Expelling this student is just dealing with a symptom of the real problem. Will France have the courage to confront those in the country who believe that Sharia blasphemy laws should be imposed and enforced?
“‘Samuel Paty had to open his mouth’: 13-year-old banned from school for defending terrorism,” translated from ““Samuel Paty n’avait qu’à pas ouvrir sa bouche” : une ado de 13 ans exclue de son collège pour apologie du terrorisme,” Valuers Actuelles, December 9, 2021 (thanks to Medforth):
“It’s not my fault that he’s dead. It’s because he didn’t have to open his mouth…” These words were said last November 17 by a 13-year-old high school girl during a Spanish class. She was referring here to Samuel Paty, professor of history and geography, who was murdered in October 2020 by a terrorist, in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine. After that, the student was expelled from her school, located in the town of Mesnil-Saint-Denis, in the Yvelines, Le Parisien reports, Thursday, December 9. Proceedings have been opened for defending terrorism and the girl will be presented in early January to a juvenile judge.
The teenager was initially excluded from school as a precaution, Le Parisien said. She then went to a disciplinary council on November 29. The latter pronounced her final exclusion. At the same time, a procedure for acts of defense of terrorism was therefore opened by the group of violence against people from the Urban Police of Elancourt, continues the daily. For her part, the Spanish teacher, shocked by the words of her pupil, has been on sick leave since the events, observes Le Parisien. She was heard in connection with the investigation, along with the principal of the college.
Other people were interviewes, such as classmates of the teenager, present during this class. They were thus able to confirm her words. Convened on December 7, the latter partially acknowledged the facts, without however realizing their magnitude. As for her mother, she mentioned the difficult and provocative behavior of her daughter to investigators, observes Le Parisien. The teenager, on the advice of the Public Prosecutor’s Office, was summoned to an Educational Unit at the Tribunal (UEAT). On January 10, she will be presented to a juvenile judge.
Fitna says
Oh look they found the bad egg. I’m sure none of the other Muslim kids, parents, community share the same views. Nope it’s just one little rogue, misbehaving, antisocial child. The rest are perfect little angels, who want to integrate and learn like their infidel classmates.
Muslims lie to us, Leftists lie to us, the media/elites lie to us and themselves about the real enormity of the problem. If anyone dares to suggest the problem is with most if not all Muslims, suddenly we’re the bad guys, not the Muslims who support beheading, destruction of free speech, incitement to terrorism, rape, etc. No we’re the problem.
Clearly everything is going along swimmingly. While Muslim countries are expelling thousands and millions of Muslims for a terrorism threat, we keep letting them in, no matter how bad things get. Muslims are bringing weapons, including hand-grenades to election events (like Zemmour’s) and the Left/media are silent about it. They’re openly waging war against us and we keep ignoring it.
I’m afraid there will be dozens more teachers losing their heads until we either fight back to learn to ‘shut up’ and be obedient, good little dhimmis or behave like slaves and battered wives (no offense to the latter).
Fitna says
*or learn…
mortimer says
Agree. Where there is one ‘bad apple’ there will be others in the barrel. In fact, 15% of all Muslim populations worldwide claim to support terrorist groups.
fadeye@yahoo.com says
I’d swear I saw a poll claiming TWICE that figure, estimated worldwide! But who can trust polls nowadays?!lol
raja says
Mortimer,
15 % is abysmally low and inaccurate. One survey in France has claimed that 66 % of French Muslims don’t recognize rule rule of man or infidel. Then there was that 82 % who were against criticism of religion as it “would hurt the religious sentiments of the people”.
Overwhelming majority of Muslims are for Sharia whether you like it or not.
\
gravenimage says
And here are Muslims around the world condemning France for daring to consider beheading a peaceful teacher by Muslims illegal:
“Muslim Countries Denounce French Response to Killing of Teacher, Urge Boycott”
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/27/world/europe/French-Muslims-Turkey-crackdown.html
Jim J Fox says
“..Lie to us AND THEMSELVES”.
Beneath the Veil of Consciousness says
She’ll be shipped off to an exclusive Muslim only private school where she can openly mainline this corrosive and toxic ideology at taxpayers’ expense.
fadeye@yahoo.com says
…and be trained in weapons & explosives probably.
mortimer says
A 13-yr-old Muslim is already to kill blasphemers. But what is the legal definition of this crime in Islam … not what you think!
The authoritative Sharia manual ‘Reliance of the Traveller’ says the death penalty applies to a DHIMMI or KAFIR who ‘mentions something impermissible about Islam’ (- Reliance of the Traveller’ Chapter ‘O’ 11.10.05.)
That is wide open to interpretation and can mean any remark or action by a kafir that a Muslim doesn’t like, no matter how slight or trivial. This Sharia blasphemy is, then, extremely flexible and arbitrary.
There need not be a real offense, just the perception of an offense. And the punishment is death, and the Islamic mob or one Muslims is authorized to murder the supposed blasphemer even without a trial.
Islam’s blasphemy law enshrines vigilantism.
