Nupur Sharma didn’t say anything other than what Islamic scholars themselves say. But it is impermissible for a non-Muslim to note such facts disapprovingly. Everyone must submit and accept Islamic perspectives.
“Prophet row: Rajasthan man offers house, property to anyone who beheads Nupur Sharma,” by Manish Godha, Free Press Journal, July 5, 2022:
After the heinous beheading of Kanhiya Lal in Udaipur, the incidents of death threats and controversial posts on social media are being reported in various parts of Rajasthan. Five persons have been arrested in the Hanumangarh district for circulating objectional content on social media.
The internet services were suspended in the state for three days after the Udaipur incident. Internet and other services were restored in a phased manner on Monday, however, as soon as they were restored, the cases of threats and objectionable content also started coming to the fore on social media.
Beheading Nupur Sharma:
In Ajmer, a man, who identified himself as Salman Chisti announced to give away his house and property as a reward to anyone who beheads suspended BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma for controversial remarks on the Prophet. Salman also made a video for this that has gone viral.
In the video, accused Salman Chisti can be heard saying, “I swear on my god, mother and children…I will give away the house and property to anyone who beheads Nupur Sharma.”
After the video went viral, the Ajmer police lodged a case under IT sections, IPC 153-A (promoting enmity on grounds of religion) and other relevant sections.
Additional Superintendent of Police Vikas Sangwan said, “a video of a person making controversial remarks came to us and we registered a case. Investigation revealed that the accused was intoxicated when he made the statements. Efforts are being made to nab the accused who is absconding. The accused is a history-sheeter and has over 15 cases registered against him in the past.”
A lawyer, Bhanu Pratap Singh from Ajmer was also threatened on social media. Singh said that he was chatting with someone on Youtube regarding Nupur Sharma’s statement, during which one Suhail Saiyad threatened him saying, ‘Teri to garden kategi.’ (you will be beheaded). The lawyers of Ajmer have complained to the police regarding this….
somehistory says
Are there no laws against such things? In the U.S., this would be seen as a crime. to solicit murder and offer payment for same.
somehistory says
It seems there are laws there against someone saying something bad; this creep has evidently been in trouble before, so evidently he is not afraid of committing crimes of a serious nature, and I hope they catch and prosecute under whatever serious laws he has broken. If there is no law against soliciting for murder, the government should come up with one.
shoehorn says
One would think there is a law against soliciting murder in India, but surely there’s a law against chopping people’s heads off. Who knows.
somehistory says
Perhaps it’s similar to what is happening in the U.S. some members of certain groups…or criminal gangs…are just not being prosecuted.
mortimer says
In India, there are provisions in the Indian Penal Code that directly criminalize incitement of violence, section 153, 505 and 506 as well.
Section 153A criminalises and punishes making statements, speeches or acts which have the effect of disturbing public tranquility or law and order by promoting enmity or creating fear or alarm between classes of people on basis of difference in religion, caste, language or place of birth.
SECTION 506. Punishment for criminal intimidation.—Whoever commits, the offence of criminal intimidation shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both; If threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, etc.—And if the threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, or to cause the destruction of any property by fire, or to cause an offence punishable with death or 1[imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years, or to impute, unchastity to a woman, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.
Wellington says
Among so many perversions here is that anyone casting aspersions upon Jesus (whose character is infinitely superior to that of the reputed Mohammed’s—even though Islam, in full parasitic and appropriation mode, as with Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus himself, et al. have assumed that all were Muslims—and this in and of itself is telling and parasitic to the nth degree), if a Christian, would never want such a person to be harmed or killed. Ditto for Buddhists for anyone criticizing Buddha. And ditto for agnostics, Jews, Hindus, et al.
No, only Islam in our age threatens mortal punishment for criticizing their “chief spokesman” or their tenets overall. And thus here again Islam reveals itself for what it is, i.e. the only major religion which in its very theological blueprint demands obedience to its theological dictates or else.
Beyond pathetic. But so very Islamic.
