Are “Islamophobia” and anti-Semitism comparable? Reza Zia-Ebrahimi, senior lecturer in history at King’s College London, maintains that the answer is yes. Zia-Ebrahimi recently made this argument with a talk co-sponsored by Harvard University’s Saudi-funded Alwaleed Islamic Studies Program and titled, “When the Elders of Zion Relocated to Eurabia: Conspiratorial Racialisation in Anti-Semitism and Islamophobia.”
Speaking to a largely middle-aged crowd of about twenty, Zia-Ebrahimi contended that both The Protocols of the Elders of Zion—a Czarist forgery published circa 1903 alleging that Jews were plotting world domination—and Eurabia: The Euro-Arab Axis—a 2005 book by Bat Ye’or declaring the demographic and political transformation of Europe into “Eurabia”—employ conspiracy-theories that incite hatred for Jews and Muslims, respectively.
In his introduction, Zia-Ebrahimi credited the late Columbia University professor Edward Said with having originated this link by comparing Orientalism to anti-Semitism. Acknowledging that the “Israel-Palestine conflict” has “cast a long shadow on these discussions,” Zia-Ebrahimi advocated viewing anti-Semitism and “Islamophobia” as “manifestations of racism” in order to transcend these “divisions.” He described one camp as having “a tendency to be friendly to the state of Israel” and a “problem with Islamophobia,” while the other considers “Israel a colonial state” and believes in “Islamophobia.” The way to overcome these differences, he reasoned, is “to show that Jews and Muslims have been racialized.”
Zia-Ebrahimi further asserted that the two groups have suffered from conspiratorial bigotry, with the “world Jewish conspiracy” on one hand and its “Islamophobic corollary, ‘Islamicization,'” on the other. While conspiracists see Jews as seeking financial control, they see Muslims as “bent on our destruction” through “demographics,” he claimed.
While acknowledging that Eurabia and the Protocols “are two very different texts,” Zia-Ebrahimi maintained that they share certain qualities: representing “Jews and Muslims as a monolithic pack,” “supernatural reimagination” whereby the “most vulnerable sectors of society are perceived as almighty,” and claiming that “both Jews and Muslims benefit from a “European fifth column,” such as socialism or internationalism.
Zia-Ebrahimi focused the bulk of his talk on Eurabia, ostensibly because the Protocols have “been extensively studied.” Yet his hostility for Bat Ye’or and her book drove – and distorted – his presentation. Referring gratuitously to Egyptian-born Ye’or’s “European Jewish heritage,” he correlated her critique of Islam with “Lebanese Christian militias” and “Serbian ultranationalists.”
Zia-Ebrahimi excoriated Ye’or for associating Islam with “jihad,” “genital mutilation,” and “stoning,” and implying that its “principal urge is to subjugate Jews and Christians.” Eurabia, he proclaimed, “assumes all Muslims agree on sharia and want to impose it on everyone else” and above all, portrays a “diabolical Islamic civilization actively scheming destruction of Europe.”
Never once did Zia-Ebrahimi address the reality of such practices within Islam, nor the fact that Islamists advocate Islamic supremacism and are implacably hostile to Europe – seen as Christendom. In his eagerness to whitewash all things Islamist, Zia-Ebrahimi ignored the multiple terrorist attacks throughout Europe and the often-contorted Western reaction to Islamist aggression.
True to his biases, Zia-Ebrahimi lambasted a “coterie of counter-jihadi authors” such as Robert Spencer, Melanie Phillips, and Mark Steyn, and academics like Bernard Lewis, Niall Ferguson, Martin Gilbert, and Robert Wistrich for supporting and legitimizing Ye’or’s work. He savaged Ibn Warraq, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, and “others referred to as ‘Muslim dissenters'” for adopting the “same discourse” in order to “be salvaged” from their “Muslimness.” Falsely conflating valid criticism and introspection with hatred and violence, Zia-Ebrahimi described the 2011 Anders Behring Breivik killings in Norway as the natural outcome of this line of thought.