How can France deal with ISLAMIC VIGILANTISM, since Allah’s law is supposedly higher than French law?
notnolib says
What about just “pointing out”? For example, if someone were to point out that islam was invented by an insane maniac named “mohammed”, or that this mohammed also invented the moon-god allah, what would happen?
gravenimage says
Not what we think? I think most Anti-Jihadists here know that violence towards “blasphemers” is sacralized.
mortimer says
This 13-yr-old terror-support said, in effect, that Samuel Paty should have submitted to discriminatory Sharia law in France which has adopted a code of human rights including the freedom of expression.
She claims that Paty died because he DID NOT submit to Sharia. He had it coming to him. Allah’s law supersedes French human rights law. So there!
She has no doubt about it: Samuel Paty deserved to be assassinated under Sharia blasphemy law.
How many other Muslims in France believe that?
………………………………………………………………………
France Muslims Attitude Terrorism
https://www.breitbart.com/europe/2020/09/03/over-quarter-french-muslim-youth-refuse-condemn-charlie-hebdo-terror-attack/
A survey released by the Institut Français d’Opinion Publique (Ifop) has revealed that 26 per cent of French Muslims under the age of 25 refuse to condemn the 2015 Charlie Hebdo terror killings.
However, five per cent of Muslims say they do not condemn the actions of the radical Islamic terrorists who committed the attack, and when broken down by age, over a quarter of those under 25 said they would not condemn killings, while 12 per cent said they condemn the attack but share the values of the attackers.
72 per cent of all Muslims denounced the 2015 massacre — but this majority is still significantly lower than the figure for the public at large, with 88 per cent of the general population condemning the killings.
41 per cent of Muslims said they would not participate in a minute’s silence for the victims, and a quarter of Muslims said they would even hurl insults during ceremonies to honour those slain.
The spread of Islamist theology and ideology has been a significant problem in France in recent years, despite President Emmanuel Macron being forced to shut down several associations and schools linked to radicalism.
A leaked report earlier this year from the General Directorate for Internal Security (DGSI) said that as many as 150 neighbourhoods across France were “held” by radical Islamic extremists.
Infidel says
I’m impressed that she was expelled. In this new bizarre Europe, I’d have expected her to receive a scholarship. Of course, the cynical me believes that this only happened b’cos there’s an election on in France, and no one now wants to be seen as pandering to muslims, since there are 3 candidates – Le Pen, Zemmour and the third guy I forget (not the mainstream female candidate that called herself a Merkel) – ostensibly willing to take them on
Rufolino says
The only candidate for President ready to make the radical changes necessary is Eric Zemour. If any of the other candidates are elected nothing serious will be done, they will tinker with this potentially catastrophic situation (a partitioned France and guerrilla war) to little real effect. Zemmour is about action, the other candidates are about politics.
PMK says
Who taught her this? The entire family should be removed from France.
Chrissie01 says
+++
EXACTLY
A 13-year-old’s opinion is not self-taught. It is overheard time and again in her community
john smith says
You said it PMK, “the entire family should be removed from France,” because that is were she got it from, her own family.
gravenimage says
+1
Kepha says
Kein Wunder. The Qu’ran itself is a manual for unholy warriors, looters, and rapists. It has a view that the unbelieving world is a place for looting and enslaving; it envisions Muslims males as a herrenvolk living on the sweat of the conquered rather than as productive persons (compare how the Bible has Adam in Paradise as “tilling and keeping the garden”, and naming the other creatures).
My own guess is that now that we have a Western world that has loudly and proudly said of the Son of God “We will not have this man to rule over us” (Luke 19:13), that same Western World will learn from a hostile and parasitic Islam not to blaspheme. I weep saying this. Islam is a collection of lies, blasphemies, and heresies. But the true God who is will not be mocked, and whatsoever we sow, we reap. (Gal. 6:7).
livingengine says
Samuel Paty was killed after a social media campaign.
Similar things are already taking place in this country. Just ask Bill Larion, Dan Leonard, and Tamar Herman .
CAIR and Tamar Herman – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ev42J1TavAE
tim gallagher says
Our western societies are all about freedom of speech and the freedom to criticise any ideas and any ideologies. Islam doesn’t allow this freedom, so Muslims don’t belong in any western society. This 13 year old should be shipped back to some Muslim society where people are not allowed to open their mouths about anything. She, and so many other Muslim primitives, do not belong in any western society where we value freedom of speech. islam and the western world are totally incompatible. One of the dopiest ideas ever is the idea that islam and western societies will get along swimmingly. It’s never going to happen.
OLD GUY says
Sadly this will be coming to America sooner than you think. The muslim/islamic migration invasion of America is rolling on with help from our Government and the supposed do gooders, along with open borders. Islam will bring violence to our neighborhoods as well as a loss of property values and crime.
So what is the gain to this supposed diversity? From what I see there is no diversity under Islam.
gravenimage says
France: 13-year-old Muslima defends beheading of teacher over Muhammad cartoon: ‘He didn’t have to open his mouth’
……………..
How many more Muslims in france and the rest of the West are just like this girl>? She didn’t come up with this savagery and homicidal Islamic supremacy herself, but from her parents, Mosque, and associates.