So apparently the Supreme Court considers Nupur Sharma responsible for the beheading of a Hindu tailor by two Muslims, as well as for the beheading of a medical professional, and for the riots that have taken place all over the country. This is an extraordinarily irresponsible ruling that will only encourage jihadis, as they will see that Indian authorities are ready to absolve them of all responsibility for their actions and blame those whom they claim caused their murderous rage.
“Ex BJP Spokesperson Nupur Sharma Should ‘Apologise To Country’: Supreme Court,” NDTV, July 1, 2022:
New Delhi: The Supreme Court today blamed suspended BJP leader Nupur Sharma for igniting tension with her comments on Prophet Muhammad and said she should “apologise to the whole country”.
“The way she has ignited emotions across the country. This lady is single-handedly responsible for what is happening in the country,” said the judges….
“We saw the debate on how she was incited. But the way she said all this and later says she was a lawyer it is shameful. She should apologise to the whole country,” said Justice Surya Kant.
Nupur Sharma had requested the court to transfer to Delhi the multiple FIRs filed against her across the country, citing threats. Questioned on the use of a “deceptive name” in her petition, her lawyer said she had not used her name because of the threats. “She faces threats or she has become a security threat,” the judges snapped.
The court snubbed Nupur Sharma’s argument on “equal treatment” and “no discrimination”.
“But when you file FIRs against others, they are immediately arrested but when it’s against you nobody has dared to touch you,” the judges said.
Her comments showed her “obstinate and arrogant character”, said the Supreme Court.
“What if she is the spokesperson of a party. She thinks she has back up of power and can make any statement without respect to the law of the land?”
Her lawyer replied she had only responded to a question by the anchor during a TV debate. When the lawyer referred to the citizens right to speak, the judges replied caustically: “In a democracy, everyone has the right to speak. In a democracy, grass has right to grow and the donkey has the right to eat.”
Nupur Sharma’s argument citing an order about protecting journalistic freedom did not wash.
“She cannot be put on the pedestal of a journalist. When she goes and lambasts on a TV debate and makes irresponsible statements without thinking of the ramifications and consequences that it will have on the fabric of society,” said the Supreme Court.
Nupur Sharma withdrew her petition.
raja says
It’s Sharia court at work. Some ignorant and useless people make it to the top in judicial circles. The Sharma’s advocate can’t even defend her.
It is the courts, though independent are the root cause of mushrooming of kangaroo courts and sundry mafias across the Indian nation.
Roland says
It is unfortunate that Indian elites, such as the Supreme Court and BJP leaders, are just as willing as Western leaders to throw Islam critics to the wolves. Yet, Nupur Sharma was not a significant or harsh critic of Islam. No elite blandishments will satisfy the rage mob.
raja says
Roland,
The unruly mob and islam can never be satisfied. The more you give in the more they want. Any takers for confrontation?
David M says
Exactly, this was always going to happen, & it will happen in the future. Muslims will always be offended by something. Obviously Muslims in India are offended they are not in charge & running the country.
Infidel says
In solidarity w/ Kanhaiya Lal Teli, Hindu vendors in Karnataka have put up posters saying, “We are Hindus, we won’t tell the truth about you, so please don’t kill us”.
https://www.opindia.com/2022/06/karnataka-hindu-vendors-start-a-poster-campaign-to-protests-against-kanhaiya-lals-beheading
I love the sarcasam here
raja says
So telling the truth about islam is too hurtful to bear. The silent war machine of islam suddenly turns rambo.
In India people often say that NO religion teaches bad things. I hope that idea has changed for better.
Infidel says
Actually, on YouTube, quite a number of Hindus have been doing sessions disclosing what’s actually written in Qur’an and sunnah – in Hindi. The stuff we used to learn here in the 2000s and 2010s, they’re now getting up to speed. Good for them!
UVG says
This law (295A), which is one of the sections Nupur Sharma has been charged with came in the 1920s after an incident in Lahore.
Muslims at the time released pamphlets calling Sita Mata a prostitute and ridiculing Krishna.