While Zia-Ebrahimi’s premise seemed at first intriguing, if flawed, his mention of the Protocols and alleged concern for anti-Semitism were in the end little more than a pretext for attacking Bat Ye’or, Eurabia, and critics of Europe’s lenient—some might say culturally suicidal—policies toward its growing Muslim population. In denying any legitimacy to these widespread concerns, and in failing to support his argument with hard evidence, Zia-Ebrahimi exposed as disingenuous his contention that anti-Semitism and “Islamophobia” are twin evils of equal force.
That Harvard would host an Islamist apologist masquerading as a champion of virtue exposes the intellectual weakness, duplicity, and true intents of scholars who charge their opponents with “Islamophobia.” Coined not to spur debate but to silence it, the efficacy of “Islamophobia’s” peddlers rests far more on the prestige of their platforms rather than the rigor of their thought. Their intellectual and moral comeuppance is long overdue.
Cinnamon Stillwell is the West Coast Representative for Campus Watch, a project of the Middle East Forum. She can be reached at stillwell@meforum.org. This article was originally written for Campus Watch and posted at the Algemeiner.
Jaladhi says
What a liar!1 Doesn’t he know that where as anti- semitism is real, Islamophobia is fake and unreal! But then what else can you expect from liars and deceivers!!
Andy says
Who Wants to Abolish the White Race?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_O8ZFBYdl_A
Andy says
Psychiatrist Who Accused Trump Of Instability Is A Fraud With No License To Practice
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxMbbYT23ig
Chand says
Dr. Bandy Lee of Yale is a fraud/ Really?
So what about the Stephanie Clifford news on the hush up money? Fake news I’m sure. So he’s not a crazy scumbag. Thank God! Just another run of the mill scumbag.
How many women was there in Trump’s life? He’s starting to rival Muhammad bin Abdullah! All powerful dudes have harems, right?
Anton says
Psychology and even psychiatry are mostly quasi-sciences. Their methodology is often based on pure demagoguery and speculations and ignores the basic scientific discovery of Korbinian Brodmann that even our behaviour can absolutely be explained by the morpho-functional structure of our brains – something absolutely scientific and falsifiable (according to “falsificationism” theory by Karl Popper). What psychologists and even psychiatrists say is very often unfalsifiable and hence unscientific.
gravenimage says
Chand, the idea that Trump has a Harem of kidnapped sex slaves is just silly.
gravenimage says
As for Dr. Brandy Lee, it does appear that her license to practice in her home state of Connecticut did lapse in 2015. This is not actually all that unusual if someone is either teaching or practicing in another state.
That being said, diagnosing supposed psychiatric illness on TV when the doctor has never once met the individual in question does tend to be extremely cheesy, and seldom has much to do with medicine at all. This with Trump is clearly political.
brenrod says
LOL achmed always wants to make an equation between the head chopping honor killers and the Nobel prize winners.
J D S says
London, America or wherever..seems “professors” today are so far left they are all “left-handed”.
Andy says
.J D S
Never let your “left” hand know, what your “right” hand is doing!
mortimer says
Agree with Jaladhi: Islamophobia is fake. However, KAFIR-O-PHOBIA is REAL.
Islam has a compulsory, essential doctrine called AL WALAA WAL BARAA which mandates hatred, hostility and war to be directed against the dirty kufaar ‘for the sake of Allah’.
Wellington says
Fallacious moral equivalency thinking on display once again. Only fools or worse will accept this rot.
StellaSaidSo says
Unfortunately, the supply of fools is abundant, especially in universities and mosques.
Wellington says
Indeed. And let’s not forget “other places” where fools abound. For instance, the Vatican, Number 10 Downing Street, in Ottawa in bunches and in the halls of the US Congress.
Yes, fools alone, let alone something even worse, i.e., those actively and knowingly functioning in full malevolence mode, e.g., a very large portion of the Muslim world and traditional authoritarian shits like Putin and the bastards running things in Beijing, make it deuce difficult to conclude that true freedom will survive.
A close call here to say the least. Surely.
gravenimage says
All grimly true.
Westman says
It seems as though there is a certain air of populism in academics these days. Like a politician, some academics seem to be “testing the wind” to determine what will get the most traction in certain “itching ears”. Tenure is the prize for pitching the leftist propaganda.
gravenimage says
I’m not sure how populist hard core Leftism is, Westman. Despite its gloss of condescending concern for the poor, it tends to be overall more elitist.