Thank you again, Islam, for being an enemy of true liberty, and thank you again, all you Western non-Muslims out there who know next to nothing about Islam but who nonetheless stupidly, indefensibly, unethically and illogically continue to shill for the predecessor to Nazism—the master faith v. the master race.
All of you (i.e., Muslims and dhimmi apologists for Islam) should be ashamed of yourselves but you won’t be until you really study what Islam is truly all about, i.e., mankind finally getting a major religion which is rotten to the core. Yes, Islam is the oldest continuous totalitarian ideology, though in religious and not secular form, and damn well disguised as well. Learn, both deluded Muslims and deluded dhimmis—but most of you won’t and thus the bane of Islam will continue to afflict mankind as does Western Leftism and your standard and oh so stupid traditional authoritarianism as exhibited by dictators like Putin, Xi and Little Rocket man in North Korea.
Man never learns. Want proof of this? Well then, just examine the last twenty years of mankind, including the bogus administration of that monumental fool and liar, one Joe Biden. Yes, individuals learn but man as a whole never learns. Time for a beer—or maybe three.
gravenimage says
+1
gregbeetham says
The root of the problem is the aberrant philosophy of the Lefties and Muslims which is similar in one fundamental aspect and that is they are entitled to a free lunch at someone else’s expense. They are like spoilt children in that regard, they never really grew up, and it extends to other facets of social outlook as well because both blame everyone else for self inflicted harm.
There is a difference in implementation though, Lefties evolve in permissive societies and Muslims have a doctrine of supremacist totalitarian oppression which the Lefties admire as long as it isn’t the Lefties who get oppressed which does eventually happen of course as you say but you can’t expect spoilt children to know any actual history when they can freely invent some convenient historical content that suits their narrative.
mortimer says
Good observations from Wellington. In Islam, Mohammed is more sacrosanct than Allah himself.
In fact, Islam gives divine attributes to Mohammed which constitute blasphemous ‘SHIRK’ (wrong worship).
The Shahada (short Islamic creed) mentions Allah and Mohammed in the same breath as seeming partners … Muslims don’t even realize that the Shahada is SHIRK.
Muslims are so afraid of the power of the mullahs to write a fatwah for their execution, that almost no Muslim will ever disagree with them.
gregbeetham says
Offering bribes to get someone murdered because they spoke the truth about the fake prophet, I would expect no less from a believer in the cult of Satan.
gravenimage says
Yep.
Ade Fegan says
Slander in Islam is saying things which they know are true … but they don’t want said
gravenimage says
So true, Ade–there is even a word in Arabic for this, “Ghiba”.
“Slander (ghiba) means to mention anything concerning a person that he would dislike.”
https://seekersguidance.org/answers/general-counsel/what-is-ghiba-slander/
Ade Fegan says
The illusion of “becoming victorious through terror”
nobody is ever victorious through terror
gravenimage says
Sadly, if your only goal is rape, plunder, and conquest it works.
tim gallagher says
I would have thought that the non-Muslims in India would be outraged by this filth from the Muslim maggots and maybe fight back and decide to kick the arseholes out of India. What a better country it would then become. Hopefully, eventually, they will decide to do so. Muslims demonstrate over and over again that they are not fit to live in any non-Muslim country. They are just too barbaric by far.
gregbeetham says
The Indian government are making the same mistake they all make, appeasing Muslims is a waste of time, when Muslims go on a rant the proper response is to let em have it both barrels and the more they chuck a fit the more you let em have it until you run out of Muslims, job done.
tim gallagher says
Yes, alas, that must be it, gregbeetham. When will all of us non-Muslims learn? I suppose the more sane and peaceful non-Muslims of the world crave a peaceful life, whereas the raving loony Muslims are always fired up for war. One day we are all going to have to wake the hell up and absolutely hammer the Muslims. And as you say, the wilder the Muslims get the harder we need to hammer them.
gregbeetham says
Tim I think the ‘good’ Muslims we have are good for two reasons, one is that they have got themselves a free pass into Jannah because they went to a foreign land to spread Islam and the other reason is not too many Muslims fully know the Jihad doctrine contained in the Koran and the Hadiths.