In response a publisher printed a book called Rangeela Rasool, which laid threadbare the horny, depraved life story of Mohmmad as evidenced in the Hadith.
There were protests. Eventually the publisher was killed. But the courts instituted this law to make sure criticism of Islam was not allowed.
None of this is new, and none of it will ever change.
Food for thought.
Infidel says
But this law protects Hinduism as well. Under it, every panelist – muslim and Hindu – who mocked Mahadev – should have been booked and tossed in the slammer!
Yeah, I know that we don’t want blasphemy laws, but if it’s there to protect islam, it had better cover Hinduism as well!
Andrew Blackadder says
Just imagine the reaction of dumb ass muslims as well as her own Government if she had actually said something wrong, misinformed, insulting or derogatory against islam…. Just imagine..
The ancient adage that the truth hurts is striking in this case.
Maybe she moves to the UK as there are less crazy muslims there…OOPS, sorry.. what was I thinking??
Black Sabbath says
Mohammad and Quaran are single handedly responsible for what happened.
raja says
Black Sabbath,
Besides, Satan and the dumb followers of the two mentioned above are responsible too.
somehistory says
yes, raja. satan is the source…just as in the days of moloch, ba’al, and the other ‘god’s of the ancient people who believed they had the right to slaughter anyone for any reason…even made-up reasons…and on any grounds…even coffee grounds and their ‘god’ was happy and approving of their demonic actions.
the people doing the murders, the rapes, the rioting are the guilty ones and are responsible. they should be held responsible and since they are not, but are being given a license to do more killing and destruction, they will and the “court” and the “judges” can then blame this poor woman who told the Truth about the filth of their belief.
Westman says
A monumental mistake was made by allowing Muslims to remain in India during the partition of 1947. India is under stress both from within and from Pakistan.
“..The percentage of Muslims in India has risen from about 9.8% in 1951 to 14.2% by 2011.” – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_India
A capitulating, fearful, India will eventually be absorbed by Islam without some significant change.
Devasur says
If that happens it would be a disaster for the world. Which would swallow the whole of asia.
Infidel says
Some are predicting that this will happen in the next 10 years, if things like the NRC/NPR – forcibly removing Bangladeshi muslims from India – are not enacted. Another law they need to put in: any muslim who dares vitiate the communal atmosphere e.g. throwing stones at Hindu processions, desecrating Hindu idols or violating Hindu temples, et al automatically loses their right to vote, as well as right to own property
raja says
Infidel,
Though I am highly critical of India and its systems I strongly believe India will be last bastion to fall to islam if at all it ever falls. Indians are still normal people (unlike the West) and don’t hate self as indoctrinated by the Left. Eugenics are unheard of in India. The West with its evil elites and grossly inadequate mechanism to face or confront islam is doomed. Only time will tell if it can survive the onslaught of destructive ideologies of Left and islam. France is poor example though it flashes some hope every now and then. UK elites under Johnson have lost all commonsense. Other nations are no better. US is the only bright spot not because of its systems any better but guns still rules the roost. The Left cannot make much headway in US as long as there are guns in the hands of its public.
Bangladeshi immigrants used number around 10 to 15 million some 20 years back in Delhi. These serious issued are only used as foot ball by pols. When India cannot feed its own why import so many termites and implant enemies within?
We need honest leaders who mean business. May God grant that wish of India.
gravenimage says
Yes–I fear for India.
Devasur says
This is the Indian judiciary no different from Islamic sharia courts. In certain cases involving Muslims, it has even given permission to marry minors.
gravenimage says
Chilling, Devasur.
Infidel says
India’s AG, who is in his 90s, even offered to retire, but has been asked by the BJP government to stay on for 3 months. This government is so intellectually bankrupt that they can’t find a middle aged Indian constitutionalist to take his job
As for this story, this is the same Supreme Court that decided that marital rape is okay in India. Too bad that country has a party that has the numbers but not the cajones to impeach these judges
Infidel says
In other words, if Hindus decide to resurrect groups like the Bajrang Dal and resume their activities of assaulting muslims for things like violating their temples or insulting their deities, slaughtering cows, et al, that should be okay, right? After all, “grass has the ‘right’ to grow and the donkey has the right to eat”
Wellington says
I want to thank you again, Infidel, for the detailed information you provide here about central and south Asia on a regular basis. I consider you one of the most astute and knowledgeable commenters at JW—and not just on your regions of expertise but on everything. For the record.