Westman says
If anti-Semitism and “Islamophobia” are equivalent why aren’t Jews stabbing Muslims yet Muslims are stabbing, bombing, and running over Jews?
More lefty-muslim propaganda from the educational fountain of taqiyya.
gravenimage says
Spot on.
Kay says
Oh, I am surrounded by fools. This false equivalency is promoted in many quarters and few care to think much about it so blithely accept it.
elee says
Islam is Amalek
MFritz says
One of those “scholars” who research only in this one field and in this special “mindset” to provide politicians with “arguments”.
Michael Copeland says
“Eurabia” Ebrahimi proclaimed, “assumes all Muslims agree on sharia and want to impose it on everyone else.””
This assertion implies, falsely, that muslims have an option, and that their “agreement” matters.
Muslims have no option. Their agreement neither matters nor is sought.
“It is not fitting for a Believer, man or woman, when a matter has been decided by Allah and His Messenger to have any option about their decision:”
That is Koran 33:36, part of Islamic law, with vigilante-style killing the penalty for denying it.
Muslims have no choice about Sharia, and are INSTRUCTED to impose it on everyone else, by violence if necessary – “by persuasion or by force”, as Ibn Khaldun explained.
“Does Islam or does it not force people by the power of the sword to submit….? Yes!”, explained Osama bin Laden.
Ebrahimi belittles “Eurabia” as “employing conspiracy-theories that incite hatred for ….Muslims”.
This is simply disingenuous and slanderous. It is conflation. Criticism is not hatred.
In contrast, hatred of Jews by muslims is COMMANDED in the Koran, and INSTRUCTED in mosques. See “Islam Instructs Hatred: Muslims Speak”:
https://libertygb.org.uk/news/islam-instructs-hatred-muslims-speak
Perhaps the “largely middle-aged crowd of about twenty” were not impressed.
Peter says
The biggest threat is Islamic:
I N F I D E L P H O B I A
Jack Diamond says
He is speaking to the kuffar, who take it for granted the Protocols are a fiction created by Jew-haters,
which he then equates with the work of Bat Ye’or and the counter-jihad, for the sole purpose of discrediting them as equally fictitious and fantastical and driven by a similar phobic irrational hatred.
Why? Because he says so. Not because of the facts on the ground (the overwhelming confirmation of “Eurabia”) but by the false equivalence of two vastly different works, one based in fantasy and one based upon grim reality.
He does not mention how seriously the Protocols are taken in the Muslim world (and possibly by himself, since he is clearer a practiced liar). Nor is he about to lecture fellow Muslims about the absurdity of the Protocols and to denounce the hatred of Jews in an upcoming tour of Muslim countries. His one mission is to discredit as absurd those speaking the truth about Islam–the purpose of jihad, and the purpose of hijrah invasion (both canonical Islam) by comparing them to something they (the kuffar, not the Muslims) consider hateful and despicable, if not outright insane.
He is waging jihad himself, encouraging the kaffirs to intellectually disarm themselves, while they physically disarm themselves.
LeftisruiningCanada says
Right on.
Eurabia: The Euro-Arab Axis is loaded to the max with citations and references of real things you can go and check.
The “protocols’ don’t have many footnotes.
This guys trying to be the next T Ramadan or something?
(Perhaps in his spare time anyway)
gravenimage says
Important points, Jack.
Ray Jarman says
The idea of Eurabia is ludicrous unless there is a goal of destroying Europe. I think that the west should become aware of Hegel’s warning about not upholding their long fought for freedoms and rights, ““…Law, Morality, Government and they alone, are the positive reality and completion of Freedom. Freedom of a law and limited order is mere caprice which finds its exercise in the sphere of limited and particular desires.” This freedom of law is exactly what Zia-Ebrahimi is preaching. He seems to say that Muslim’s should be permitted to invade Judo Christian civilizations by stealth and over time become the rulers.