The danger is their children when the clerics get their hands on them, they don’t have any immunity from the Jihad requirement so they have to think how they are going to avoid the burning pit for eternity by conducting some form of Jihad, whatever that might turn out to be. Islam is an insidious evil and impressionable children are its victims, what clerics teach children should be monitored without fail.
Fitna says
Spot on Tim
tim gallagher says
Thanks, Fitna. We definitely see things the same way when it comes to islam.
shoehorn says
They had their chance during partition. Pakistan kicked Hindus out but India failed to reciprocate. Now they got the 3rd largest Muslim community in the world.
gravenimage says
Sadly true. There are few non-Muslims in Bangladesh, and they have been almost completely wiped out in Pakistan. Meanwhile, the Muslim population in India has grown sharply.
Devasur says
Leftists don’t care about the hindus, Buddhists, Christians etc getting wiped out in Pakistan and Bangladesh. While simultaneously cry about imaginary Muslim genocide in India. It is so obvious that they only care about Muslims.
tim gallagher says
No doubt true, shoehorn. The usual situation with islam. Any tolerance is always one way. One day I believe it will be different. Non-Muslims everywhere will have had enough of islam’s crap and will get tough with its appalling behaviour.
gregbeetham says
Two countries have already had enough of Muslim crap, China is one and Myanmar is the other one and the humanitarians got their knickers in a knot over it.
tim gallagher says
Yes, that’s right, gregbeetham. I would also include countries like Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic and Slovakia who refuse to let Muslims into their countries in the first place, which is a great way to go. I remember the criticism that Myanmar copped when they threw their Muslims out. I thought that they had just had enough of the usual appalling behaviour from Muslims, so I thought their actions made sense. The Chinese regime I loathe, but maybe they do also have a reason to get so tough with their Muslims. Where Muslims gain power they always treat non-Muslims very badly so I have no sympathy for them.
gravenimage says
India: Muslim offers house, property to anyone who beheads Nupur Sharma, despite accusations being false
………………………
Just horrifying–and of course it doesn’t matter that what Nupur Sharma said was simply what all pious Muslims believe.
Is he going to be prosecuted for this? I hope so–but in today’s India this is hardly a sure bet…
Fitna says
Ya that’s the trouble with India and it’s plurality of beliefs/cultures. On the one hand they want to appear tolerant of everyone. On the other they’re tolerant of the intolerant, which is criminal and insane.
Also being a poorer country they lack the resources we do in the West to tackle Islam. Plus with greedy, corrupt politicians, it’s hard to get anything accomplished. Modi talked tough about Islam to get elected then acted like a good little Dhimmi once he was in power.
However that was also because scummy traitorous Lefties went after him as well. What India and every free country needs is a strongman who’s not cowed by anyone and will smash both the Muslims and Lefties.
James Lincoln says
Fitna says,
“they’re tolerant of the intolerant, which is criminal and insane.”
Yes.
Consider “The Paradox of Tolerance”:
This was a concept advanced by the philosopher Karl Popper which claims that “unlimited tolerance necessarily results in the destruction of the tolerant by the intolerant, resulting in a society in which tolerance is no longer possible.”
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
Wellington says
Seconded. And yet, James, this is the very argument that Leftists use to silence mainstream conservatives.
It was used just yesterday against me on another site, to wit, that Leftists have a right to silence people like me because we endorse intolerance (of course we do not) and thus we deserve to be silenced.
My “crime”: castigating those who chased Justice Kavanaugh out of a restaurant in DC. But you see such people deserve to do so because Kavanaugh and his defenders (like me) should have no protection because we are tolerant of the intolerant even though it is the intolerant here who are intolerant of the tolerant—for instance having abortion decided by some 150 million voters in 50 states instead of nine people deciding such.
This is the “thinking” of Western Leftist totalitarian thought most everywhere. Ominous. Wrong. Inimical to true freedom of expression. Very intolerant and totalitarian. But so very Leftist.
