad Easter Church bombings there, an article praising violent Muslim conquest of Infidels, a piece lauding turning Hagia Spophia into a Mosque, a piece applauding the Jannisaries and kidnapping of Christian children and forced conversion to Islam, and articles demonizing democracy. Much more there. Ugly stuff, but all perfectly Islamic.
Noam Cherney says
Am I the only one who has never heard of muslims going berserk for insulting Allah ? They seem pretty much putting mohammed over god. While criticizing christians for the concept of Trinity, they have a Trinity of their own wirh Mohammed first, koran second and Allah last …
gregbeetham says
Muslims can gloss over any amount of inconvenient truths, they are adept at deception including apparently self deception, they conveniently don’t notice that Islam has vestiges of the prior Moon god religion all over the place, that’s why there are pagan crescent moon symbols on buildings and flags etc. and then there is the black rock worshippers who got incorporated into Islam and now all Muslims think there is some divinity attached to the pagan black rock stuck on the corner of the Kaabah.
Yes it is a murderous satanic pagan cult and the followers are practically zombies, it should be banned from all civilized societies.
gravenimage says
Good observation, Noam. “Allah” has been described as Muhammed’s sock puppet, and this seems pretty accurate.
Walter Sieruk says
This further shows that Islam is based on vicious hate-filled violence and not reason and logic.
mortimer says
Yes, the attacker was imitating Mohammed.
Walter Sieruk says
One way this “War of ideas ” may be defined is that it’s the Christian West verse the Islamic East. That brutal and bloody incdent at Hyde Park is a reminder of the 1979 movie entitled TIME AFTER TIME. This reason is because the hero on that movie had shown wisdom when he said “The first man to raise his fist is the man who has run out of ideas” The violent follower of Islam must have “run out of ideas.”
gravenimage says
Sadly, though, Muslims don’t care about this. They just want to force Infidels to submit, and are fine using violence.
John says
“Submit”, is the Arabic meaning of the English word,” Peace”. islam is Arabic, therefore it is,” Religion of SUBMISSION”. More likely a Barbaric Totalitarian Political IDEOLOGY of male Savages than a religion.
gravenimage says
Important point, John. Submission, not peace.
John says
“the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace), ” WTF, Satan’s advocates do not even understand the English Meaning of the English word” Peace’. Just the Arabic meaning which is ‘SUBMISSION” or DIE. Bless him my arse.
Jerry says
You can’t insult a long dead prophet, let alone a self appointed fake prophet.
Mohammad was self indulgent gigolo who for year had a wealthy and enterprising “Sugar Mummy”.
When she died the work shy parasite had to build and expand his own enterprise dedicated to raiding desert Oases and Caravans, murdering most males robbing and plundering their animals goods and possessions and taking the Women, girls and “unbemished” toddler boys as sex slaves most to tavish and some to trade.
Mohammad expanded his Marauding Brigand Bands to become a Mega “Godfather” of an ancient crime Syndicate.
To recruit his criminal underlings first sufficed his offer to them that in return for his leadership and planning he would only take one fifth of the Loot, and they would keep the remaining four fifths.
When some, no doubt after some less successful raids questioned about what would happen if they died on such raids the concept of Jihad was invented and so was the concept of the Islamic Paradise – an (imagined) mega Whorehouse in the hereafter, replete with Seventy Two (somewhat used used but eternally self repairing and replenishing) dark eyed “Virgins” allotted to each Shaid, all besides streams overflowing with wine.
Through the evolution of mankind humans became interdependent and some developed compassion towards others, mainly those resembling themselves and their own young.
Even hardened criminals often require some excuse or justification for harming others.
That excuse was countered by Mohammad invention of the concept of Kaffirs and Kufar, claiming that all were born Muslims and those who were not practicing as such were either corrupted by others including parents, or, worse, were in willful denial of his “True Faith” and thus Kaffirs (not simply ignorant non-believers).
Mohammad tried at first to recruit Jews and Christians to his marauding bands under the false misrepresentation that his falsification were actually the true corrections of their own faith. Thus, initially he appeared friendly to both.
Jews rejected his falsehoods outright and so did many Christians. Thus developed Mohammad’s pathological and genocidal hatred of all.Jews and the slightly lesser hatred of all Christians.
When Mohammad conquered Mecca and captured the Kaaba, a site of a fallen Meteorite and a shrine to 360 Idol Deities, he used the same pretence he first tried with the Jews and Christians pretending to bring the Arab Pagans a new and improved version of their own and original faith.
Mohammad then demoted 359 of the idolatry deities and promoted the one, Allah as their chief deity.
The Islamic battle Cry: Allahu Akhbar, actually offends and is blasphemous against the pretended but professed Islamic Monotheism.
It means Allah is the Greatest, or Greater (by) comparison, thus, in a roundabout way acknowledging the existence and deity of 359 othe Kaaba Idols as (minor) deities.
Mohammad ambition drove him to wish himself a God, but he was smart enough to tealise that doing so would alienate even the gullible Arab Pagans.
He cleverly proclaimed himself as the last and final prophet, thus making himself the only arbiter of God’s will and Command.
gravenimage says
Certainly plausible.
John Smith says
Nothing much in the UK MSM, they appear to be scared, only @GBNews gave it appropriate exposure. It was an horrendous attack, with a knife, on a very small female.
Are the MSM Christianophobes, or scared?
Jerry says
See my explanation of Mohammad and Islam, below, albeit full of uncorrectable typos and misspellings.
To a greater or lesser extent, all off us consider many of our own observations, religious and or political, as the self evident truth.
Most of us do not intend to lie or decieve others let alone ourselves.
However, go and face a wall. What you see is the truth and it appears self evident.
Our observation, does not immediately reveal, however, that there is a whole, practically infinite universe beyond that wall, containing, at least, some if the rest of the truth.
Francis says
There is virtually no coverage of this in the UK but there is an excellent article in the online ‘The Critic’ by Tim Dieppe at https://thecritic.co.uk/stabbed-for-critiquing-islam/
gravenimage says
Thanks for that link, Francis.
francis says
why in this article is the word prophet followed by the words (pbuh)
I for one don’t believe that we have to toe the line on respecting this false prophet, murderer, padeophile, misogynist and caravan robber. perhaps we should always use the phraseology Prophet (self proclaimed / false) when referring to this obvious fraud.
gravenimage says
Francis, this is a quote. Quotes have to be cited verbatim. This does not mean that Robert Spencer agrees with this appellation.
OLD GUY says
Islam is a dictatorship, and all dictators use violence and fear to control their followers and to enslave others.
JCA Reid says
Islam & its perverted, degenerate “Prophet” insults Humanity & decent Human Conduct! Anyone with half a working Brain Cell can see that! Yasser Arafat was right…. “…..most Wars are caused by People talking to their imaginary friends.” Ms Tush is a brave lady & did not deserve this. Just shows how perverted & degenerate Muslims are.
Aussie Infidel says
Islam is a religion born out of hatred and violence, that attracts hateful and violent people to its cause, and is perpetuated by hatred and violence.