He seems to think that the Jews being able to use their hard work to build wealth is wrong. Only through individual wealth can a nation become wealthy. I would love to have the opportunity to have a one on one with this Zia-Ebrahimi for I would ask him questions as to why has the Middle-East been so ravaged by internecine for centuries while the west has been able move forward even though it has had to overcome wars by princes and usurpers who wanted more power and their neighbor’s wealth. The west has been enriched by great philosophical minds like Hegel, Rousseau, Kant, Hobbs and Locke who all preached peace and love of their fellow man and how best to establish governments subject to the people that allow for differing opinions by these people. I am personally afraid that the west will end up like the protagonist in O’Neil’s “The Hairy Ape,” who enters the cage with the ape because he sees himself similarly and is killed. We must learn exactly what Islam is and what it advocates and by force will attain its goal of complete subjugation of the West. Hans Morgenthau described the western man best, “Man is born to seek power, yet his actual condition makes him a slave to the power of others.” There seems to be no restraint on religious leaders in the preaching of the Qu’ran or Hadith.
LeftisruiningCanada says
In a more wordy and academic fashion he would probably do what a certain muslim commenter here does, and simply blame the West for all the problems in the islamic nations.
Either that, or claim that they were not islamic enough. Possibly due to western interference with the obviously perfect system that the koran expounds.
You know the drill.
(Did Rousseau really preach peace, love and freedom?)
Ray Jarman says
Rousseau most certainly did preach love, peace and freedom. I used to believe that Thomas Hobbes had the most influence upon our framers, especially John Adams and Thomas Jefferson, but after rereading their writings in addition to John Locke, I think that all three were extremely important. My only problem with Rousseau in the past and especially in college was that his preaching of pure democracy in his “General Will” was the root cause for the Athenian demise against Sparta where not even Pericles could bring everyone together but now after reading articles he wrote as arguments against rivals, I see him in a different light.
gravenimage says
Broadly agree, Ray.
Richard says
Harvard is now a university of Gleichschaltung….nothing more, nothing less.
jack cade says
Time for John Galt to reappear.
gravenimage says
I am John Galt.
LeftisruiningCanada says
“Je suis”, surely 😉
gravenimage says
Je suis John Galt works, too… 🙂
Terry Gain says
Off the top of my head I can think of at least 6 million reasons why this whining Muslim is dad wrong.
Terry Gain says
Off the top of my head I can think of at least 6 million reasons why this whining Muslim is dead wrong.
Garfield says
+1
Dov Berrol says
Muslim culture is the “me too” culture of the world. They remind of the insecure narcissistic at a party who constantly has to one up everyone to make themselves feel better. Everything about Islam is “me too” – right from the theology in the Koran to the whining about being as persecuted as Jews and minorities far far more in danger than them and far far smaller in numbers than them.
I really think psychiatric professionals can add “Islamic Personality Disorder” to their Cluster “B” classification of mental disorders which included Borderline and Narcissistic. They really DO need psychiatric help.
Terry Gain says
I think it is more accurate to describe Islam as the You Too Culure as in you too Abraham and you too Jesus. You are Muslims. Islam is resolute and the whining is a disingenuous form of Jihad. They are the least oppressed people on earth and the whining, as for example comparing themselves to Jews, is intended to keep it that way.
Terry Gain says
I should also have said that Muslims believe that a refusal to accept Islam is discrimination and telling the truth about Muhammad is blasphemy.
gravenimage says
Professor Claims Anti-Semitism and ‘Islamophobia’ Are Equal Threats
………………………………
Never mind that the “Protocols” are a Jew-hating forgery, and that Bat Y’eor’s book is entirely factual. As these creeps would have it, the truth is no defense.
And good to see Cinnamon Stillwell contributing here again.
Andy says
Viktor Orban: Will there be a Christian Europe?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2oU3rBgPMY
VaeVictis says
Muslims constantly call for all Jews to be killed. However you never hear of Jews calling for all Muslims to be killed. That says it all.
gravenimage says
Yep.
Terry Gain says
Jews don’t call for ANY Muslims to be killed for any reason, including not accepting Judaism.
Garfield says
I would like that statement to be a billboard in times square.
Enough nonsense, taquiyya and lies. Islam is a supremacist death cult. Its run like a mafia. It keeps adherents stupid. Its time for the world to reject it…their entire made up book of garbage written by a child rapist and stop the creeping menace of sharia politics.
Cheer Bear Girl says
Islam calls for the oppression of non believers. Muslims are hardly victims, more like victimizers.
krishna says
Jews do not have that level of privilege. Anywhere outside Israel, jews are an extreme minority (we are at most 2% of the population in the US and far less everywhere else) and a rather helpless one. Persecuting Muslims will not go unanswered by countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Pakistan. It’s a blessing to have such numbers.