Infidel says
James
I have heard Sanjay Dixit, who’s occasionally interviewed RS for his YouTube show “The Jaipur Dialogues”, cite this principle from Karl Popper: “Tolerance of the intolerant leads to intolerance”
gravenimage says
True, Fitna, James, and Wellington. Tolerance is generally a good thing–but where it includes tolerance of the violently intolerant, it is anything but.
Mark Spahn (West Seneca, NY) says
==QUOTE== Salman Chisti can be heard saying, “I swear on my god, mother and children…I will give away the house and property to anyone who beheads Nupur Sharma.” ==UNQUOTE
Hello, Salman. Before we go ahead with what you propose, let’s clarify a few things. What does “swear on” mean? If I behead Ms. Sharma and you fail to deed me your house and property (including shares of stock), I will have the right to kill your mother (still living?) and children (how many?), right? I take your god to be fictional, so I won’t try to kill him (or her). We need to put your offer into the form of a legally binding contract. (May I sub-contract the “hit”, Mafia-style?)
somehistory says
OT
per the Jerusalem Post
“Eid al-Adha festival in Ramallah attacked for ‘displaying LGBT banners'”
“palestinian thugs attacked a group of people in Ramallah on Friday who were celebrating Eid al-Adha, on the pretext that participants were carrying banners belonging to the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) community…….Palestinian Authority policemen fired live ammunition into the air to stop the assault.”
Infidel says
In somewhat related news, members of the sufi shrine in Ajmer were found to be connected to the murder of Kanhaiya Lal. On top of that, other members had called for a boycott of Hindus, and in return, the number of Hindus visiting that shrine fell by 90%, which is great news
https://www.opindia.com/2022/07/ajmer-dargah-witnesses-sharp-decline-in-devotee-footfall-after-anti-hindu-speeches
One of the most ridiculous practices of HINOs (Hindus in name only) is that they go to Ajmer to visit this Sufi shrine, and ask the members to pray for their success. Which of course muslims aren’t allowed to do: what they do pray for is for those people to be shown the ‘light of islam’. As a result, the money of these pilgrims is what drives the economy of that city
Today, thankfully, after the hate speeches of those Sufis, the bulk of these morons finally see a different light (than islam) and are boycotting that place. As a result, hotels, guest houses, restaurants and other tourist driven businesses were left floundering
Hindus need to read and learn the real color of Sufis in general, and this one in particular. Qhwaja Moin ud din Chisti was a soldier in the invading muslim army that massacred the people of Ajmer, boasted of abducting, converting and raping Rajput princesses and destroying temples and slaughtering cows. Anything but the ‘peaceful’ reputation that Sufis supposedly have. As one wag put it, they’ll cut your throat while whirling and dancing and singing their qawali songs
https://www.opindia.com/2020/06/islamic-jihad-india-sufi-khwaja-moinuddin-chisti-garib-nawaz-nizamuddin-khilji-hindus-forced-conversions
Devasur says
Sufism music and dance itself are copied from hindus. Nothing they have is original.
Infidel says
And from other people, since the Sufis of places like Samarqand, Buqhara, Rum and various other places had limited access to Hindus. At any rate, I find both their music and dance pretty horrendous: almost at par w/ the “Trap” music of today
Andrew Blackadder says
Just imagine the reaction if that lady had said something on Indian TV that was wrong or insulting about islam..
My personal opinion of islam is so important to muslims around the world, whereas their personal opinion of my beliefs are of zero importance to me.
If I tell a wee muslim fellow that I think his religion appears to be very violent and he then attacks me very violently for saying this then i wonder if he is being a good wee muslim fellow by doing so…
islam is a Fascist Religious Cult in EVERY description of those three words…
Now they really wanna behead me… Bring it on Ali Baba…Bring it on….
Maemae77 says
This is silencing the truth tellers. Freedom of speech and Islam cannot coexist.
#WithoutLiesIslamDies