This would be easier to believe were mental illness not so often invoked, even in clear cases of jihad violence. Ahmed’s behavior toward Nicole could have been a manifestation of the culture of violence created in an environment where the society’s foundational holy text commands men to beat women from whom they “fear disobedience” (Qur’an 4:34). This is similar to the way in which that same foundational text’s calls for violence against unbelievers (2:191, 4:89, 9:5, 9:29, 47:4, etc.) are going to give rise to jihad violence.
“Alleged killer should be permanently in psychiatric prison,” translated from “Mutmaßlicher Killer soll dauerhaft in Psychoknast,” by Markus Langner and Karl Keim, Bild, March 7, 2023 (thanks to Medforth):
Leipzig – Almost three years after the murder of Nicole Z. († 25) at a railway site on Rosa-Luxemburg-Strasse in Leipzig, the suspect is finally in court. The public prosecutor’s office has now applied to the Leipzig Regional Court for the so-called “implementation of a security procedure” against a Bulgarian (22) who is said to have killed the woman.
According to the conviction of senior public prosecutor Ricardo Schulz, the then 19-year-old Ahmed N. killed a 25-year-old woman on the night of “March 15, 2020 and thus committed manslaughter.”
After the discovery of a female body on the railway premises in Leipzig, it is clear: the 25-year-old German was killed!
Passers-by discovered the body on March 15 on the railway premises. The dead had severe injuries to the upper body. A year later, prosecutors and police reported that a suspect could be placed in a psychiatric hospital.
The investigating authorities assume that Ahmed N. “committed the act while in a state of insanity.” Nevertheless, the aim is to prevent the man from walking free. The security procedure is intended to ensure that the alleged killer remains in the psychiatric ward for a longer period of time, Schulz said when asked about BILD.
However, the proceedings against another suspect were dropped. The Turk (35) could not be proven to have participated in the crime “with the certainty necessary for an indictment.”
kae says
Totally sane.
Just invested with hate and murderous intent.
Incompatible with civilisation.
Jim says
The left and do-gooders of a liberal persuasion do not want to condemn Islam or its holy books. So they take a therapeutic approach. Anyone who does what the texts command is mentally ill, not simply obeying the commandments in holy books that command obedience. If they condemned the whole theology of the religion, then of course they could not say that the faithful are good people. They would be forced to favor measures to slow immigration and block the practice of Islam in their country, which could lead to more violence. So the insanity judgment is the seemingly only explanation. Nothing should stand in the way of massive immigration to infidel countries. It assumes that most people are not insane, and thus locking a few insane people in institutions leaves the remaining majority with a good reputation as peaceful and compatible with the society where they are coming.
James Lincoln says
Jim,
As good an explanation as I’ve ever heard regarding the insanity defense for muslim migrants.
OLD GUY says
I think you have something there.
somehistory says
A Kingdom Hall of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Hamburg was the scene of the murder of four men, two women and an unborn baby, as well as the injury to others.
The murderer evidently killed himself as the police arrived and entered the building.
the only report I read which identified him, said something about “mental illness.”
The real mentally ill are being maligned by all of these people being excused because some lawyer or family member or other advocate, decides they didn’t know any better than to do what they did.
You don’t beat someone to death….or shoot them, strangle, drown, etc….while believing it’s the right thing to do. An insane person will not murder and then seek to justify his crime…because he didn’t realize it was wrong in the first place.
In my opinion, and I’ve read and studied these kinds of crimes for a long time, very few murders are committed by people who don’t know what they are doing is wrong.
How many murder another in the presence of a law enforcement officer? If such an action takes place, does the murderer just smile at the officer and appear to believe he acted in an acceptable way?
How many of these then appear in court and say “yes, I did it, because ….” and give some *reason* that would sound insane?
He should face death, not a long time being fed, housed and coddled.
Gary Wm Myers says
Jim is absolutely right and a Syrian psychologist agrees with him.
Islamic Insanity:
“I came to the absolute conviction that it is impossible…impossible…for any human being to read the biography of Mohammed and believe in it, and then emerge a psychologically and mentally healthy person.” – Syrian Psychiatrist Dr. Wafa Sultan
Gary Wm Myers says
Please disregard this comment.
Gary Wm Myers says
Syrian psychologist disagrees with Jim.
Islamic Insanity:
“I came to the absolute conviction that it is impossible…impossible…for any human being to read the biography of Mohammed and believe in it, and then emerge a psychologically and mentally healthy person.” – Syrian Psychiatrist Dr. Wafa Sultan