There was no attempt to exterminate Muslims worldwide and in a span of 6 years, 1 out of 3 Muslim wasn’t murdered en mass. Muslims were never subjected to blood libels or pogroms for deicide.
I am happy for my Muslim cousins in Abraham that their history was not dark like the Jewish one, I wouldn’t wish our suffering on anyone.
No, Islamaphobia is not Anti-semitism, and thank Mercy for that. Because no one deserves what Jews went through.
gravenimage says
I understand your points, krishna, but I do not envy Muslims–they are burdened with the hideous creed of Islam, which they can never safely leave, and there are only so many Muslims because of a concerted campaign of conquest and oppression.
Jews also have a great deal to be proud of as a people–Muslims, not so much…
Ibrahim itace muhammed says
Hate campaigns against Islam and muslims started by the church in the West, which led to those brutal crusade wars. Thereafter, Christian evangelists resorted to intellectual warefare in the form of orientalism to present false informations about Islam in the West. when It failed, the West headed by evil united states sponsored misguided Terrorist groups to justify hate propagandas against Islam. Now that such idiot terrorists are defeated, what Will be the next strategy ? The Satan (holy spirit) is always ready to tempt mithraist christians to make mischiefs
StellaSaidSo says
JW’s resident clown returns, with more of his unique pearls of nonsense.
I see that you’re a tad shaky on the history of the Crusades, Ibby old chap. The Crusades were a defensive action, in response to centuries of Islamic predation in Christian lands. Research is not your forte, is it? Much easier to simply believe the b/s you hear in the mosque. No intellectual rigour needed for that, eh?
And another thing: Islamic terrorism started 1400 years ago, centuries before the founding of the United States. ‘I have been made victorious through terror’, the foul paedophile rapist murdering swine Mohammed proudly announced. Perhaps he should have added, for your benefit, ‘and I didn’t need a cent of funding from the United States’. Blaming all Islamic terrorism on the US is as absurd as any US support of it is reprehensible. You will note that under the current US administration, funds are being withdrawn from countries which engage in terrorism. I’m sure that you are very grateful to President Trump for this.
mortimer says
Agree with Stella. I don’t think Ibrahim realizes how foolish he actually appears while trying to explain Islam to people who have already read the Islamic trilogy (Sira, Bukhari and Koran) and cannot be so tricked by him.
BTW, there is nothing sinister about Orientalism. It is a scientific attempt to uncover the hidden burned and buried sources of Islam’s primary writings and to discover ‘what really happened’.
When archeology and the Islamic source texts WILDLY DISAGREE, we must assume that the archeology is the key to understanding and that the source texts are merely self-aggrandizing propaganda mandated by the caliphs to support their rival dynasties.
Ibrahim itace muhammed says
Stellasaidso, It is not true. Has savage mad devil Trump suspended funding and arming fascist evil zionist state of Israel and evil saudi monarchs Who funded directly and coordinated world terrorism from wahhabists (the root) to Isis ?
StellaSaidSo says
Ibby old chap, you’re not paying attention. POTUS has withdrawn funding from both Pakistan and Iran, just days ago. No doubt there will be withdrawal of $$ from other hostile players as time goes on.
As has been pointed out to you before, but you refuse to be honest about it, your hatred of Israel is not about Israel, but about JEWS. You hate Jews, don’t you Ibby? Why is that? Because a hysterical book written by a raving desert lunatic in the 7thC tells you to. The Jews are entitled to the land of Israel. They were there long before the raving desert lunatic invented the ludicrous nonsense called Islam. And if they weren’t under constant attack from raving desert lunatics, they would not need to fire a shot.
Ibrahim itace muhammed says
stellasaidso, no, you are wrong. Evîl united states funded and armed terrorist groups from wahhabists (the origin )to Isis through evil zionist state of Israel and evil saudi monarchs. Has savage mad devil Trump suspended any cooperation with any of these factors of world terrorism ? Instead mad devil Trump is now religious bringing these two axis of evil closer to evil united states.
mortimer says
Ibrahim, I would like to remind you of the words of Jesus. Mark 3:28-30: “Truly I tell you, all sins and blasphemes will be forgiven for the sons of men. But whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven, but is guilty of an eternal sin. He said this because they [the Pharisees] were saying, ‘He has an evil spirit’.”