Infidel says
Thank you, Wellington
raja says
Wellington,
You are also admired here like Infidel and there are countless others too.
somehistory says
as you often write, Wellington, I strongly second your reply to Infidel. He’s one very intelligent and informed person. I can’t say I understand all of the terms he uses…when they are English words and don’t know, I look up, but he knows of what he writes.
GreekEmpress says
Yep. I learn a lot from everybody here.
gravenimage says
I second your comment to Infidel, Wellington. Important information from India and the rest of south Asia.
James Lincoln says
Wellington,
Great comment regarding Infidel.
I learn much from him.
raja says
The judge in question has made a donkey of himself and he is being bombarded in social media from all sides.
Infidel says
Another Nupur Sharma 😈 comments on this decision here
https://www.opindia.com/2022/07/supreme-court-nupur-sharma-loose-tongue-hijab-verdict-karnataka-hc
somehistory says
good for her. hope she stays safe after being so brave and bold.
Infidel says
Actually, there are two Nupur Sharmas. Here is one of them (who works at OpIndia) interviewing the other
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZ0ur-i8o9w
somehistory says
I was remarking on the one who criticized the court for its ruling. Is that not the one who has a photo on the news’ site with the headline in the first link you provided?
Infidel says
The first link was an article written by OpIndia’s Nupur Sharma defending the Nupur Sharma that’s being hunted by everybody, and now by this judge. The second link was from a month ago, about the former interviewing the latter
somehistory says
Ok, I was not misunderstanding. Both ladies are brave to fight the flow. Hope they can both remain safe from those who can’t stand the Truth.
gravenimage says
Thanks for that link, Infidel.
Pray Hard says
Because apologizing to moslems has worked out so well for India over the centuries. Moron.
gravenimage says
+1
tim gallagher says
So, according to the gutless creatures in authority, the truth teller about Islam is “single-handedly responsible” for trouble from the viciously intolerant Muslims, who are so intolerant of any criticism of their evil cult. What a load of absolute bullshit. It is islam and its followers, who can’t cope with the light of truth being shone on their vile prophet’s evil nature, who are to blame for the trouble. The followers of other, more peaceful and rational religions, do not behave like rabid loonies when criticism is made of those religions. islam creates monsters who become immediately violent at any criticism of their evil cult. This cowardly caving and pandering to the irrational Muslim maniacs has to end. The truth about Islam needs to be told day in and day out and the whole evil religious ideology might some day, finally, collapse. What a great improvement for humanity that will be. Instead we get all these cowards, who can’t stand a bit of heat, caving in to the Muslim mob.
somehistory says
tim,
they are saying “she’s got the power”! Lots of power over a billion people.
Actually, she is being delivered up as a scape goat. Which comes from the Bible, where the goat was sent into the wilderness, symbolically carrying the sins of the people.
this court of pretend judges wants to sacrifice her so they can get back to the *normal* everyday riots and killings by mozlums, and the luring of their young girls by lusty males who will mistreat them to death.
Just as long as some other non mozlum Indian doesn’t talk truth about it.
tim gallagher says
Yes, somehistory, this cowardice seems to me to be all about an “anything for a peaceful life” type of gutlessness. The truth tellers always seem to be abandoned by the pathetic, totally gutless authorities. The Muslims carry on like maniacs and the authorities, yet again, cave in to the Muslims’s bullying. This is no way to deal with such an evil, violent ideology as Islam. If it keeps on going like this, the Muslims might win and I mean all around the world.
Fitna says
Agreed Tim and SH,
This is the face of cowardice and treason. It’s exactly the same in the West where (mostly Leftists) demonize critics of Islam rather than call out for Muslims bad behavior.
If the traitor’s narrative takes hold and becomes the mantra for the state (as it has in some places in India), then we’re all doomed.