You are blaspheming the Holy Spirit frequently in this forum.
Ibrahim itace muhammed says
mortimer, Holy spirit does not exist. That concept of holy spirit as aspect of God representing His breath or voice is a pagan idea from mithraism inspired by thé Satan. The only spirits are Angels, jinns or demons and Satan Who revolted and was cursed.
Champ says
Wow there are no shortage of lies being written by the imbecile …
Very tiresome.
StellaSaidSo says
Ibrahim, if you reject paganism, then you must reject Islam for its pagan elements.
Your Mohammed was hardly an original thinker. The Koran is borrowed from earlier sources, including Judaism, Christianity, and PAGANISM. For example, ‘Allah’ was a moon god – one of hundreds of desert djinns.
Again you demonstrate your appalling lack of knowledge about the very subject for which you claim superior expertise.
Ray Jarman says
This is the most absurd comment I have seen on JW. I would like to know where you were provided with such nonsense. Maybe you can explain why the pernicious murdering pedophilic cult attacked and slaughtered the inhabitants of Aleppo, Antioch and every other great city from Mecca to Cairo and beyond. The horde pillaged its way even as far as Tanzania and Nigeria leaving the lands with rotten corpses everywhere. The First Crusade did not occur until every avenue of compromise with the cult had been extinguished in 1095 to gain access to the Holy Lands. These once great cities and states had been turned to rubble and the people and their great thirst for knowledge had been decimated. Not one place on the face of the earth has this despicable cult ever converted the local population except through the most violent of means where as Christ and his disciples like Paul and Peter converted by demonstrating the goodness of Christianity and while there have been occasions for men in the name of Christ have done evil, it was in contravention of Jesus’ very teachings of love and charity.
Maybe you can explain the reason for the Fulani and Boko Haram’s slaughter of Christians and even other Muslims who are not Islamic enough. The Fulani in Nigeria constantly slaughter whole villages for no reason other than that the people are Christian. Muslims in Uganda and Kenya ravaging and raping villagers. Tell me where these acts are being carried out Christians. In India the cult is constantly reaping havoc upon its neighbors and in Bangladesh they are killing Christians and Buddhist daily. I could go on but I hope you are capable of receiving the message.
Ibrahim itace muhammed says
Ray Jarman, It means filthy mithraist christians carried out genocidal killings of muslims during crusade wars pursant to mithraist Bible in Samuel 15:3 in response to refusal by Muslims to allow christians access to holy places to worship the Satan (holy spirit)? That is exactly religious war christian liars have been telling us does not exist in christianity. Idiots !!
Andy says
Ibrahim itace muhammed do you come from a s**THOLE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0XajmjPtuU
Ray Jarman says
Ibrahim, I have no idea what you are talking about as 1 Samuel is when he was a young boy and 2 Samuel 15-3 is a list people. Besides, this was centuries before Jesus Christ was born. Maybe I have studied the wrong history books but I don’t believe so as my BS was in Government Administration with a Masters in International Relations and one could call either simply Political Science/History. I am beginning to believe that you are just trying to gain attention and I am responding this time but believe me, not again.
StellaSaidSo says
Great post, Ray Jarman.
But all our efforts to educate are, of course, wasted. We are dealing with a ‘culture’ whose sole purpose is to wipe out the competition. Islam is breeding, indoctrinating, and arming, while we are trying to debate, negotiate, accommodate and tolerate. Just as we did, all those centuries ago.
Had the First Crusade happened a lot sooner, we might not have needed another.
gravenimage says
The vile Ibrahim itace muhammed wrote:
Hate campaigns against Islam and muslims started by the church in the West, which led to those brutal crusade wars.
……………………………….
In other words, Christians noticed that Muslims were oppressing and slaughtering Christians, and saying so is “hate”, as he sees it. He has also said that Infidels have no right to defend against violent Jihad, which is what the Crusades were about.
More:
Thereafter, Christian evangelists resorted to intellectual warefare in the form of orientalism to present false informations about Islam in the West.
……………………………….