It’s also giving permission for Muslims to go ahead and unleash their fury on opponents of Islam because it’s their fault for not behaving like cowed dhimmis.
Where has capitulation ever worked? All you’ll get is even more aggression and violence, esp. against the brave heroes speaking the truth about an evil ideology.
This dumbass judge has sacrificed the future for the present. He thinks his life is safe from Muslim violence because he threw the victim (Nupur Sharma) under the bus. But the reality is that not only will the Muslims get him one day anyways, he’s created millions of new enemies in the non-Muslim camp.
Muslims usually get complacent and assume when things are going their way, they are dominant. In reality they are a small minority in India and as the Hindus showed, once they get enraged, it’s the Muslims who eventually get genocided and/or chased out of their province. They’re just lucky that Hinduism isn’t anything like Islam or all the Muslims would’ve been exterminated a long time ago.
It’s easy for non-Muslims to feel overwhelmed by the raging Muslim mob, but don’t forget as long as you’re not in a Muslim country, it’s the non-Muslims who are the majority and Muslims are playing with fire if they should decide to wage war/jihad against us, it will backfire on them.
Had the judge remembered they outnumber Muslims 5 to 1 (or more) then maybe he would’ve had the stones to defend this poor woman.
tim gallagher says
I agree, Fitna. This judge has sacrificed the future for the present. As I said up above, these cowards all seem to be about “anything for a peaceful life” right now by caving in to the bullying Muslims mob, but it is not the way to deal with islam at all. I agree that this is also the gutless way that many authorities in western countries deal with islam and its violent bullying. They also cave in pathetically and, as you say, they throw the brave truth tellers under the bus.
James Lincoln says
tim gallagher says,
“This judge has sacrificed the future for the present.”
Succinctly and perfectly stated. My compliments.
tim gallagher says
Thanks James, but, to give credit where it’s due, I was just repeating Fitna’s wise comment that “the dumbass judge has sacrificed the future for the present” which I thought was spot on. All this gutless, soft behaviour, caving in to the violent, bullying Muslims, is a recipe for disaster in the future, that’s for sure.
Mark Spahn (West Seneca, NY) says
Is the reader expected to know what FIR means? It is explained nowhere in the quoted article.
https://www.helplinelaw.com/employment-criminal-and-labour/FIR/all-about-filing-a-complaint-and-lodging-fir%E2%80%99s.html
Infidel says
First Investigation Report. Can you guess what it does from that name?
Black Sabbath says
Dirty islamic rats are in the supreme court of India. The court wants to murder Nupur Sharma.
Fitna says
+10
probably Muslims or backstabbing non-Muslims, either way they’re our enemy.
gravenimage says
India’s Supreme Court: Nupur Sharma should apologize, is ‘single-handedly responsible for what is happening’
…………………..
What Sharma said is in fact also confirmed by all pious Muslims.
Fitna says
Exactly Graven, but when Muslims say Moh was a pedo, they call it beautiful. When a non-Muslim says the same thing, all hell breaks loose.
Muslims are insane hypocritical jackasses. We need Muslims like we need pandemics.
TruthSeeker says
Great discussion here. What i find really vomit inducing is the depths to which these humans have fallen morally. Talking about the two judges in question, one of them belongs to the ‘Parsi’ community who have historically been annihilated by the Islamic advance in a gruesome manner. They were reduced from a great civilization to refugees. The other judge is a ‘Hindu’ in namesake i guess. Hindus were subjected to unspeakable torture and violence as well in the past. Having said all that, it is just unbelievable how the descendants of two such communities can sell their souls and the respect for their own ancestors and their own roots without a trace of shame. Sadly, they are not the only ones. Many such people exist in the ecosystem . What hope is there for such a morally bankrupt society, where after behaving in this depraved manner, these two individuals are still ‘accepted’ by their closest social circle – their families and friends ? Does not one person in their relation tell them how low they have fallen? Does not even one family relation disown them? It is a big question in my opinion and as the answer to it seems yes, because these individuals are still enjoying life, apparently, reminds me again of how i have no hope for such a morally bankrupt society.