Notice that, as previously, Ibrahim itace muhammed does not say what “false informations” were supposedly told about Islam.
Actually, a lot of “Orientalism” was quite pro-Islam, and rather foolishly romantic about Muslims.
More:
when It failed, the West headed by evil united states sponsored misguided Terrorist groups to justify hate propagandas against Islam.
……………………………….
Ibrahim itace muhammed has said before that terrorist groups were created by the West to make Islam look bad, and yet he himself agrees with them on every point–that Infidels who do not accept Islam can be raped and murdered, and that there is nothing more glorious than waging violent Jihad against the “filthy” Christians. He has also said that he is looking forward to taking part in genocide against the Jews.
So–how does he actually disagree with Jihad terrorists? He doesn’t. They just represent rival Jihad groups to his own.
More:
Now that such idiot terrorists are defeated, what Will be the next strategy ? The Satan (holy spirit) is always ready to tempt mithraist christians to make mischiefs
……………………………….
How are they “defeated”? Ibrahim itace muhammed hopes we haven’t noticed that his coreligionists continue to rape and murder us every day.
More:
Stellasaidso, It is not true. Has savage mad devil Trump suspended funding and arming fascist evil zionist state of Israel and evil saudi monarchs Who funded directly and coordinated world terrorism from wahhabists (the root) to Isis ?
……………………………….
Of course, the idea that it is just Saudi Arabia that is funding Jihad terror is absurd. This is mainstream Islam, as Ibrahim itace muhammed himself affirms.
Moreover, President Trump has put Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and the “Palestinian” Territories on notice, and will–hopefully–cut aid to those vicious Shari’ah states.
More:
stellasaidso, no, you are wrong. Evîl united states funded and armed terrorist groups from wahhabists (the origin )to Isis through evil zionist state of Israel and evil saudi monarchs.
……………………………….
Once again, Ibrahim itace muhammed is making the ludicrous claim that Jihad terrorists are “Zionists”, even though he himself has lauded Jihadists raping, enslaving, and murdering unbelievers and waging violent Jihad.
More:
Has savage mad devil Trump suspended any cooperation with any of these factors of world terrorism ? Instead mad devil Trump is now religious bringing these two axis of evil closer to evil united states.
……………………………….
This is common with dishonest Muslims–claiming they are against terrorism, then actually tipping their hands that what they actually mean by this is that they are opposed to America or Israel *defending* themselves against Jihad terrorism.
More:
mortimer, Holy spirit does not exist.
……………………………….
Well, *that* is interesting, since Ibrahim itace muhammed has many times claimed that he saw the Holy Spirit while hanging out in a Christian graveyard in Nigeria.
But then, Muslims have never cared about being logically consistent in any way.
More:
That concept of holy spirit as aspect of God representing His breath or voice is a pagan idea from mithraism inspired by thé Satan. The only spirits are Angels, jinns or demons and Satan Who revolted and was cursed.
……………………………….
Of course, the concept of the Holy Spirit has nothing to do with Mithraism, and much predates Christianity’s acquaintance with that cult in Roman lands. Why is Ibrahim itace muhammed so ignorant? Wait…don’t answer that question…
More:
Ray Jarman, It means filthy mithraist christians carried out genocidal killings of muslims during crusade wars pursant to mithraist Bible in Samuel 15:3 in response to refusal by Muslims to allow christians access to holy places to worship the Satan (holy spirit)? That is exactly religious war christian liars have been telling us does not exist in christianity. Idiots !!
……………………………….
Where to start? There was no genocide against Muslims during the Crusades.
And if Christianity predates Mithraism–as it does–then the Book of Samuel from the Old Testament or Torah does even more so. The Book of Samuel dates to around 630–540 BC.
Further, his claim that the ancient Amalekites were Muslim is utterly absurd, as is the implication that they were fought by Christians.
Why are so many pious Muslims completely ignorant about Judaism, Christianity, and history? Because if it is not in the tedious and ugly Qur’an, they consider knowledge of no use.
gravenimage says
Some fine replies to the appalling Ibrahim itace muhammed.
Ray Jarman says
Thanks to all.
Bert says
They are in fact the same. Anti-semite, Islamaphobe, Homophobe, Xenophobe, Bigot, Racist, Sexist, and a long list of other words are nothing more than Communist tools to make you shut up.
Stand up and Speak out.
Wake up!
ronyvo says
No comparison what so ever. Islam is SIMPLY criminal. The book which guide the Muslims is very clearly the Koran is a filthy diabolical inhumane criminal piece of garbage. Any country allows it in its land is doomed.
mortimer says
In point of fact, there is no mandate within Judaism for world domination and no plot for world dominance would gain traction among Jews ever, since the majority of Jews would vehemently oppose such a proposal is errant foolishness.
HOWEVER, Islam has a clear mandate for world dominance:
-definition of jihad from the Shorter Encyclopaedia of Islam, page 89, [7]: DJIHAD, holy war. The spread of Islam by arms is a religious duty upon Muslims in general…it must continue to be done until the whole world is under the rule of Islam.”
-The Caliph fights all other peoples until they become Muslim …”(The “Reliance of the Traveler,the Classic Manual of Islamic Sacred Law, p.599)
Furthermore, two copies of a secret manual of the Muslim Brotherhood plan to take over North America were discovered: “An Explanatory Memorandum On the General Strategic Goal for the Group In North America.”
This document (Explanatory Memorandum) of the Muslim Brotherhood is a genuine and real as the Protocols of Zion were spurious and false.
mortimer says
In a debate with Stephen Coughlin (late American army intelligence), Reza Zia-Ebrahimi would be shot down in flames in a matter of minutes. Major Coughlin studied the minutiae of all the matters the Persian writer raises and he has an unparalleled understanding of the MILITARY-DOCTRINAL ASPECT of jihad.
Equally devastating for Reza Zia-Ebrahimi would be to ATTEMPT to debate Robert Spencer on the subject since Robert Spencer is exceedingly well informed on the teaching of the Iranian mullahocracy and on their plans for world dominance.
The thesis of Reza Zia-Ebrahimi falls apart because all branches of Islam share a common doctrine of WORLD CONQUEST and WORLD DOMINANCE of Islam through jihad-warfared directed against disbelievers.
Reza Zia-Ebrahimi fails because Islam itself is intrinsically militant and Judaism is not.
StellaSaidSo says
Interesting and informative posts, Mortimer. Agree re ‘Explanatory Memorandum’. I try to get people to read this, as it is short enough for even the most challenged Lefty. Stephen Coughlin’s ‘Catastrophic Failure’ (788 pages) takes a little more commitment. The man is truly awesome for the breadth and depth of his knowledge. I recommend his Red Pill Briefs (lectures) on YouTube if you haven’t seen them.
gravenimage says
Thanks, Mortimer.
Lydia Church says
Anti-Semitism is based on hate and is not justified.
There is no rational definition of ‘islamophobia,’ because that implies that there is some irrational and unfounded fear or dislike of islam. But islam by its very nature inspires fear and that intentionally. And rationally, it is normal to be afraid of the fruits of islam. Because of that, we don’t like it. We also see these acts being carried out in terrorist attacks against innocent victims.
Now I am not afraid because I fear no man or what he can do to me, I fear God alone.
But I still hate islam.
And the dislike of islam is totally justified, the hatred of Jews is totally unjustified.
Lydia Church says
And then there is another point.
The people and the ideology. One is about people; the Jews, the other is about islam, an ideology.
In Christianity we have a saying that keeps things in perspective:
Love the sinner (person), but hate the sin or false religion.
One of the best ways of loving your enemies is by informing them that they are in danger regarding one or both of these; sin or false teachings. Even sinners rescue their mules from falling into a ditch! It is only hypocrites who do not warn about these dangers.
Me says
Mr Spencer: it is obvious that the west is historically ignorant to how Islam spread all over the middle east. They cannot/will not see the threat and think that they are immune. Therefore videos showing how non-Muslim countries BECAME Muslim, are essential. Also to show how Islam affected their lives.. how equality and law and art and music and culture, all stopped and disappeared. Do you have any such videos in the pipeline?
Robert Spencer says
No, but I’m finishing up a comprehensive book entitled The History of Jihad From Muhammad to ISIS.
FYI says
Really?And what does the taqqiya-merchant prof have to say about the demonic, koranic anti-Semitism of allah and his muslim followers.
Perhaps he should read what the koran says about the Jews…..